Energy Transition and Fiscal Preferences: A Survey Experiment
How to cite
Mukherjee, Srutakirti; James, Alexander. 2025. "Energy Transition and Fiscal Preferences: A Survey Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017200. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17200-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
State governments in fossil-fuel-rich states rely heavily on revenue generated from oil, gas, and coal extraction. This dependence creates a cyclical pattern in fiscal policy, as tax rates and public services adjust to booms and busts in these economies. These fluctuations introduce persistent fiscal volatility that directly affects local communities. The possibility of a future move away from fossil-fuels and towards greener energy puts these communities dependent on fossil-fuel at a higher risk.
Under these possible transitions, resource-reliant states face a real risk of out-migration. In this study, we analyze how fiscal adjustments influence people’s decisions to leave their state. We also examine different strategies for attracting new residents, especially in smaller towns that are most vulnerable. While large cities offer numerous economic opportunities, small towns have a distinct set of natural, infrastructural, social, and community-based amenities that can influence people’s willingness to relocate. To study these different strategies, we focus on Laramie, Wyoming as a small town within a fossil-fuel state.
We implement a nationwide online survey through Prolific. Respondents living in fossil-fuel-reliant states are asked what fiscal changes would influence their decision to leave the state. Respondents irrespective of their state of residence are asked to about their willingness to move to Laramie under a set of informational treatments such as fiscal, infrastructural, natural, socio-economic, and placemaking. Finally, we compare in-migration responses between residents of resource-rich states and those from other states.
By examining fiscal preferences and migration decisions, this research contributes to the broader discussion on how fossil-fuel-dependent communities can remain resilient in the face of a possible transition toward greener energy in the United States.
Intervention
We run an online survey experiment through Prolific that targets United States residents above the age of eighteen. The survey is designed in Qualtrics and will be administered on Prolific.
The survey has four sections (1) demographics and socio-economic background, (2) experiment 1 (Out-Migration), (3) experiment 2 (In-migration to Laramie, WY.), and (4) choice of fiscal policy to counter fossil-fuel revenue decline,
In the first experiment, respondents residing in one of the ten resource-rich states (Alaska, Colorado, Kansas, Louisiana, Montana, New Mexico, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Texas, and Wyoming) are randomly assigned to one of seven scenarios and asked about their likelihood of moving out of their current state over the next three years. In the baseline scenario, respondents are simply asked about their likelihood of moving to a different state in the next three years. In the six treatment scenarios, respondents are told to imagine a 10% reduction in state government revenue due to a fall in fossil-fuel production, and that their state government responds with a different fiscal policy in each treatment: (i) raising the average property tax rate; (ii) raising the average sales tax rate; (iii) raising the average individual income tax rate; (iv) cutting public spending on education; (v) cutting public spending on healthcare; and (vi) cutting public spending on infrastructure.
In the second experiment, all respondents from all states are asked about their willingness to move to Laramie, Wyoming under varying informational treatments. In the control group, subjects are given basic innocuous information about Laramie, WY. (e.g., that it is a college town and that it is at an elevation of 7,200 ft). Treatments will provide subjects with one of three pieces of additional information about Laramie, WY., depending on treatment: i) tax policy, ii) socio-economic conditions, or iii) natural amenities. Further, each of the treatments and the control will be presented with either i) a real image of downtown Laramie, WY., or ii) a modified one that enhanced place-making modifications (including things like urban greenery and pedestrian friendly design).
The two experiments are shown in a randomized order to control for order effects.
Experimental design
The survey uses a between-subjects experimental design. This study has two online surveys administered through Prolific. (i) an “oil-rich states” survey administered only to respondents currently residing in the top ten fossil-fuel dependent states (Alaska, Colorado, Kansas, Louisiana, Montana, New Mexico, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Texas, and Wyoming), and (ii) an “oil-poor-states” survey administered to respondents from the remaining states. The screening for the surveys will be conducted using Prolific’s pre-screening tool to restrict participation to residents of the designated states. State-of-residence will be verified again at the start of the survey.
The two surveys share common demographic and background questions, but have different experimental modules. The experiment about out-migration is only administered in the oil-rich survey, and the experiments about in-migration is distributed in both the surveys.
In the first experiment, respondents living in the top ten fossil-fuel dependent states are randomly assigned to one of three hypothetical scenarios describing how their state might respond to a large decline in fossil-fuel revenue. After reading the assigned scenario, respondents report how likely they would be to move to a different state in the next three years. The scenarios are:
Baseline: Respondents are simply asked how likely they are to move to a different state in the next three years.
Treatment 1 (Property Tax Increase) : Respondents are told to imagine a 10% reduction in state government revenue due to a fall in fossil-fuel production, and that their state government responds by mandating a rise in the average local property tax rate.
Treatment 2 (Sales Tax Increase) : Respondents are told to imagine a 10% reduction in state government revenue due to a fall in fossil-fuel production, and that their state government responds by increasing the average sales tax rate.
Treatment 3 (Individual Income Tax Increase) : Respondents are told to imagine a 10% reduction in state government revenue due to a fall in fossil-fuel production, and that their state government responds by increasing the average individual income tax rate.
Treatment 4 (Spending Cut on Education) : Respondents are told to imagine the same 10% revenue decline, but that their state government responds by cutting public spending on education.
Treatment 5 (Spending Cut on Healthcare) : Respondents are told to imagine the same 10% revenue decline, but that their state government responds by cutting public spending on healthcare.
Treatment 6 (Spending Cut on Infrastructure) : Respondents are told to imagine the same 10% revenue decline, but that their state government responds by cutting public spending on infrastructure.
All respondents, regardless of state of residence, participate in a second experiment that elicits their willingness to move to Laramie, Wyoming under different informational and visual treatments. Each respondent is shown images of downtown Laramie either original images or modified images that visually incorporate placemaking improvements (e.g., added urban greenery, pedestrian-friendly streetscape design). After viewing the assigned information and images, respondents report how likely they would be to move to Laramie in the next three years.
The experiment consists of seven scenarios:
Baseline (General Information - Original Images): Respondents are shown general information about Laramie along with original photographs.
Treatment 1 (Tax Environment - Original Images) : Along with same general information as the baseline scenario, respondents receive additional information describing Laramie’s tax environment (e.g., absence of state income tax, relative tax burden). They are shown original images.
Treatment 2 (Tax Environment - Enhanced Images) : Identical informational treatment as in treatment 1, but respondents are shown visually enhanced images with placemaking improvements.
Treatment 3 (Socio-Economic Factors - Original Images) : Along with same general information as the baseline scenario, respondents receive information about cost of living, unemployment rates, safety, and community amenities in Laramie, accompanied by original downtown images.
Treatment 4 (Socio-Economic Factors - Enhanced Images): Identical socio-economic information as in treatment 3, but respondents are shown visually enhanced images with placemaking improvements.
Treatment 5 (Natural Amenities - Scenic Image) : Along with same general information as the baseline scenario, respondents receive information about Laramie's outdoor amenities, accompanied by a photograph of the mountain landscape surrounding Laramie
Treatment 6 (General Information - Enhanced Images): Respondents are shown general information about Laramie along visually enhanced images of downtown Laramie with placemaking improvements.
We will estimate treatment effects by regressing respondents’ self-reported scores on indicators for the treatment scenario they were randomly assigned to. We report results both without controls and with a set of demographic and socioeconomic controls. Outcome variables will be treated as continuous variables in baseline regressions. In conditional regressions, covariates include subject i) age, 2) gender, 3) dependents below the age of eighteen, 4) current living arrangement (owns their home, rents, or stays with friends and family), 5) household income, 6) employment status, 7) current work arrangement (fully remote, fully in-person or hybrid), 8) indicator for direct or indirect employment in the fossil-fuel industry, 9) entrepreneurial intent, 10) education, 11) intent to pursue higher education, and12) political ideology.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.