Bricks to Blocks: Information and Coordination Challenges for Transitioning to a Cleaner Building Technology
How to cite
Sulaiman, Munshi; Hassan, Hashibul; Hossain, Md Mohsin; Kamal, Rohini.
2026. "Bricks to Blocks: Information and Coordination Challenges for Transitioning to a Cleaner Building Technology." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017559.
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17559-1.4
Download:
BibTeX
·
RIS— for reference managers without a browser
translator. Zotero and most
others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
Traditional fired clay bricks dominate the construction sector in Bangladesh, contributing significantly to air pollution and topsoil degradation. Although cleaner, non-fired alternatives like concrete blocks exist, their adoption remains low. This study evaluates whether reducing information frictions and capacity constraints can accelerate adoption of blocks. We implement a three-arm cluster randomized controlled trial across 66 upazilas (sub-districts) in 22 districts (total baseline sample N = 3,056 respondents). Upazilas are randomized within district into: (i) Control (no intervention), (ii) Treatment 1 (T1): information workshop on block usage plus a block supplier directory targeted to contractors, procurement officers, and private clients, and (iii) Treatment 2 (T2): T1 plus hands-on worker training with within-contractor randomization of workers to measure direct effects and spillovers. Primary outcomes capture adoption and usage, procurement/tender behavior, blocks related knowledge and perceptions, and worker-level skills and intentions. The analysis estimates intent-to-treat (ITT) effects at the upazila level for all respondents, and direct/spillover effects among workers under within-contractor assignment. Results will provide causal evidence on strategies to reduce emissions in Bangladesh's construction sector.
Intervention
The study evaluates the transition from traditional fired clay bricks to cleaner concrete/soil blocks in the construction sector through a clustered randomized controlled trial with three arms:
Control Group: Participants in these Upazilas receive no intervention and continue with business-as-usual operations.
Treatment 1 (Information & Facilitation): Contractors and relevant stakeholders receive an information and facilitation package delivered through in-person workshops. This includes a concise booklet summarizing the policy context (government shift towards blocks), comparative benefits and costs, a directory of local block supplier contacts, and basic workmanship guidance.
Treatment 2 (Information & Facilitation, Worker's training): Along with the Treatment 1 package, randomly selected one worker from each contractor in Treatment 2 will get hands on training on the use of blocks.
Experimental design
This is a cluster randomized controlled trial with upazila as the unit of randomization. Upazilas are randomized into three arms (Control, T1, T2) stratified by district, with one upazila per arm within each sampled district. Outcomes are measured via surveys of contractors, procurement officers, construction workers, and private clients sampled within each upazila after the endline survey of the same respondents. Main analysis will estimate intention-to-treat effects on respondent-level outcomes, accounting for clustering at the upazila level and stratification by district.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization was done in office by computer (Stata 17 MP). A random uniform number was generated to order upazilas within each district, and study arms were assigned within district using a modular rule. A reproducible random seed based on a timestamp was used. (Note: Code set seed 20251026 was used in Stata).
Randomization unit
Randomization Unit Upazila (Cluster randomization). Randomization was stratified by District, assigning Upazilas within a district to different arms.
Additional randomization (within one arm): Within-contractor randomization of construction workers in T2, selecting exactly one of two sampled workers per contractor for treatment using a uniform random number.
Clusters
66 upazilas (clusters), spread across 22 districts, with 22 upazilas per arm.
Observations
3,056 respondents to be tracked as a panel from baseline to endline. Baseline composition: 792 contractors, 152 procurement officers, 1,584 construction workers, and 528 private clients.
Primary endpoints capture adoption and awareness of eco-friendly blocks, measured separately for each actor type.
Confirmatory primary outcomes:
For contractors (N=792): (1) Ever used eco-blocks - binary indicator for having ever used hollow concrete blocks (HCB) or compressed/stabilized soil blocks (SSB) instead of fired clay bricks (baseline mean = 27.1%, MDE = 11.4 pp or 0.26 SD), and (2) Awareness index - continuous index (0-2) summing policy awareness and information receipt (baseline mean = 0.81, MDE = 0.17 units or 0.26 SD).
For construction workers (N=1,584): Ever worked with eco-blocks - binary indicator for having ever worked on a project using HCB/SSB (baseline mean = 31.9%, MDE = 9.0 pp or 0.19 SD).
For private clients (N=528): (1) Awareness index - identical construction to contractors (baseline mean = 0.534, MDE = 0.20 units or 0.30 SD); and (2) Used blocks in construction - binary indicator for having ever used eco-blocks in own construction (baseline mean = 3.0%, MDE = 5.3 pp or 0.31 SD). Both are confirmatory primary outcomes. The MDE for client block adoption in SD units (0.31 SD) is statistically equivalent to the awareness index (0.30 SD); the low baseline (3%) is reflected in the power calculation via a conservative rho=0.20 assignment and does not justify downgrading the classification. The preferred estimand restricts to baseline non-adopters (N approx. 512, 97% of clients), where "ever used" at endline equals new adoption since baseline, eliminating the floor-effect concern by construction. Adoption is the terminal behavioral outcome of the theory of change; classifying the mechanism (awareness) as primary while treating the terminal outcome as exploratory would invert the causal logic.
Exploratory outcomes (limited power):
Evaluated tender with blocks (procurement officers, N=152) - binary indicator for having evaluated a government tender that included eco-blocks (baseline mean = 49.3%, MDE = 0.59 SD). Classified as exploratory due to small sample (approximately 2 officers per cluster). Procurement officers attend workshops primarily as a belief signal; any direct behavior change is a positive externality.
Compliance/manipulation check (not a confirmatory outcome):
Received training on blocks (T2 workers, N=528) - binary indicator for having received training on working with eco-blocks (baseline mean = 2.3%, MDE = 3.8 pp or 0.26 SD, using contractor-level clustering with 264 contractors and 2 workers each). Reported prominently but not a confirmatory primary outcome, as it measures intervention delivery rather than substantive adoption behavior.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes capture mechanisms consistent with the information and coordination channels in the theory of change.
For contractors (N=792): (1) Received info on eco-blocks—whether the respondent received information about eco friendly blocks in the past year (baseline = 16.3%, MDE = 0.29 SD), measuring direct information exposure through the T1 channel; (2) Aware of government policy—whether the respondent knows government prefers alternatives to fired clay bricks (baseline = 64.4%, MDE = 0.25 SD); (3) Ease of contacting suppliers—measured on a 5-point ordinal scale (Very Difficult to Very Easy); the main analysis uses a binary recode (Moderate Easy/Very Easy = 1; variable: easy_supplier_contact; baseline = 52.5%, MDE = 0.28 SD), with the full ordinal variable treated as continuous in OLS reported as a robustness check; (4) Advised clients to use blocks—whether the contractor has recommended eco-blocks to private clients (baseline = 38.9%, MDE = 0.24 SD); (5) Knows local block supplier—whether the contractor knows a local eco-block supplier, directly targeted by the supplier directory covering 122 verified producers (baseline = 28.7%, MDE = 14.2 pp or 0.31 SD in the contractor-only main specification; a supplementary pooled contractor+client specification yields MDE = 10.6 pp or 0.26 SD).
For construction workers (N=1,562): Peer uses blocks—whether the worker is aware of peer workers who have worked with eco-blocks (baseline = 26.7%, MDE = 0.25 SD).
For private clients (N=528): (1) Knows local block supplier—whether the client knows a local eco-block supplier (baseline = 11.2%, MDE = 0.35 SD); (2) Aware of government policy (baseline = 40.9%, MDE = 0.30 SD).
For the secondary outcome “knows block supplier,” the pre-specified main analysis estimates separate effects by respondent type (contractors, private clients). A supplementary pooled interacted model combining contractors and private clients (N=1,320) tests whether effects differ across respondent types. The pooled regression includes respondent-type fixed effects and treatment-by-type interactions; both the pooled model and the separate-sample estimates are reported regardless of interaction significance.
The following outcomes are pre-registered as exploratory due to limited statistical power, small sample sizes, or indirect intervention alignment.
For contractors (government tender participants only, N=182): Proposed blocks in tender - whether the contractor has ever proposed eco-blocks in a government tender (baseline = 13.2%, MDE = 0.48 SD), reclassified from secondary to exploratory because the conditional sample (N=182, approximately 23% of contractors) yields an MDE substantially larger than the primary contractor outcomes (both 0.26 SD) and larger than the client adoption outcome classified as primary (0.31 SD). The study is underpowered for confirmatory inference on this outcome.
For contractors (N=792): Block market access - a continuous index (0-1) measuring supplier accessibility, constructed as the average of perceived block availability and knowing a local supplier (baseline = 25.3%, MDE = 0.37 SD), classified as exploratory as a mechanism variable for the coordination channel.
Barrier perceptions index (contractors) - a z-scored index from 4 binary barrier items with meaningful baseline variation: blocks not easily available (60.5%), not preferred by clients (24.6%), not mentioned in tender (20.6%), and lack of awareness (14.4%). Six additional barrier items excluded due to floor effects (less than 7% prevalence). Captures information and coordination frictions targeted by T1 (N=577 non-adopter contractors, MDE = 0.29 SD).
For procurement officers (N=152): Environment in top 3 bid criteria - whether the officer ranks environmental considerations among top 3 tender evaluation criteria (baseline = 2.6%, MDE = 0.58 SD), classified as exploratory due to small sample and floor effect. Received quality training - whether the officer has received training on assessing eco-block quality in tenders (baseline = 21.1%, MDE = 0.57 SD), reclassified from secondary to exploratory; all procurement officer outcomes are exploratory due to approximately 2 officers per upazila cluster, with MDEs ranging from 0.56 to 0.59 SD across the four PO outcomes.
For private clients (N=528): Received info on eco-blocks - whether the client received information about eco-friendly blocks in the past year (baseline = 12.5%, MDE = 0.30 SD), classified as exploratory because it is a supportive mechanism/manipulation measure rather than a focal confirmatory endpoint.
Endline-only measures: The following are collected only at endline because they capture post-intervention states. ANCOVA adjustment is not available for these outcomes.
Compliance and dosage: (1) Workshop attendance (all treated respondents)—binary indicator equal to 1 if the respondent attended the BRAC/BIGD information workshop. (2) Training dosage (T2 contractors only)—number of workers per contractor who actually received hands-on training (0, 1, or 2), required for the pre-specified dose-response analysis. (3) Used supplier directory (T1/T2 contractors and private clients)—binary indicator equal to 1 if the respondent consulted the supplier directory, separating directory compliance from workshop attendance.
Contamination check: SUTVA is threatened when substantive treatment content reaches the control group, not when respondents merely hear that a workshop occurred. We measure: (1) Received workshop materials (all respondents, especially Control)—binary indicator equal to 1 if the respondent received printed eco-block materials (leaflets, supplier directory, cost comparison sheets) from someone outside their upazila, capturing material leakage. (2) Received detailed block information from external source—binary indicator equal to 1 if someone shared specific information about block costs, supplier contacts, or technical specifications, distinguishing substantive treatment leakage from general awareness.
Adoption dynamics: (1) New adoption since baseline (contractors and private clients)—binary indicator equal to 1 if the respondent used eco-blocks for the first time since baseline. For private clients, this outcome is especially important because baseline adoption is rare (3.0%); it complements the repeated “ever used” measure by isolating first-time adoption after the intervention. (2) Number of block projects (contractors)—count of construction projects using eco-blocks in the past 6 months, capturing the intensive margin; analyzed using Poisson QMLE (negative binomial as robustness check).
Mechanism measures: (1) Cost comparison belief (contractors and private clients)—perceived relative cost of blocks versus bricks on a 5-point scale (1 = much cheaper to 5 = much more expensive, with “don’t know” option). (2) Post-use satisfaction (contractors and private clients who used blocks)—overall satisfaction on a 5-point Likert scale.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.