Part-time provisions in parental allowance schemes and couples’ division of market work: incentives and information provision
How to cite
Knabe, Andreas; Derlin, Manja; Keldenich, Carina. 2025. "Part-time provisions in parental allowance schemes and couples’ division of market work: incentives and information provision." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017256. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17256-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In this project, we examine whether the introduction of ElterngeldPlus—an additional parental allowance option introduced for births after 1 July 2015 that removes disincentives to part-time work while receiving Elterngeld—encourages a more equal division of paid work and childcare between partners through simultaneous part-time employment. We also assess the role of information provision: in particular, whether limited transparency about financial incentives helps explain the relatively low uptake of ElterngeldPlus for supporting parallel part-time work arrangements.
To address these questions, we conduct a 2×2 randomized survey experiment with a representative sample of about 2,000 adults aged 20–50 in Germany. The experiment evaluates how (1) the introduction of the ElterngeldPlus scheme and (2) the presentation of information on its financial implications shape couples’ preferred division of paid work after the birth of their first child.
Intervention
The intervention is delivered in a randomized online survey experiment. Respondents are randomly assigned to one of four conditions varying (i) the parental allowance scheme shown (Basiselterngeld vs. ElterngeldPlus) and (ii) the level of information provided (Case 1: verbal rules and tables containing information on work hours and labor income, but not the precise values of the parental allowance vs. Case 2: verbal rules and tables containing information on work hours and incomes including the parental allowance). After receiving the assigned information, participants make choices over work-hour allocations in a post-birth scenario.
Experimental design
We conduct a 2×2 between-subjects online survey experiment with 2,000 adults aged 20–50 in Germany. The experiment examines how (i) parental allowance rules (Basiselterngeld vs. ElterngeldPlus) and (ii) information provision (Case 1: verbal rules and tables containing information on work hours and labor income, but not the precise values of the parental allowance vs. Case 2: verbal rules and tables containing information on work hours and incomes including the parental allowance) affect individuals’ preferred division of paid work within couples after the birth of a first child.
All respondents receive a vignette in which their first child has just been born. They must allocate a fixed total of 40 weekly work hours between themselves and their partner for the first 14 months after birth. This setup isolates preferences over the distribution of market work from other considerations, such as regarding the total hours supplied. Respondents make choices in three income scenarios that vary in partners’ pre-birth relative earnings. For each scenario, they choose among five predefined work arrangements (specialization, sequential leave, simultaneous part-time, etc.). Net income is assumed to halve when hours halve.
The respondents are randomly assigned to one of four treatment groups, which differ in the rules for the parental allowance scheme and presentation of information (see above).
Because the research question concerns the gendered divisions of labor, all scenarios describe a heterosexual couple. Respondents are assigned the role (woman or man) consistent with their self-reported gender. Men and women are given the same potential arrangements in terms of how labor is divided between the mother and the father (see primary outcome section), but the different arrangements themselves are not fully symmetrical. This is done because feasible arrangements are restricted by, e.g., maternity protection rules, which imply that women cannot work immediately postpartum, and to prevent choice overload.
Randomization occurs at the individual level, with quotas ensuring roughly equal numbers of male and female respondents. Analyses will be conducted separately by respondent gender and pooled where appropriate.
(For more details, see the pre-analysis plan.)
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.