Building Teacher Capacity or Outsourcing Pedagogy? Experimental Evidence from Science Education Reform
How to cite
Sahoo, Soham; Prakash, Nishith; Gautam, Santosh K.; Gomez, Ariel; Kumar, Sandeep; Jha, Vinay Kumar. 2025. "Building Teacher Capacity or Outsourcing Pedagogy? Experimental Evidence from Science Education Reform." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017098. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17098-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Skills such as curiosity and critical thinking enable students to explore ideas and adapt to change, yet fostering these skills in low-capacity public schools remains difficult. This study evaluates two delivery models for curiosity-based science education through a randomized controlled trial in 150 government middle schools and 7,185 students in rural Uttar Pradesh, India. In the teacher-training model, government science teachers receive intensive workshops and coaching to integrate inquiry-driven pedagogy, while in the external-instructor model, trained facilitators deliver the same ten-session curriculum directly to students. Both use identical, syllabus-aligned content grounded in cognitive science research on curiosity and metacognition. The experiment tests whether reforms should build internal teacher capacity or rely on external agents for implementation, situating this comparison in the realities of public systems characterized by workload constraints, hierarchical structures, and limited instructional support.
Intervention
We evaluate two delivery models for curiosity-based science education in government middle schools in rural Uttar Pradesh, India. The intervention introduces a ten-session, hands-on science curriculum—developed in partnership with the Agastya International Foundation—that promotes inquiry, experimentation, and reflection using low-cost, locally available materials.
In the Teacher Training (T1) arm, regular government science teachers receive multi-day in-person workshops and ongoing coaching from the implementing partner Ecoprism. The training focuses on integrating curiosity-based pedagogy into regular classroom instruction, modeling active-learning techniques, and supporting teachers through moderated peer groups.
In the External Instructor (T2) arm, trained Ecoprism facilitators directly deliver the same ten lessons to students during school hours while regular teachers continue standard instruction. This model allows high-fidelity delivery independent of teacher capacity constraints.
Both interventions use identical curricular content and implementation materials, differing only in who delivers the instruction. The design isolates two common policy approaches in education reform—building internal teacher capacity versus outsourcing delivery to specialized external agents—and measures their relative effects on student curiosity, critical thinking, growth mindset, and learning outcomes.
Experimental design
The study uses a cluster-randomized controlled trial with randomization at the school level. Randomization is stratified by administrative block. A total of 150 government middle schools in Fatehpur district, Uttar Pradesh, are randomly assigned to one of three groups:
Treatment 1 (Teacher Training) – science teachers receive in-person workshops and ongoing coaching to integrate curiosity-based, inquiry-driven pedagogy.
Treatment 2 (External Instructor) – trained facilitators from the implementing partner deliver the same ten-session curiosity curriculum directly to students.
Control – business-as-usual classroom instruction with no exposure to the new curriculum.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.