We evaluate an external personalized mentoring model integrated into public primary schools in Shanghai. Students will be stratified and randomly assigned to Treatment (mentor) or Control (business-as-usual). Treated students receive weekly one-on-one mentoring (academic/SEL support, study strategies, goal-setting, and home–school communication). Primary outcomes include standardized academic performance and non-cognitive skills, as well as expectations (all measured through parent, mentor, and teacher surveys and from course grades/exams).
Experimental design
Population & setting: Public primary schools in Shanghai; voluntary student sign-up coordinated through schools. Arms: Among those who show interest in participating in the program, we divide them into (i) Treatment: one-to-one mentoring, (ii) Control: business-as-usual. Students (grades 1–4 initially), plus matched parents/teachers/mentors for survey modules. Enrollment: Baseline surveys (student/parent/teacher) prior to randomization; administrative outcomes merged from school records. Intervention content: Academic support, strategy coaching (e.g., time management, error logs), socio-emotional skills, weekly goals. Mentors trained and supervised.
Design details
Randomization method
Stage 1 (T vs. C): Within each class, create 4 strata using gender × prior achievement (above/below median): female-low, female-high, male-low, male-high. Randomize within stratum to Treatment vs. Control.
Stage 2 (mentor matching for treated): Randomly assign mentors to treated students while balancing across strata and respecting mentor capacity. With 4 strata and mentor capacity = 5, fill 4 slots with one treated student sampled at random from each stratum; the 5th slot is drawn by a stratum-weighted random pick based on remaining availability, then a random treated student within that stratum
Randomization unit
Individual student (Stage 1: student-level T vs. C; Stage 2: student-level mentor assignment). Treatment is not clustered.
Clusters
0
Observations
It is uncertain at this stage, but we expect 197 participants in the first round. We expect to increase the number of participants in the following rounds.
Arms
We expect to repeat the treatment across different semesters/years/schools in the future to reach at least 500 in the control and 500 in the treatment group, but this is an approximation because it will depend on how many students agree to participate in the program.
Primary outcomes
Academic achievement: standardized school test scores, standardized to z-scores within grade/school/term.
Non-cognitive skills: student grit / acdemic expectations / socio-emotional skills / academic confidence/mental well-being/help-seeking behavior indices constructed from pre-/post-student/parent/mentor surveys. These outcomes will be measured in surveys to parents, mentors, teachers, and students themselves.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.