In-Group vs. Out-Group Communication
How to cite
Hagenbach, Jeanne; Saucet, Charlotte; Tergiman, Chloe. 2025. "In-Group vs. Out-Group Communication." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017442. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17442-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We examine situations of strategic communication between two individuals who belong or do not belong to the same group. Our objective is to study how the level of information transmitted from Senders to Receivers depends on whether communication takes place in-group or across different groups. We are particularly interested in examining how a given message is interpreted when coming from an in-group or an out-group member.
We consider a specific communication game with clear, well-known, theoretical predictions: the Sender (she) communicates hard information about a binary state, aiming to convince the Receiver (he) that the state is high. The Receiver, on the other hand, seeks to accurately guess the true state. A key feature of our setup is that we allow for the possibility that the Sender may not be informed of the state in the first place, a case in which the only message she can send is an empty one (Dye, 1985).
The probability that the Sender is uninformed is common knowledge and, in theory, shapes how Receivers interpret empty messages: they may result from strategic intent to hide unfavorable news or from mechanical constraints. We investigate how Receivers weight these two possible interpretations of an empty message, and whether these weights depend on group affiliations. In essence, we ask if Receivers are more inclined to give the benefit of the doubt to in-group Senders than to out-group Senders.
Intervention
The experiment focuses on strategic information disclosure between a Sender and a Receiver.
We vary two dimensions of the communication interaction :
(1) whether Senders and Receivers belong or not to the same group. The groups are built within the experiment before the communication phase starts.
(2) the probability with which the Sender is initially informed of the payoff-relevant state. This probability When this probability equals one, we are in the standard disclosure game. When the probability is lower than one, we are in the framework proposed by Dye in 1985.
The design is 2 by 2 and the four treatments are implemented between subjects.
Experimental design
The experiment has two main parts: first, participants engage in a collective word game designed to create group identities; second, they play a series of Sender-Receiver communication games.
- In Part 1, participants are randomly assigned to two teams. They play four rounds of a word game with their teammates. Precisely, in every round, each team member receives a set of letters, and teams must collectively form the longest possible word through intra-team discussion in a chat. Payments for Part 1 ensure that subjects try to find valid words, and also words that are longer than the ones found by the other team.
- Part 2 consists of several rounds of a Sender-Receiver communication game in which players, assigned permanently as either Senders or Receivers, are matched in pairs according to treatment: either with partners from the same team (InGroup) or from the other team (OutGroup).
Each round of communication game goes as follows: (1) a card color is randomly drawn, red or green; (2) the Sender is informed or uninformed of the color according to a probability that depends on the treatment; (3) the Sender sends either a precise color message or an empty message to the Receiver; (4) the Receiver observes this message and reports the probability that the card is green.
In the communication game, payoffs are standard: Senders earn payoffs increasing in the Receiver’s belief that the card is green. Receivers are paid according to a binarized scoring rule that rewards truthful reporting of their beliefs about the probability that the card is green.
More details about the design are given in the attached pre-analysis plan.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.