Parental Involvement in Education and Children's Human Capital Formation

How to cite

Siddique, Abu; Krutikova, Sonya; Khandelwal, Vatsal; Vlassopoulos, Michael; Zenou, Yves. 2025. "Parental Involvement in Education and Children's Human Capital Formation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017346. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17346-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Abu Siddique* , Sonya Krutikova , Vatsal Khandelwal , Michael Vlassopoulos , Yves Zenou

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017346
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17346-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-03-27 – 2026-03-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, I21, I25, J13, O12, O15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17346

Abstract

How can targeted parental engagement strategies address the widespread challenge of improving children’s academic outcomes in low-income countries? Existing literature from both economic and educational psychology fields highlights the importance of parental involvement in children’s educational outcomes. These studies examine various pathways through which parental engagement impacts academic performance, including human capital transmission, resource provision, parenting style, and social network development, while also emphasising the long-term effects on human capital formation and intergenerational mobility. However, the multifaceted nature of parental engagement necessitates identifying which aspects are most influential. Joyce Epstein (1995) proposes four primary forms of engagement for young children: (i) volunteering at schools, (ii) parenting, (iii) communicating with educators, and (iv) supporting learning at home. This study aims to experimentally test the causal impact of parental volunteering at children’s schools on their school performance and assess whether parenting practices, communication, home learning support, and parental social network function as potential mechanisms for this influence. We opt for an experimental test because empirical tests of this framework using observational data pose two major challenges. Firstly, parents who volunteer may differ from those who do not in ways that could be correlated with parental investment choices and the education of their children. Secondly, there may be a simultaneous relationship between parental decisions to volunteer and children's academic outcomes, leading to the issue of reverse causality. Therefore, this project aims to provide one of the first causal evidences of parents' volunteering at schools and its impact on their children's education outcomes.

Intervention

The intervention is a school-based parental volunteering program implemented across 80 primary schools in Bangladesh. Schools sent invitation letters to about 5,000 parents describing an opportunity to volunteer at their child’s school for 2–3 hours whenever help was needed or during school events. Parents who agreed returned consent letters, and from these volunteers, a study sample was drawn. In 60 “intervention” schools, consenting parents were randomly assigned either to: (1) a treatment group that was formally signed up to volunteer in school activities for about 18 months (May 2023 to Sep 2024); e.g., helping organise sports day/cultural events, assisting with school programs, cleaning and other support tasks, and receiving weekly SMS reminders encouraging volunteering; or (2) an active-control group from the same schools who were told the volunteering slots were full and were not needed, receiving no SMS reminders. In 20 additional schools, parents followed the same recruitment process but were assigned to a pure control group with no volunteering role either. At the time of pre-registration, we are still not done with collecting data from schools and teachers.

Experimental design

We partnered with 80 public primary schools (grades 1–5) in the Rajshahi region of Bangladesh. About 5,000 parents were invited to volunteer at their child's school; roughly 70% consented and were eligible for sampling. From consenting parents, we randomly selected about 1,500 parent–child dyads for surveys.

Parent-level randomization within intervention schools: In each of the 60 intervention schools, around 22 consenting parents were randomly chosen and then individually randomized into:
- Treatment group (volunteering encouragement): 14 parents per school were formally signed up to volunteer for 18 months and received weekly SMS reminders encouraging participation.
- Active control group (no volunteering role): 8 parents per school were told volunteering slots were full and were not asked to volunteer; they received no SMS reminders.

Pure control schools: In each of the 20 pure control schools, 8 consenting parents were randomly selected into the study sample; no parent was asked to volunteer, and no reminders were sent.

Total schools N=80:
- 60 schools were "intervention schools".
- 20 schools were "pure control schools".

Planned sample sizes (pre-attrition): 860 treatment dyads, 481 active control dyads, and 160 pure control dyads.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done in the office by computer
Randomization unit
Individual level
Clusters
80 schools
Observations
- 1501 parent-child dyads - Up to 160 teachers (up to 2 teachers per school) - Up to 80 headmasters (one per school)
Arms
-Treatment parents: 860 parent-child dyads -Active control: 481 parent-child dyads -Pure control: 160 parent-child dyads
Primary outcomes
Outcomes of children: Primary outcomes include--- (A) Cognitive Outcomes: (1) standardized test scores in mathematics and Bengali; (2) working memory; and (B) Non-cognitive outcomes: (3) school attendance; (4) academic motivation, (5) happiness at school, (6) self-confidence about education, (7) socio-emotional functioning using the SDQ (excluding prosociality). Outcomes of parents and potential channels for children’s outcomes: Primary outcomes include--- A. Parental Investments on Children: (1) family care and support for learning (FCI), (2) financial and time investments in children’s learning, (3) other time-intensive parental investments, (4) parental carefulness, (5) setting limits, (6) alternate care arrangements, (7) knowledge about children’s school, (8) beliefs about child’s performance relative to actual performance; B. Parental Well-being: (9) mental health (stress and anxiety), (10) mothers’ bargaining power, (11) subjective well-being (happiness and life satisfaction), and C. Parental Networks: (12) communication with other parents and social networks—which captures both the extensive margin (number of parents known, considered friends, or contacted for advice or support) and the intensive margin (frequency of contact, sharing of parenting or education tips, and discussions of personal or financial concerns)—(13) networks with other parents and (14) altruism (hypothetical dictator game) In addition to this, we will also aim to measure teacher and school outcomes from as many schools as possible, depending on permissions and logistical constraints. Outcomes of teachers: Primary outcomes include--- A. Teacher well-being (1) mental health, (2) subjective well-being, (3) absenteeism, and B. Teacher investments (4) extra tutoring, (5) contact with parents (including recall of parents’ names as an indicator of relationship depth). Outcomes of schools (by surveying principals and observations): Primary outcomes include---- (1) recent investments in schools and of what type, (2) teacher–student ratio per classroom (i.e., whether new teachers were hired), and (3) school or classroom quality checklist, including whether a teacher is present in class, whether the classroom is noisy, and whether teachers use corporal punishment.
Secondary outcomes
Children: Secondary outcomes include--- (A) School Environment: (8) experiences of bullying or discouragement for studying, (9) prosociality measured through a Dictator Game. (B) Academic Effort and Motivation: (10) school dropout, (11) academic self-perceptions, (12) self-study engagement, (13) proportion of hours allocated to study using time allocation across school, home study, play, and interactions with teachers or parents. Parents: Secondary outcomes include--- A. Experience with Schools: (15) volunteering at schools, (16) communication with schools, (17) beliefs about teacher effectiveness B. Parenting Practices and Aspirations: (18) child–parent relationship, (19) parenting style, (20) home study time, (21) satisfaction with children’s school performance, (22) aspirations for children’s education. In addition to this, we will also aim to measure teacher and school outcomes from as many schools as possible, depending on permissions and logistical constraints. Teachers; Secondary outcomes include--- A. Beliefs about Students: (5) aspirations about students’ education and (6) beliefs about student performance. In addition, we will also measure (7) perceptions of the volunteering program (including qualitative views on its impact and suggestions for improvement). Schools: Secondary outcomes include--- (4) parents’ feedback and satisfaction, including any complaints about school quality or facilities, (5) whether schools are happy about parents’ volunteering and why (qualitative), (6) how they would like to improve or change the volunteering program (qualitative), (7) whether volunteering increased schools' expenditures and how (qualitative), and (8) which policies or changes are perceived as most effective for improving student performance and well-being, and where parent volunteering ranks among them (qualitative question).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords