Warm Glow, Scope and Parochialism: A Natural Field Experiment After the Climate Law Referendum
How to cite
Tanner, Michael; Perino, Grischa. 2025. "Warm Glow, Scope and Parochialism: A Natural Field Experiment After the Climate Law Referendum." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017402. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17402-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study investigates the motivations behind charitable giving after the provision of a public good, following the approval of a new climate law through a referendum. An environmental NGO is launching its first fundraising appeal after this policy success, creating a setting in which the core policy outcome has already been secured. This context allows us to examine whether post-policy donations are driven primarily by expressive warm-glow motives or by instrumental considerations about continued impact.
We implement a natural field experiment with 3,543 potential donors using a 2×2 design. The first treatment dimension varies the motivational framing of the appeal: the message either emphasizes expressive participation and the symbolic value of being part of a successful civic movement (warm-glow framing), or it highlights the instrumental role of donations in financing concrete follow-up activities and ensuring effective implementation of the law (instrumental framing). The second treatment dimension varies the spatial scope of benefits emphasized in the appeal, focusing either on local benefits for Hamburg or on global climate benefits. This allows us to test whether donors exhibit parochial preferences and whether spatial scope interacts with motivational framing.
Randomization is stratified by past donation behavior, nationality, prior engagement with the NGO, and timing of subscription relative to the approval of the climate law. The primary outcomes are the donation decision and donation amount. The experiment provides causal evidence on expressive versus instrumental motivations and on the role of spatial scope and parochialism in pro-environmental giving after a public good has already been provided
Intervention
The intervention is a natural field experiment embedded in the environmental organization’s first fundraising campaign following the approval of a new climate law through a referendum. A total of approximately 3,543 individuals from the organization’s contact list, including both past and potential donors, receive one of four versions of a donation request. The experiment follows a two-by-two design.
The first treatment dimension varies the motivational appeal of the message. In the warm-glow condition, the appeal emphasizes expressive participation and the symbolic value of being part of a successful civic movement, highlighting the collective achievement of the referendum. In the instrumental condition, the appeal emphasizes the concrete role of donations in financing follow-up activities and ensuring effective implementation of the law, thereby stressing the tangible impact of contributions.
The second treatment dimension varies the spatial scope of benefits emphasized in the appeal. Half of the messages focus on local benefits for Hamburg, while the other half highlight global climate benefits.
Randomization is conducted at the individual level and stratified by nationality, past donation status, and prior engagement with the organization, and time of subscription with regards to the laws passing, ensuring balanced assignment across treatment groups. Each individual receives only one version of the fundraising message through the organization’s standard communication channels.
The intervention is designed to examine why individuals donate after the successful provision of a public good, distinguishing between warm-glow and instrumental motivations and testing for parochial preferences and sensitivity to the spatial scope of benefits through variation in local versus global emphasis.
Experimental design
The study is a natural field experiment conducted during an environmental organization’s first fundraising campaign following the public announcement of the approval of a climate law through a referendum. Approximately 3,543 individuals from the organization’s contact list are randomly assigned to one of four treatment conditions in a two-by-two design. These conditions vary the motivational appeal of the donation request, contrasting a warm-glow appeal emphasizing expressive participation and symbolic support with an instrumental appeal emphasizing the role of donations in supporting implementation of the law, and vary whether the benefits of the climate law are described in terms of local or global impact.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.