Belief Updating, Cognitive Noise and Order Effects
How to cite
Chilò, Filippo; Galliera, Arianna; Panebianco, Fabrizio. 2026. "Belief Updating, Cognitive Noise and Order Effects." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017473. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17473-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We study how cognitive noise shapes belief updating from sequences of signals and generates order effects.
We extend a Bayesian model of cognitive noise to a sequential environment in which agents noisily integrate new evidence relative to their previous belief rather than pooling all signals together, producing primacy or recency depending on the relative effective weights on past beliefs and new information. The magnitude of such order effects is instead dependent on the cognitive noise experienced when decoding the signals, which is the main hypothesis we plan to test via an online balls-and-urns experiment with repeated belief elicitation under a binarized scoring rule, complemented by a within-task measure of cognitive uncertainty. We plan to explore whether the latter, together with additional measures of cognitive/numerical abilty, can explain the magnitude of order effects at the individual level.
Two additional treatments (Treatment 1 and 2) aimed at independently manipulate the salience of prior beliefs (to shift reliance on past beliefs) and signal diagnosticity (to shift the weight on new information) will be pre-registered separately. The aim of such treatments is to assess the model's ability to predict the direction of order effects.
Experimental design
The study is conducted online with participants recruited via Bilendi and completing the task individually on a computer. Each participant plays seven rounds of a balls-and-urns task with two possible states: a Blue urn containing 5 blue and 4 red balls and a Red urn containing 4 blue and 5 red balls, with the true urn chosen with 50/50 probability (but not shown to the participant). In each round, participants observe a simultaneous draw of four balls from the unknown urn and then make three decisions: (1) they guess which urn the draw came from (Blue vs. Red); (2) they report the probability (from 50% to 100% on a 50-step slider) that their guess is correct, and this report is incentivised using a Binarized Scoring Rule that converts the stated probability and correctness of the guess into a lottery win probability for a fixed reward; and (3) they report their cognitive uncertainty by stating how likely it is that the computer’s Bayesian probability lies within ±5 percentage points of their own reported probability, using a 0–100% slider (not incentivised). Tokens are used as the unit of account and later converted to payments.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.