Endogenous Screening and Health Behaviors

How to cite

Darden, Michael. 2025. "Endogenous Screening and Health Behaviors." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017283. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17283-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Michael Darden*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017283
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17283-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2025-11-20 – 2026-02-15
Countries
United States of America (MD)
JEL codes
I12; I18
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17283

Abstract

Our paper models the decision to seek low-dose CT (LDCT) lung cancer screening. Because 80$\%$ of lung cancers are caused by cigarette smoking, we build a dynamic structural model in which screening and smoking are chosen simultaneously. Screening has the potential to identify early-stage lung cancer, when it is potentially treatable, and it alleviates uncertainty about the true lung cancer state. At the same time, screening is costly in both pecuniary and non-pecuniary terms, and it is not perfect in the sense that false positives may lead to unnecessary care. Smoking generates utility, particularly for those with significant and recent smoking histories, but it also increases the risk for both lung cancer and other chronic conditions. Our goal is to estimate the model and to simulate policy counterfactual scenarios that address both costs and benefits of screening.

To directly estimate the model, we would need longitudinal information on screening and smoking behaviors, subjective beliefs, screening outcomes, and health transitions over many years. Because such data do not exist, our empirical approach combines data from several sources. For our primary data source, we plan to conduct a randomized information experiment that will evaluate how brief, randomized information about stigma, perceived quality, and price affect intentions to seek low-dose CT (LDCT) lung cancer screening within 12 months. Our population of interest are those above the age of 40 who have some cigarette smoking history. Before the information treatments, we will assess eligibility for $0 out-of-pocket (OOP) screening based on USPSTF 2022 guidelines. We intend to report the average treatment effects generated by our experiment and the heterogeneity in these effects by theoretically relevant factors at baseline, including stigma, perceptions of quality, and income. We will then use these treatment effects to calibrate our model. We will run our survey on Prolific.

Intervention

We intend to run a survey on the Prolific platform. We restrict attention to those over the age of 40 with some smoking history. The survey captures risk and time preferences and basic SES measures. We also assess beliefs and expectations regarding lung cancer and lung cancer screening. Then, we randomize respondents into one of four arms: control, stigma, quality, and price. We ask respondents about their likelihood of seeking lung cancer screening in the next 12 months, and we frame the question differently across arms. The control arm presents a neutral framing; the stigma arm reassures respondents that clinicians will not be judgmental during the screening; the quality arm informs respondents of the true false positive rate in LDCT screening; and the price arm presents out-of-pocket cost information depending on whether the respondent satisfies USPSTF eligibility for free screening. For those eligible (as assessed by the survey), price arm respondents are informed of their eligibility; for those ineligible, we randomized an out-of-pocket price for screening. We assess intention to screen on a 0-100 scale as well as with a binary decision. Following the intention to screen questions, we assess comprehension. Finally, we assess intention to smoke cigarettes over the next 12 months. Half of respondents are randomized to a neutral framing of the smoking question, and half of respondents are randomized to a framing that suggests a recent "clean" screening.

Experimental design

We intend to run a survey on the Prolific platform. We restrict attention to those over the age of 40 with some smoking history. The survey captures risk and time preferences and basic SES measures. We also assess beliefs and expectations regarding lung cancer and lung cancer screening. Then, we randomize respondents into one of four arms: control, stigma, quality, and price. We ask respondents about their likelihood of seeking lung cancer screening in the next 12 months, and we frame the question differently across arms. The control arm presents a neutral framing; the stigma arm reassures respondents that clinicians will not be judgmental during the screening; the quality arm informs respondents of the true false positive rate in LDCT screening; and the price arm presents out-of-pocket cost information depending on whether the respondent satisfies USPSTF eligibility for free screening. For those eligible (as assessed by the survey), price arm respondents are informed of their eligibility; for those ineligible, we randomized an out-of-pocket price for screening. We assess intention to screen on a 0-100 scale as well as with a binary decision. Following the intention to screen questions, we assess comprehension. Finally, we assess intention to smoke cigarettes over the next 12 months. Half of respondents are randomized to a neutral framing of the smoking question, and half of respondents are randomized to a framing that suggests a recent "clean" screening.

Design details

Randomization method
The survey is built in Qualtrics. Qualtrics does the simple randomization.
Randomization unit
Individual.
Clusters
4,000 Individuals.
Observations
4,000 Individuals.
Arms
Intention to Screen: 1,000 per arm * 4 arms = 4,000 Intention to Smoke: 2,000 per arm * 2 arms = 4,000 The two randomized questions are independent.
Primary outcomes
Intent to seek LDCT lung cancer screening; intent to smoke cigarettes.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords