Performance Observability and Feedback Avoidance among Pupils

How to cite

Riener, Gerhard; Agarwal, Garima. 2025. "Performance Observability and Feedback Avoidance among Pupils." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017152. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17152-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Gerhard Riener* , Garima Agarwal

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017152
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17152-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-11-01 – 2026-04-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, D83, J16, I21
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17152

Abstract

This preregistration describes a field experiment implemented on the Maidaan educational platform in India. The study examines how feedback observability (anonymous vs. public) and task difficulty (easy vs. hard) jointly affect students’ willingness to engage in an additional learning opportunity. The experiment follows a 2×2 factorial design, implemented over four tournament waves between November 2025 and January 2026. This updated version integrates referee feedback, removes the prior control condition, and adds placeholders for pending operational details.
This section draws on the original preregistration’s discussion of ego-utility and feedback avoidance mechanisms. In many learning and selection environments, performance is publicly observable. Ego-utility theories predict that when performance feedback is public and diagnostic, individuals self-protect by avoiding tasks or reducing effort to shield beliefs about their ability (Kőszegi, 2006; Möbius et al., 2022). These mechanisms are especially relevant for school-aged children in competitive digital environments, such as the Maidaan platform.
Understanding how feedback visibility affects motivation is crucial for digital learning environments. Publicly observable performance can enhance social learning but may also create ego concerns that reduce participation, especially after poor results. This experiment explores these mechanisms in a naturalistic setting, leveraging the Maidaan platform’s large student base and regular quiz tournaments.

Intervention

Students participating in academic quiz tournaments on the Maidaan digital learning platform are invited to take part in an additional voluntary “practice” round. The invitation message and feedback display vary in how performance information is presented (publicly or anonymously) and in how the difficulty of the practice round is labeled (easy or hard). The study examines how different formats of feedback and task framing affect students’ willingness to engage in further learning activities.

Experimental design

The study is a 2×2 randomized field experiment implemented on the Maidaan educational platform in India with students in grades 3–9. After completing a regular academic quiz tournament, students receive a standardized WhatsApp message inviting them to play a short, optional “bonus practice round.” The experiment varies two features of this invitation:
(1) Feedback observability — whether performance on the bonus round is displayed publicly on the leaderboard or anonymously, and
(2) Task difficulty label — whether the bonus round is described as easy or hard.
Participation in the bonus round is entirely voluntary. The main outcome is whether students choose to play. The study examines how different ways of presenting feedback and difficulty influence students’ willingness to re-engage with learning tasks.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization occurs at the individual level within each wave, using stratified block randomization (block size = 4, one student per arm). Stratification variables: school, grade, gender, performance tier {Final Rank, DNQ narrow, DNQ large, DNP}, school_type (contract/non-contract), and pool. Returning students are re-randomized independently in each wave; prior assignments are not carried forward. We will record the treatment sequence participants were exposed to and control for previous treatments.
Randomization unit
Individual student. Randomization is conducted at the individual level within each tournament wave. Stratified block randomization (block size = 4; one student per treatment arm) is implemented within strata defined by school, grade, gender, performance tier (Final Rank, DNQ narrow, DNQ large, DNP), school type (contract/non-contract), and pool. Returning students are re-randomized independently in each wave (Nov 1, Nov 15, Jan 10, Jan 31 – 2025/26). Analyses account for repeated participation by clustering standard errors at the individual level and using school fixed effects.
Clusters
67 schools. The experiment includes approximately 67 distinct schools (7 contract schools and 60 non-contract schools) participating across four tournament waves, with an average of 80–120 students per school per wave.
Observations
Approximately 20,000 student-wave observations (≈ 5,000 unique students × 4 waves). Each student is randomized in up to four tournament waves between November 2025 and January 2026. The expected total includes both contract and non-contract school participants from 67 schools. Analyses will pool all wave-level observations and cluster standard errors at the school and individual levels.
Arms
Public × Easy: ≈ 5,000 student-wave observations (≈1,250 per wave; students from all 67 schools) Public × Hard: ≈ 5,000 student-wave observations (≈1,250 per wave; students from all 67 schools) Anonymous × Easy: ≈ 5,000 student-wave observations (≈1,250 per wave; students from all 67 schools) Anonymous × Hard: ≈ 5,000 student-wave observations (≈1,250 per wave; students from all 67 schools)
Primary outcomes
opt-in to the bonus round (categorical: 3=finished, 2=started 1=clicked to play, 0=did not). Main interest is binary (3 vs 0).
Secondary outcomes
(conditional on opt-in): bonus-round performance (score and accuracy), engagement with leaderboards (Leaderboard’ and ‘Your Stats’ tabs), and the timing of opt-in (minutes/hours post-message). Engagement data are derived from Maidaan backend logs where available.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords