Climate Security and Informal Settlements: Evidence from Sierra Leone
How to cite
Bryan, Gharad; Tsivanidis, Nick; Kamara, Abou Bakarr; Rinaldi, Emliano. 2025. "Climate Security and Informal Settlements: Evidence from Sierra Leone." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017263. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17263-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Rapid urban expansion in Sub-Saharan Africa has pushed low-income households into informal settlements located in areas increasingly exposed to coastal flooding and landslides. Freetown, Sierra Leone exemplifies this challenge: large informal neighborhoods occupy low-lying coastal zones that face severe seasonal flooding, yet previous government relocation efforts—typically top-down, peripheral, and poorly aligned with residents’ preferences—have largely failed. This project provides the first integrated empirical and structural assessment of whether, and how, governments should facilitate the voluntary relocation of households living in high-risk informal settlements.
We proceed in four steps. First, we quantify the economic, health, and fiscal costs of recurrent flooding by combining a novel panel survey of 3,000 households with administrative expenditure data and high-frequency water-level monitors installed across at-risk communities. Second, we implement a spatially conditional housing-subsidy experiment to estimate household preferences over housing and neighborhood attributes. Through a Multiple Price List design, households choose between remaining in their current dwelling or relocating to safer neighborhoods under varying subsidy levels, enabling us to identify the minimum compensation required to induce voluntary movement and the heterogeneity in these thresholds. Third, we use randomized subsidy offers and a follow-up panel to estimate the causal impacts of relocation on economic outcomes, health, and human capital. Finally, we study how to prevent re-encroachment of vacated land. We elicit community leaders’ willingness to enforce no-build zones and combine these data with relocation impacts and compensation costs in a dynamic quantitative spatial model tailored to a low-income, high-informality context.
Together, the project will generate the first evidence on the welfare gains from relocating households away from climate-vulnerable areas and the policy instruments most likely to achieve sustained, voluntary reductions in exposure.
Intervention
The intervention offers households living in flood-prone informal settlements the chance to win housing subsidies tied to specific safer neighborhoods in Freetown. Using a Multiple Price List (MPL), each participant chooses between staying in their current home or relocating with a randomly assigned subsidy covering 25–100% of annual rent. Subsidy terms are revealed via scratchcards, creating randomized variation in the attractiveness of moving. Lottery winners independently secure housing in their assigned neighborhood, and the project pays the subsidy directly to landlords. Follow-up surveys track winners and non-winners for 18 months to measure the causal impacts of relocation.
Experimental design
Households will be given a series of choices between locations and housing types at different levels of subsidy. After they make choices, a card will be scratched to determine if they are a "winner". For "winners" one of their choices will be chosen to be "implemented." If they chose to move in that choice they will be given a moving subsidy and help to find a new home in a safe part of Freetown.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.