AI and Human Guidance in Labor Conciliation
How to cite
Seira, Enrique. 2025. "AI and Human Guidance in Labor Conciliation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017348. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17348-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This randomized controlled trial examines whether providing dismissed workers with clear legal information improves outcomes in Mexico’s mandatory pre-judicial conciliation process. Many workers arrive at conciliation with limited knowledge of their rights and the procedures governing severance, contributing to low settlement rates. In partnership with the Mexico City Conciliation Center, we randomize individuals who come to schedule their conciliation meeting into four groups: (i) a control group receiving no additional information; (ii) a short video explaining the conciliation process and basic legal entitlements; (iii) the video plus legally accurate information delivered by a trained law-student enumerator; and (iv) the video plus legally accurate information delivered through a calibrated large language model (LLM)–based interactive tool.
The study tests whether information provision increases worker knowledge, affects expectations, and improves settlement rates and terms. It also compares the effectiveness of human versus AI-based information delivery. Primary outcomes include settlement incidence, settlement amounts, worker understanding of rights, and subsequent legal actions. Results aim to inform scalable interventions to improve access to justice in labor disputes.
Intervention
This experiment focuses on workers who visit the Conciliation Center to schedule a mandatory conciliation meeting with their employer after being dismissed. Workers will be exposed to one of the following randomly assigned conditions:
a) Control group: No additional information provided.
b) Treatment 1 (Basic info video): participants will receive a video explaining the conciliation stage, and their main entitlements under the law. The video will last 2 minutes.
c) Treatment 2 (Enumerator Info): Participants receive basic video info + information about the conciliation process and labor law from trained law students.
d) Treatment 3 (LLM Info): Participants receive basic video info + information via an AI-powered interactive tool.
Experimental design
This experiment focuses on workers who visit the Conciliation Center to schedule a mandatory conciliation meeting with their employer after being dismissed. Workers will be exposed to one of the following randomly assigned conditions:
a) Control group: No additional information provided.
b) Treatment 1 (Basic info video): participants will receive a video explaining the conciliation stage, and their main entitlements under the law. The video will last 2 minutes.
c) Treatment 2 (Enumerator Info): Participants receive basic video info + information about the conciliation process and labor law from trained law students.
d) Treatment 3 (LLM Info): Participants receive basic video info + information via an AI-powered interactive tool.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.