Talent Allocation to Startups versus Incumbents: A Cross-Country Experiment for Germany and the United States

How to cite

Nüß, Patrick; Akcigit, Ufuk; Jeworrek, Sabrina; Miranda, Javier; Müller, Steffen; Wiederhold, Simon. 2025. "Talent Allocation to Startups versus Incumbents: A Cross-Country Experiment for Germany and the United States." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017172. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17172-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Patrick Nüß* , Ufuk Akcigit , Sabrina Jeworrek , Javier Miranda , Steffen Müller , Simon Wiederhold

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017172
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17172-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-11-13 – 2025-12-12
Countries
Germany (), United States of America ()
JEL codes
J22, J31, J81, M13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17172

Abstract

We outline the design of a cross-country experiment measuring talent allocation to startups in Germany and the United States. We combine a discrete-choice (job-choice) experiment, an elicitation of wage expectations, and an elicitation of perceived non-wage amenities to identify (i) workers’ willingness to pay (WTP) for job characteristics, (ii) perceived and actual reported differences in job characteristics between startups and established firms, and (iii) expected wage differentials by firm type. This design allows us to estimate the compensating wage differential required for high-skilled workers to be indifferent between working in a startup and an established company in each country.

Intervention

This study implements an online job-choice experiment to measure workers’ preferences over employment in different types of firms. Participants repeatedly choose between hypothetical job offers that vary in wages and selected non-wage working conditions. A key experimental feature is the randomized framing of firm type, which allows us to estimate whether workers assign an independent value to working in startups compared to established firms (or closely related firm-type dimensions). Based on participants’ choices, we estimate WTP for firm type and for non-wage attributes. We further elicit respondents’ expectations about wages and working conditions across firm types. Together, these measures allow us to quantify how preferences and beliefs shape the attractiveness of startups relative to established firms, and how this differs between Germany and the United States.

Experimental design

We conduct a stated-preference job-choice experiment that allows us to estimate workers’ WTP for different job characteristics and for employment in different types of firms. Each respondent first answers a short module about their current employment situation. We use this information to anchor hypothetical job offers relative to the respondent’s current job.

Participants are then presented with a series of ten binary job-choice tasks. In each task, respondents choose between two hypothetical jobs that differ in monetary compensation and a small subset of non-wage job characteristics. To reduce cognitive load, only a limited number of characteristics vary within each choice pair to differences in wage and two amenities. Wage levels are directly tied to the respondent’s reported current wage, with proportional upward or downward variation within a bounded range.

A key feature of the experiment is the randomized framing of firm type. Respondents are randomly assigned to one of two framing conditions that describe either (i) a “startup vs. established firm” comparison or (ii) a 2×2 framing with Young/Old and Innovative/Not Innovative. This randomization enables us to identify whether respondents place intrinsic value on working in startups beyond the specific job attributes themselves.

After the discrete-choice module, we elicit expected wages by firm type (at hire and after 3 years) and perceived amenity differences by firm type, and collect demographics/background information. These additional measures allow us to compare preferences to beliefs, evaluate heterogeneity across worker groups, and assess how preferences and perceptions jointly shape the attractiveness of startups relative to established firms.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization by a computer
Randomization unit
1. Between-subjects: firm-type framing (Group A vs. Group B). 2. Within-subject: randomized attribute profiles across the 10 binary choice tasks.
Clusters
1. 10,000 individual choices, 5,000 individuals per country 2. 100,000 individual choices over hypothetical jobs
Observations
10,000 individuals × 10 choices = 100,000 choice observations.
Arms
1/3 of the sample receives the startup vs. established firm framing, 2/3 receive the framing with firm age and innovativeness. ≈3,333 individuals (≈33,330 choices firm-type framing Group A). ≈6,666 individuals (≈66,660 choices firm-type framing Group B).
Primary outcomes
1. WTP to work at a startup (vs. an established firm), estimated from a discrete choice experiment (10 binary job choices per respondent). 2. Expected differences in wages and working conditions between startups and established firms. 3. Implied compensating wage differential for workers to be indifferent between working in a startup and an established firm, computed by combining primary outcomes 1 and 2.
Secondary outcomes
Heterogeneity in WTP and in implied compensating differentials by: country (Germany vs. U.S.), gender, age, STEM field, migration background, risk tolerance, patience, current job-loss concerns, own startup experience, strength of entrepreneurial orientation in the respondent’s environment, and East vs. West Germany (if sample size permits).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords