Understanding Attitudes toward Autonomous Vehicle in Tort Liability: Randomized Experiments

How to cite

Kim, Jeong Yeol; Choi, Syngjoo; Park, Hai Jin; You, Seungmi; Cho, Yeojoon. 2025. "Understanding Attitudes toward Autonomous Vehicle in Tort Liability: Randomized Experiments." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017422. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17422-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jeong Yeol Kim* , Syngjoo Choi , Hai Jin Park , Seungmi You , Yeojoon Cho

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017422
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17422-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2025-12-01 – 2026-03-31
Countries
Korea (Republic of) ()
JEL codes
K13, K41, C90, D91, O33
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17422

Abstract

Autonomous vehicles present fundamental challenges to tort liability systems designed for human drivers. This study examines whether laypeople exhibit systematic bias in fault attribution and damage awards when defendants operate autonomous vehicles rather than conventional vehicles, and whether information about tort law's preventive function moderates these judgments.

We conduct a pre-registered randomized experiment with 6,200 participants. The original study employs a 2×2 factorial design with 4,200 participants in a legal framing condition. An additional between-subject condition with 2,000 participants uses a non-legal framing, in which all legal terminology (e.g., comparative negligence, civil litigation) is replaced with everyday language centered on "responsibility," and no legal informational materials are provided. This non-legal condition was added post-registration (conducted March 10–31, 2026) to test whether the legal framing itself affects fault attribution and damage award judgments.The first factor varies information content: participants receive either general civil litigation information or information emphasizing tort law's preventive function in promoting safety investments. The second factor varies engagement: half of participants answer support questions about the preventive function of tort law while half do not. Following treatment, all participants complete six vignette-based liability scenarios as mock judges in traffic accident cases. Each scenario systematically manipulates defendant vehicle type (human-driven vs. autonomous), accident preventability, vehicle performance characteristics, and plaintiff fault levels.

Our design addresses three research questions. First, we estimate whether autonomous vehicle defendants face higher fault attributions or damage awards compared to human drivers in otherwise identical accidents, testing for autonomous vehicle aversion in liability judgments. Second, we test whether information emphasizing tort law's deterrence function reduces or amplifies any observed bias, examining whether framing tort law as a safety incentive mechanism rather than purely compensatory affects liability judgments differently for autonomous versus human defendants. Third, by comparing the legal and non-legal framing conditions, we examine whether embedding liability judgments in a legal context — with legal terminology, procedural framing, and tort law information — systematically shifts fault attribution and damage awards relative to judgments made using ordinary responsibility language. This addresses whether observed autonomous vehicle bias (if any) is specific to legal reasoning or reflects broader responsibility attribution patterns.

The vignette scenarios present realistic traffic accidents involving either two vehicles (intersection and highway settings) or vehicle-pedestrian collisions. We manipulate defendant vehicle technology (human-driven vs. fully autonomous), accident preventability (whether the defendant vehicle could have avoided the accident), autonomous vehicle performance capabilities (superior vs. equivalent to human drivers), and plaintiff baseline fault (equal to, lower than, or much lower than the defendant’s fault). Each participant evaluates six scenarios selected through constrained randomization to ensure exposure to different vehicle types while maintaining statistical power. Participants in the non-legal framing condition evaluate the same six vignette scenarios, but all references to legal concepts (comparative negligence, civil liability, tort law) are replaced with non-legal equivalents (responsibility allocation, accountability). These participants receive no informational treatment about civil litigation or tort law's preventive function. This between-subject comparison isolates the effect of legal framing on liability judgments while holding the underlying accident scenarios constant.

Primary outcomes include fault allocation percentages (comparative negligence determination) and solatium amounts (non-pecuniary damage awards). We measure both point estimates and participants' reported confidence in their judgments. This confidence measure enables analysis of decision certainty, which may differ between autonomous and human defendant cases even when average judgments appear similar.

We stratify randomization by age, gender, and metropolitan residence to enable analysis of heterogeneous treatment effects. These dimensions are policy-relevant because public acceptance of autonomous vehicles may vary systematically across demographic groups, and tort liability judgments by actual judges or juries may reflect similar heterogeneity. Our sample includes targeted recruitment from regions with ongoing autonomous vehicle development initiatives.

The experimental design enables causal identification of information treatment effects on liability judgments while the within-subject vignette variation permits estimation of autonomous vehicle bias through difference-in-differences analysis. By varying both information framing and engagement depth, we test whether passive information exposure suffices or whether active processing through support questions is necessary to shift liability judgments.

This study contributes to understanding how liability systems may need to adapt as autonomous vehicles become prevalent. If we observe systematic bias against autonomous vehicles, this suggests that current liability frameworks may inadvertently create excessive deterrence for autonomous vehicle deployment even when these vehicles demonstrably improve safety. Conversely, if information about tort law's preventive function reduces bias, this suggests that public education about liability system objectives could facilitate autonomous vehicle adoption while maintaining appropriate safety incentives.

Intervention

This pre-registered study employs a between-subject legal vs. non-legal framing design combined with a common vignette-based judgment task.
[Legal Frame (N = 4,200)] Participants in the legal frame complete a 2×2 factorial information experiment followed by a liability judgment task. In the first stage, participants are randomly assigned to watch either (i) a video providing general information about civil litigation procedures or (ii) a video emphasizing the preventive function of tort law. Within each information condition, they are further divided into (a) a group that proceeds directly to the next stage after watching the video and (b) a group that answers brief questions about the preventive function of tort law before moving on. In the second stage, all participants act as mock judges evaluating traffic accident vignettes framed in legal terminology (e.g., comparative negligence, plaintiff, defendant, solatium).
[Non-Legal Frame (N = 2,000)] Participants in the non-legal frame receive no informational treatment — no video and no comprehension questions. They proceed directly to the vignette judgment task. All legal terminology is replaced with everyday language: references to comparative negligence are reframed as responsibility allocation, legal party designations are replaced with non-legal equivalents, and non-pecuniary damages are described using ordinary language. This condition serves as a baseline to identify whether the legal framing itself systematically affects fault attribution and damage award judgments.
[Common Vignette Task] In both frames, participants evaluate traffic accident cases presented as vignettes across 30 distinct scenarios that systematically vary whether the defendant operates a human-driven vehicle or an autonomous vehicle, whether the autonomous vehicle is equipped with state-of-the-art safety technology for accident prevention, whether its prediction-and-avoidance capabilities are superior to or equivalent to those of human drivers, and the plaintiff's baseline level of fault (equal to, lower than, or much lower than the defendant's fault). The 30 scenarios are categorized into five groups; for each participant, one scenario is randomly drawn from each group, and one additional scenario is randomly selected from the full set, so that each participant evaluates a total of six scenarios. For every scenario, participants allocate fault between the two parties, determine an amount for non-pecuniary damages, and report their confidence in each of these judgments.

Experimental design

This pre-registered online survey experiment is conducted with 4,200 adults in South Korea aged 20 to 60, recruited from a professional online panel. Sample sizes are allocated across age groups to reflect the underlying population structure. Each participant is individually and randomly assigned to one of four treatment arms in a 2×2 factorial design that combines information content (general information about civil litigation vs. information emphasizing the preventive function of tort law) and the presence or absence of support questions about the preventive role of tort law. Participants first answer pre-treatment questions on AI and autonomous vehicles, then receive their randomly assigned information treatment, and subsequently read standardized explanations of key legal concepts such as fully autonomous vehicles, responsibility allocation, and non-pecuniary damages. They are then presented with six traffic accident vignette scenarios, randomly drawn from a set of 30 scenarios that systematically vary the defendant vehicle type, the presence of advanced safety technology for accident prevention (a latest-generation infrared camera), the accident-prediction and avoidance performance of the autonomous vehicle, and the plaintiff’s baseline fault level (medium/low/very low). For each scenario, participants determine the comparative responsibility allocation and the pain and suffering damages amount and report their confidence in these judgments. Finally, they complete a post-treatment questionnaire measuring demographic characteristics, litigation and driving experience, and psychological traits.

Post-registration amendment (March 2026): A non-legal framing condition was added as a between-subject arm with 2,000 new participants (conducted March 10–31, 2026). In this condition:

All legal terminology is removed (e.g., "comparative negligence" → "responsibility allocation"; "plaintiff/defendant" → everyday equivalents)
No informational video or text about civil litigation procedures is shown
Participants evaluate the same six vignette scenarios as the legal framing conditions
The outcome measures (fault allocation percentages and solatium amounts) remain identical

This addition enables a between-subject comparison of legal vs. non-legal framing to test whether the legal context itself moderates fault attribution toward autonomous vehicle defendants.

Design details

Randomization method
Random assignment in the experiment is conducted by a computer program. At the point when participants complete the pre-survey and proceed to the information treatment stage, each participant is independently assigned to one of the four treatment conditions. The platform’s randomization algorithm is designed to maintain approximate balance across the four treatment groups, taking into account key demographic characteristics of the Korean population (such as age, gender, and region). Participants in the non-legal framing condition were recruited as a separate sample and were not randomized into the 2×2 information treatment design. Within the non-legal condition, each participant was assigned six vignette scenarios through the same constrained randomization procedure used in the legal framing conditions, ensuring comparable exposure to different vehicle types.
Randomization unit
Individual participant. Each respondent is independently assigned to treatment with no clustering.
Clusters
Not applicable (individual-level randomization without clustering)
Observations
6,200 participants (Legal 4,200 + Non-legal 2,000)
Arms
* Legal frame (4,200 participants) Approximately 1,050 participants per treatment arm: - Arm 1: Civil Litigation Information Only (1,050 participants) - Arm 2: Civil Litigation Information + Comprehension Questions (1,050 participants) - Arm 3: Preventive Function Information Only (1,050 participants) - Arm 4: Preventive Function Information + Comprehension Questions (1,050 participants) Since each participant evaluates six vignette scenarios, this yields a total of approximately 25,200 scenario-level observations (about 6,300 per treatment arm). * Non-Legal Frame (2,000 participants) All participants are assigned to a single condition: Arm 5: No legal information, no legal terminology — all legal terms replaced with everyday responsibility language (2,000 participants) Since each participant evaluates six vignette scenarios, this yields a total of approximately 12,000 scenario-level observations.
Primary outcomes
Defendant Responsibility Allocation For each of the six vignette scenarios, we measure the percentage of responsibility allocated to the defendant using a continuous slider scale (0-100%), where 0% indicates the defendant bears no responsibility and 100% indicates the defendant bears full responsibility for the accident. This responsilibility ratio allocation determination directly measures whether participants assign different levels of responsibility to autonomous versus human-driven defendants. Pain and Suffering Damages For each vignette scenario, we measure the monetary award for non-pecuniary damages that participants determine the defendant must pay to the plaintiff, entered as a continuous amount in units of 10,000 Korean won (approximately $7.50 USD). Scenarios specify that economic damages (medical expenses, lost wages) total 30 million won, and participants determine appropriate additional compensation for pain, suffering, and emotional distress.
Secondary outcomes
Judgment Confidence Measures For both responsibility allocation and non-pecuniary damages awards, we measure participants' reported confidence in their judgments on 0-100% continuous scales. These measures assess whether participants experience greater decision uncertainty for autonomous versus human defendant cases, which has implications for jury deliberation dynamics and settlement negotiation patterns even if average judgments appear similar. Support for the Preventive Function of Tort Law For participants in the Questions Condition, we measure performance on the two multiple-choice comprehension items testing support for the preventive function of tort law. This manipulation check verifies whether the engagement manipulation successfully increased processing depth and enables instrumental variables analysis treating support question as an endogenous mediator. Baseline Autonomous Vehicle Attitudes Pre-treatment measures include self-reported AI knowledge (5-point scale), AI interest level (5-point scale), autonomous vehicle feature usage experience (binary), and autonomous vehicle feature usage frequency (4-point scale). These measures enable analysis of whether pre-existing autonomous vehicle attitudes predict liability judgments and moderate treatment effects. Scenario-Level Manipulation Checks For selected scenarios, we measure participants' perceptions of accident preventability and vehicle performance characteristics to verify that manipulated features were perceived as intended. These measures test whether autonomous vehicle defendants described as having superior accident avoidance capabilities are indeed perceived as more technologically advanced than human drivers.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords