Higher-Order Reasoning and the Development of Social and Redistributive Preferences
How to cite
Alan, Sule. 2025. "Higher-Order Reasoning and the Development of Social and Redistributive Preferences." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017281. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17281-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We leverage an ongoing randomized controlled trial (RCT) initiated in Summer 2022 to assess whether an intervention designed to strengthen higher-order reasoning skills also shapes children’s social and redistributive preferences. We study the development of trust and reciprocity, redistributive attitudes, inequality aversion, moral reasoning, and fairness ideals. The intervention was delivered from October 2023 to April 2025, spanning two academic years (grades 2–3) in two provinces in Southeast Turkey. It consists of structured classroom activities and materials targeting core components of analytical thinking—fluid reasoning, short-term memory, analytical categorization, and inference skills—with the aim of improving critical thinking and supporting both academic and socioemotional development.
The original RCT includes 132 primary schools (67 treatment, 65 control) in Gaziantep and Şırnak and was registered in January 2025 with primary outcomes focused on cognitive, socio-cognitive, and higher-order thinking skills (Registry no: AEARCTR-0015281). This supplemental registration documents and analyzes newly introduced measures of children’s social development using only the Gaziantep sample, which comprises 84 schools (43 treatment, 41 control). One control school closed after the first year, leaving 43 treatment and 40 control schools for analysis. Şırnak is excluded from the present study due to funding constraints. If these constraints are relaxed by the time of fieldwork (April 2026), Şırnak will be added.
Intervention
The intervention consists of a structured set of curricular materials designed to strengthen key components of analytical thinking in young children. Its overarching aim is to accelerate learning and improve learning efficiency, thereby reinforcing foundational numeracy and literacy skills in the early primary years. In the first year, the program targets abstract reasoning, short-term memory, and analytical categorization. In the second year, it emphasizes inference and analogical reasoning. Trained teachers were instructed to allocate at least four hours per week to the materials during regular class hours. Program implementation concluded in April 2025.
Experimental design
The ongoing RCT includes 132 state primary schools, with 48 located in Şırnak province and 84 in Gaziantep. Schools were assigned to treatment with a 50% probability, stratified by district. This resulted in 67 treatment schools and 65 control schools.
For the present study, we will collect social and redistributive outcomes only in Gaziantep in May 2026, and the analysis will therefore focus on the Gaziantep sample. If logistics allow, we will also collect the moral reasoning measures in Şırnak. Due to the closure of one control school, the Gaziantep sample now consists of 83 schools: 43 treatment and 40 control. If current funding constraints are relaxed by the time of the fieldwork (April 2026), we will collect all of the above outcomes in Şırnak as well.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.