Faces or Facts? Experimental Evidence on Time Pressure, Information Costs, and Gender Bias in Electoral Choice
How to cite
Marín, Alejandra; Canales, Andrea; Bahamonde, Héctor. 2025. "Faces or Facts? Experimental Evidence on Time Pressure, Information Costs, and Gender Bias in Electoral Choice." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017574. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17574-1.3
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project seeks to analyze how physical attributes, such as perceived dominance, and the policy proposals of candidates interact in electoral decisions, considering gender and information conditions (time pressure and access costs) as factors that structure biases and stereotypes in political behavior.
The research stems from evidence that when voters face cognitive or informational limitations, they tend to use heuristic shortcuts, such as physical appearance, to simplify their decision. Previous studies demonstrate that traits such as attractiveness, facial dominance, and perceived emotions influence the evaluation of candidates, and that these effects can differ between men and women, reproducing leadership and gender stereotypes.
The study proposes four main hypotheses: (1) under time pressure, the influence of physical attributes increases; (2) when accessing information is costly, voters prioritize visual cues; (3) female candidates are evaluated more by their appearance than male candidates, especially under conditions of low information; and (4) there is a tendency to value proposals from candidates of the same gender more highly.
The research uses a quantitative experimental design, specifically the implementation of a conjoint experiment, a design widely used in the social sciences to identify the relative weight of multiple attributes in individual decisions. In this study, 462 participants (men and women aged 18 to 65, neither residents nor citizens of Colombia) will be presented with a series of candidate profile pairs containing randomized information about their gender, age, ideology, physical attractiveness, and policy proposals. The profiles will include a photograph (obtained from the ballot papers of the last four local elections in Colombia) and a brief summary of ideas compiled from actual campaign manifestos and condensed using IA.
The sample will be divided into three groups: a control group, a group subjected to time pressure, and a group with information access costs. Through this experimental manipulation, we will estimate how information conditions modify the weight of physical and gender attributes in electoral decisions. All participants will sign informed consent forms, the anonymity of responses will be guaranteed, and the data will be used exclusively for academic purposes.
The study aims to understand whether voters rely more on appearance when they feel rushed or when obtaining information is costly, and whether these effects differ for male and female candidates and voters. By doing so, the research seeks to shed light on how information constraints and gender-related stereotypes shape political decision-making. The findings will contribute to a better understanding of how real-world voting conditions influence electoral choices and democratic representation.
Intervention
The study implements a randomized online survey experiment. Participants are asked to make a series of voting choices between pairs of hypothetical mayoral candidates. Each candidate profile includes a photograph and a brief summary of policy positions. Candidate attributes, such as gender, age category, political ideology, and facial characteristics related to perceived dominance, are randomly varied across profiles.
Participants are randomly assigned to one of three experimental conditions:
- Control: Participants view candidate profiles with photographs and brief policy descriptions and make voting choices without additional constraints.
- Time Pressure: Participants view the same candidate profiles but must make each voting decision within a fixed and limited amount of time, indicated by a visible countdown timer.
- Information Cost: Participants may access more detailed policy information for each candidate by clicking an additional option. Accessing this information requires completing an extra step, making information more costly to obtain.
All participants complete the same number of choice tasks. After completing the voting tasks, participants answer short follow-up questions regarding perceived time pressure, perceived information costs, and their decision-making experience. No real political actors are involved, and the intervention does not include persuasion or behavioral manipulation beyond the randomized presentation of decision environments
Experimental design
The study uses a randomized online survey experiment with a between-subjects design at the participant level and a within-subjects design at the choice-task level. Participants are randomly assigned to one of three experimental conditions: a control condition, a time pressure condition, or an information cost condition.
All participants complete a series of paired candidate choice tasks. In each task, participants choose between two hypothetical mayoral candidates. Each candidate profile includes a photograph and a brief summary of policy positions. Candidate attributes, such as gender, age category, political ideology, and facial characteristics related to perceived dominance are randomly assigned across profiles and across choice tasks.
The experimental conditions differ only in the decision environment. In the control condition, participants make choices without additional constraints. In the time pressure condition, participants must make each choice within a fixed and limited amount of time, indicated by a visible timer. In the information cost condition, participants may access more detailed policy information by completing an additional step, making information more costly to obtain.
The order of choice tasks and the pairing of candidate profiles are randomized. All participants complete the same number of choice tasks. Data collection is conducted online using an external survey provider, and participants are not exposed to real political campaigns or actors.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.