Comparing single versus double lump sum anticipatory cash transfers for drought in Afghanistan
How to cite
Clingain, Clare; Jawuoro, Stanley. 2025. "Comparing single versus double lump sum anticipatory cash transfers for drought in Afghanistan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017488. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17488-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Humanitarian actors are increasingly using anticipatory action (Coughlan de Perez et al., 2015) to help climate-vulnerable households protect their lives and livelihoods ahead of predictable climate shocks such as floods and droughts. Research conducted in primarily low- and middle-income countries has demonstrated anticipatory action’s potential ability to improve food consumption, support households to take more pre-shock actions, protect or invest in assets, avoid negative coping strategies, and improve overall well-being (Balana et al., 2023; Gros et al., 2019; Gros et al., 2023; Pople et al., 2021). Much of this evidence draws from one of the most common interventions used for anticipatory action: unconditional cash transfers. In the context of droughts, existing evidence suggests a lump sum cash transfer delivered as early as possible before the lean season has impacts on economic outcomes with potential longer-term impacts compared to post-shock response (Pople et al., 2023). However, little evidence exists to support how much and when anticipatory cash transfers should be delivered to households, particularly when there are multiple windows of action in which anticipatory actions could protect the harvest and/or mitigate lean season impacts. Furthermore, a majority of studies on anticipatory action have not been conducted in fragile or conflict-affected contexts, with a few notable exceptions (Balana et al., 2023; Pople et al., 2023). Our study contributes to the literature by producing experimental evidence from Afghanistan to understand whether a single lump sum anticipatory cash transfer to mimic harvest income versus two lump sum cash anticipatory transfers intended to mimic harvest income plus mitigate lean season impacts, delivered at separate windows, have any differential impacts on households’ food security and economic well-being.
NOTE: Data collection was complete prior to registration, but no data analysis examining treatment effects or descriptive information has been conducted.
Intervention
NOTE: Data collection was complete prior to registration, but no data analysis examining treatment effects or descriptive information has been conducted.
Households will receive unconditional cash transfers valued at roughly $122 ahead of a predicted drought. Depending on the treatment assignment, households will either receive all of the cash upfront during the first window of action ("protect harvest") or they will receive half of it upfront ("protect harvest") and half of it at the second window of action ("mitigate lean season impacts"). All cash will be delivered in person to the primary household representative by IRC staff.
Experimental design
We selected Badghis province purposively based on long-range forecasts indicating potential drought risk within the next 3-6 months. Within Badghis, we purposively selected a district based on forecasted risk, existing vulnerabilities including livelihood risk to drought, and operational feasibility. Within the selected district, we constructed a list of communities from which we then randomly assigned communities to either the single or double lump sum groups. All households within those communities would receive the same treatment. Balance checks will be conducted to ensure randomization worked, and cluster-robust standard errors will be used to account for community-level effects.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.