Demand for traditional and modern health care in Sub-Saharan Africa: Experimental evidence on beliefs about the origin of illnesses and treatment effectiveness

How to cite

Fritz, Manuela; Priebe, Jan; Mbavu, Cédric. 2026. "Demand for traditional and modern health care in Sub-Saharan Africa: Experimental evidence on beliefs about the origin of illnesses and treatment effectiveness." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017371. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17371-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Manuela Fritz* , Jan Priebe , Cédric Mbavu

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017371
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17371-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2026-01-14 – 2026-02-10
Countries
Ghana (), Kenya (), Nigeria (), Tanzania, United Republic of (), Uganda ()
JEL codes
I10, I11, I12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17371

Abstract

In many sub-Saharan African countries, stigma towards mental and neurological illnesses is widespread. This is partly reinforced by beliefs that certain conditions, such as epilepsy or schizophrenia, have a spiritual rather than biomedical root cause. Uncertainty about the origin of illness as well as about the treatment effectiveness of modern versus traditional or spiritual treatment can influence help-care seeking behavior and treatment choices. We conduct an online experiment in five sub-Saharan countries to study the prevalence of spiritual-origin beliefs of epilepsy and schizophrenia and to assess the uncertainty around treatment effectiveness of different health care providers. We then study the effect of two information treatments on these beliefs, uncertainties and treatment preferences. The first information treatment provides scientifically validated information on the biomedical origin of the diseases, while the second provides evidence on the effectiveness of modern medical treatment. We compare the effects of the treatments against a passive control group and a priming group. We elicit incentivized belief updating and treatment choices in response to information. Our results shed light on the mechanisms driving demand for traditional care and provide evidence on how misperceptions about the origin and treatment of mental and neurological illnesses can be effectively addressed to increase uptake of biomedical treatment.

Intervention

Participants will be randomly assigned to one of four groups: (1) a control group, (2) a priming group, (3) an information treatment on the biomedical origins of the disease (“origin” treatment), or (4) an information treatment on the effectiveness of modern medical care (“effectiveness” treatment). The two treatment arms provide scientifically validated information, focusing either on the biomedical etiology (i.e. the cause) of the disease or on the effectiveness of modern medical treatment, respectively.

Experimental design

We conduct an online survey experiment with participants recruited via Facebook advertisements. Facebook users who view and click on the advertisements are redirected to the study platform, where they complete a 20-minute survey. The survey elicits participants’ beliefs about the causes of, and treatment options for, epilepsy and schizophrenia.

Participants are randomly assigned to one of four experimental groups: (1) a pure control group, (2) a priming group, (3) treatment group 1 (“origin”), or (4) treatment group 2 (“effectiveness”). In addition, participants are subject to a second randomization that determines the order in which the disease-specific modules are presented, with participants receiving questions on epilepsy first and schizophrenia second, or vice versa.

The overall experimental structure is as follows. First, we estimate within-individual relationships between beliefs about disease origins and treatment effectiveness for several diseases to study how widespread spiritual beliefs are. Second, we measure prior beliefs and the level of uncertainty about disease etiology and treatment effectiveness. Third, we implement an information experiment to identify causal effects of information on posterior beliefs and uncertainty about disease etiology and treatment effectiveness. Fourth, we use an incentivized belief-elicitation task to study belief updating and resulting changes in the demand for health care services. Finally, we employ an incentivized measure to assess donation decisions. The exact experimental flow for each of the four groups is outlined below and presented as graphical overview in Figure 1 (separately uploaded).

____________________________
Group 1 (pure control):
____________________________
(0) Within estimate of origin-effectiveness (for several diseases)
(1) Elicitation of beliefs and uncertainty about the root cause of illness #2 (epilepsy/schizophrenia)
(2) Elicitation of beliefs and uncertainty about effectiveness of traditional and modern medicine for treating illness #2 (unincentivized + incentivized)
(3) Health care provider choice
(4) Donation task

____________________________
Group 2 (priming group):
____________________________
(0) Within estimate of origin-effectiveness (for several diseases)
(1) Elicitation of beliefs and uncertainty about the root cause of illness #1
(2) Elicitation of beliefs and uncertainty about effectiveness of traditional and modern medicine for treating illness #1 (unincentivized)
(3) Health care provider choice
(4) Elicitation of beliefs and uncertainty about the root cause of illness #2
(5) Elicitation of beliefs and uncertainty about effectiveness of traditional and modern medicine for treating illness #2 (unincentivized + incentivized)
(6) Health care provider choice
(7) Donation task

____________________________
Group 3 (treatment group “origin”):
____________________________
(0) Within estimate of origin-effectiveness (for several diseases)
(1) Elicitation of prior beliefs and uncertainty about the root cause of illness #1
(2) Elicitation of prior beliefs and uncertainty about effectiveness of traditional and modern medicine for treating illness #1 (unincentivized)
(3) Health care provider choice
(4) Information treatment “origin”: participants read a text about scientifically validated information on the biomedical origin of the diseases
(5) Elicitation of posterior beliefs and uncertainty about the root cause of illness #2
(6) Elicitation of posterior beliefs and uncertainty about effectiveness of traditional and modern medicine for treating illness #2 (unincentivized + incentivized)
(7) Health care provider choice
(8) Donation task

____________________________
Group 4 (treatment group “effectiveness”):
____________________________
(0) Within estimate of origin-effectiveness (for several diseases)
(1) Elicitation of prior beliefs and uncertainty about the root cause of illness #1
(2) Elicitation of prior beliefs and uncertainty about effectiveness of traditional and modern medicine for treating illness #1 (unincentivized)
(3) Health care provider choice
(4) Information treatment “effectiveness”: participants read a text about scientifically validated information on the effectiveness of modern medical treatment
(5) Elicitation of posterior beliefs and uncertainty about the root cause of illness #2
(6) Elicitation of posterior beliefs and uncertainty about effectiveness of modern or traditional medicine for treating illness #2 (unincentivized + incentivized)
(7) Health care provider choice
(8) Donation task

Design details

Randomization method
Individuals are randomized via computer-generated random assignment within the online survey.
Randomization unit
Individual respondent
Clusters
Not applicable. No clusters.
Observations
There is no fixed sample size. We aim to reach as many participants as possible by recruiting participants via Facebook ads. Results from previous studies suggest that we might be able to reach about 6,000 participants with the determined budget.
Arms
There is no fixed sample size. We aim to reach as many participants as possible by recruiting participants via Facebook ads. Participants will be allocated to one out of four treatment arms with equal probabilities.
Primary outcomes
Primary outcomes are grouped into belief-based outcomes, choice outcomes, and allocation outcomes: (1) Beliefs and uncertainty (a) Beliefs about the root causes (etiology) of epilepsy/schizophrenia and the associated subjective uncertainty; (b) Beliefs about the effectiveness of modern or traditional medicine and the associated subjective uncertainty; (c) Beliefs about the effectiveness of modern medical treatment for epilepsy/schizophrenia, elicited using an incentivized belief-elicitation task. (2) Health care provider choice (d) Hypothetical choice of health care provider (not incentivized). (3) Donation allocation task (e) Allocation of a real monetary endowment between two NGOs: one facilitating knowledge exchange among African traditional healers and one facilitating knowledge exchange among African medical doctors on best-practice treatment options (incentivized).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords