Willingness to pay for carbon abatement: institutional vs. retail investors in various contexts

How to cite

KROFT, BRAM VAN DER; Palacios, Juan; Rigobon, Roberto; Zheng, Siqi. 2025. "Willingness to pay for carbon abatement: institutional vs. retail investors in various contexts." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017176. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17176-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

BRAM VAN DER KROFT* , Juan Palacios , Roberto Rigobon , Siqi Zheng

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017176
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17176-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Withdrawn
Trial dates
2025-11-04 – 2026-05-13
Countries
United States of America (Massachusetts)
JEL codes
Q51 (Valuation of Environmental Effects), G11 (Portfolio Choice - Investment Decisions), G41(Behavioral Finance: Effects of Psychological, Social, Cognitive, and Emotional Factors on Decision Making)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17176

Abstract

We study how sustainability preferences differ between institutional asset owners, asset managers, and homeowners, focusing on their willingness to pay (WTP) for carbon abatement. While prior survey evidence on sustainable investing largely centers on retail investors’ stated motives, less is known about how professional investors and managers—who make sustainability decisions in practice—value carbon reductions when facing realistic trade-offs. Our game elicits WTP for a ton of carbon in two complementary ways: (1) through direct stated-preference questions and (2) through incentivized vignette choices that simulate realistically calibrated renovation decisions for representative US office or residential buildings. Comparing these elicitation methods allows us to measure how participants’ WTP to reduce carbon differs when it is explicitly presented as a carbon tax versus when it is implied through building renovation choices. We implement a between-subject design with four groups: (i) Asset managers, entities responsible for the day-to-day operations and asset management decisions, (ii) asset owners, institutional asset owner entities that own the asset but do not manage it directly (e.g., ABP, Norges), relying on third-party managers, (iii) asset owners and managers deciding on a residential renovation akin to their own home, and (iv) retail homeowners deciding on a renovation on their private property. This structure enables us to disentangle differences in the WTP gap across experience and expertise (institutional owner vs. asset managerial vs. homeowner), incentive settings (principal vs. agent), and socio-demographic characteristics. By combining elicitation modes with participant heterogeneity, our study sheds light on how professional experience and incentives shape the valuation of carbon reductions.

Intervention

In this experiment, we aim to assess whether participants have a different willingness to pay to reduce a ton of carbon under a directly stated carbon tax than when they make sustainable renovation choices and experience the trade-offs. We also want to study heterogeneity in a potential gap in WTP across owners vs. managers of assets, experience, principal or agent incentives, and socioeconomic differences. To this end, we assign institutional asset owners, homeowners, and asset managers to a setting where they either own or do not own the asset, in our paper, to a home or office setting. We then ask key demographic questions and assess their priors regarding (sustainable) renovation knowledge, return expectations, impact beliefs, and sustainable investment preferences. Following this, we conduct a vignette study in which participants are assigned to a representative building (commercial or residential) and asked to select the sustainability renovations to pursue in that building. We conducted this vignette study for a home (residential) or office building (commercial), and participants were presented with the financial, environmental (i.e., CO2 emissions), and health consequences of each renovation immediately. We then calibrate their willingness to pay for emission reductions and health consequences from these choices.

Experimental design

In this experiment, we aim to assess whether participants have a different willingness to pay to reduce a ton of carbon under a directly stated carbon tax than when they make sustainable renovation choices and experience the trade-offs. We also want to study heterogeneity in a potential gap in WTP across owners vs. managers of assets, experience, principal or agent incentives, and socioeconomic differences. To this end, we assign institutional asset owners, homeowners, and asset managers to a setting where they either own or do not own the asset, in our paper, to a home or office setting. We then ask key demographic questions and assess their priors regarding (sustainable) renovation knowledge, return expectations, impact beliefs, and sustainable investment preferences. Following this, we conduct a vignette study in which participants are assigned to a representative building (commercial or residential) and asked to select the sustainability renovations to pursue in that building. We conducted this vignette study for a home (residential) or office building (commercial), and participants were presented with the financial, environmental (i.e., CO2 emissions), and health consequences of each renovation immediately. We then calibrate their willingness to pay for emission reductions and health consequences from these choices.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer
Randomization unit
Person
Clusters
Sample size: planned number of clusters: We plan to have 4 clusters of observations. 1 group of institutional asset owners who make an office decision, 1 group of asset managers who make an office decision, 1 group of institutional asset owners & asset managers who make a house decision, and 1 group of homeowners who make a house decision.
Observations
For the first cluster, we strive to attain 100 to 150 institutional asset owner responses in the office setting. We have set up a collaboration with the Global Real Estate Sustainability Board (GRESB) and the Pension Real Estate Association (PREA), two of the largest trade unions among real estate investors in the US. They will help us distribute our survey. Furthermore, we collected a large number of email addresses of institutional asset owners through LinkedIn, providing a secondary source of prospective participants. For the second cluster of asset managers answering the office choice set, we similarly strive to attain 100 to 150 responses. We do this in collaboration with GreenBuild and the National Association of Real Estate Investment Trusts (NAREIT) trade associations. We similarly collected over 25,000 emails of REIT employees through LinkedIn that we will approach if our primary contacts do not deliver sufficient responses. For the third cluster, we will recruit approximately 300 participants via Prolific. There are randomly divided into the office and house setting with equal probability. We will sort on participants living in the United States, owning a home, working in the financial sector or real estate industry, with (if possible) a managerial role. For the last cluster, we aim to recruit 700 participants via Prolific. These participants should live in the United States, own a home, work in sectors other than the financial sector or real estate industry, and be as representative of the US average as possible.
Arms
For the first cluster, we strive to attain 100 to 150 institutional asset owner responses in the office setting. We have set up a collaboration with the Global Real Estate Sustainability Board (GRESB) and the Pension Real Estate Association (PREA), two of the largest trade unions among real estate investors in the US. They will help us distribute our survey. Furthermore, we collected a large number of email addresses of institutional asset owners through LinkedIn, providing a secondary source of prospective participants. For the second cluster of asset managers answering the office choice set, we similarly strive to attain 100 to 150 responses. We do this in collaboration with GreenBuild and the National Association of Real Estate Investment Trusts (NAREIT) trade associations. We similarly collected over 25,000 emails of REIT employees through LinkedIn that we will approach if our primary contacts do not deliver sufficient responses. For the third cluster, we will recruit approximately 300 participants via Prolific. There are randomly divided into the office and house setting with equal probability. We will sort on participants living in the United States, owning a home, working in the financial sector or real estate industry, with (if possible) a managerial role. For the last cluster, we aim to recruit 700 participants via Prolific. These participants should live in the United States, own a home, work in sectors other than the financial sector or real estate industry, and be as representative of the US average as possible.
Primary outcomes
Primary outcomes: • Participants’ willingness to pay for reducing a ton of CO2 and removing health outcomes in the vignette study • Participants’ willingness to pay for reducing a ton of CO2 in the carbon tax setting
Secondary outcomes
Supplementary outcomes: • Sustainable investing preferences, return expectations, and impact beliefs
Sponsors
Name: Dutch Science Foundation Location: Netherlands Url: https://www.nwo.nl/en Name: MIT Climate and Sustainability Consortium Location: Cambridge, MA Url: https://impactclimate.mit.edu/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords