Choice architecture, sorting, and availability of stem cell donors

How to cite

Ndiaye, Yero Samuel; Stange, Till; Wiesen, Daniel; Kampkoetter, Patrick. 2026. "Choice architecture, sorting, and availability of stem cell donors." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017570. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17570-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yero Samuel Ndiaye* , Till Stange , Daniel Wiesen , Patrick Kampkoetter

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017570
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17570-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-01-14 – 2029-06-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17570

Abstract

The unit of intervention is a school drive, i.e., a stem cell registration event at a high school or vocational school. After a presentation by trained volunteers, students can register in the stem cell registry via a test kit (buccal swab) and by providing the required information needed upon registration (contact details). Directly after registration, the donor receives a confirmation email.

For the intervention, students are randomly allocated to treatment and control group schools (equal split). For the control group, the standard registration protocol at a regular school drive applies.

The treatment group receives the standard protocol with an additionally communicated exit option (opt-out) during the donor drive, informing them that they will have the option to opt out of the registry when receiving the confirmation email. The default communication in the confirmation email of the treatment group is to stay in the registry, but it will also contain a link to an exit landing page. By clicking on this link, treatment participants have the opportunity to actively exit the registry (opt-out).

To understand potential heterogeneity in responses to the intervention, we run a short digital follow-up survey with subjects from the control and treatment groups. The follow-up survey contains questions on subjects’ motivations to join the registry, economic and social preferences, personality traits, and informedness about the extraction methods. We also aim to survey individuals who choose not to register at on-site events, using equivalent items and questions to understand their reasons for not joining the registry.

Additionally, the survey will include questions on factors such as the role of peer comparisons in the decision to register. We will ask participants about the registration behavior of their peers (e.g., how many of their friends registered or did not register) and explore beliefs regarding their own and others’ actual availability for donation. If possible, we will incorporate incentivized measures to elicit beliefs about social norms related to peer pressure and availability, in order to classify types of individuals. Moreover, we plan to randomly vary the feedback about the impact of peer influence to examine how this information shapes participants’ responses about their own availability and willingness to donate. If possible, we will also include questions allowing us to analyze how additional factors would have influenced the likelihood of registration or the perceived trust in the organization.

Intervention

Opt-out intervention designed to increase stem cell donor recruitment and availability for confirmatory typing.

Experimental design

The study is conducted during stem cell donor registration drives at high schools and vocational schools in Germany. The unit of randomization is the school drive. Schools are randomly assigned (1:1) to a control group, which follows the standard registration protocol, or to a treatment group, which follows the same protocol but with an explicitly communicated opt-out option. In treatment schools, students are informed during the drive that they will have the possibility to opt out of the registry upon receiving the confirmation email, which includes a link to an exit landing page.

A short digital follow-up survey is administered to participants in both groups (and to non-registrants at the same events) to document heterogeneity in behavioral responses and to link stated motivations and beliefs to observed registration and opt-out behavior. The experimental contrast compares the standard protocol to the same protocol with a salient post-registration opt-out option.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-generated random assignment, stratification based on school district, school type, and partner schools (i.e., regularly participating schools in drives).
Randomization unit
School-level
Clusters
800 schools
Observations
55,000 students (potential donors)
Arms
65 students per school, 400 school per treatment
Primary outcomes
Registration rates (1), use of opt-out (exit) option (2)
Secondary outcomes
Actual CT availability (1), Survey completion rates (2) knowledge about extraction methods (3), subjects' motivations to join (not join) the registry (4), role of peer comparisons in the decision to register (5)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords