Households' economic response to their perceived income uncertainty

How to cite

Chen, Xiaoting(Jasmine). 2025. "Households' economic response to their perceived income uncertainty." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017079. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17079-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Xiaoting(Jasmine) Chen*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017079
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17079-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-11-17 – 2026-01-29
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D14, E21, D12, D84
Secondary IDs
D81, C91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17079

Abstract

How do households perceive their income uncertainty over the next 12 months? How does their subjective uncertainty shape their consumption, saving, and debt repayment? To address these questions, I combine existing survey data from the Bundesbank Online Household Panel (BOP-HH, 2022–2025) with a within-subject randomized information experiment. The subjective uncertainty variable uses a pre-existing income density question where respondents allocate probabilities across income-change bins. The information treatment is designed to measure how households adjust spending, saving, and debt repayment in response to (1) varying magnitudes of perceived income risk and (2) ambiguous uncertainty about future income. The design follows a mean-preserving-spread framework, where households face scenarios with identical expected income but different income variances. Subsequently, the known probability condition is removed, and participants are asked to make financial allocation decisions based on their own subjective income distribution. The study quantifies the precautionary saving motive implied by buffer-stock models and assesses how risk and ambiguity amplify households’ marginal propensity to consume, save, and repay debt. The findings will inform behavioral models of household finance and guide macroeconomic policy communication that accounts for perceived uncertainty.

Intervention

The first question starts by collecting respondents' current household income allocation decisions. Afterwards, everyone received a guaranteed income as the control group. The third question randomly split the whole sample into four groups. Two groups received a risk preference question and another two groups received an uncertainty ambiguity preference question. From the fourth question to the fifth question, whole sample will be randomized into two treatment groups (4 sub-groups).

Treatment group 1: Perceived income risk treatment
- Respondents are shown hypothetical income distributions with identical expected values but different variances (low vs. high).
- Treatment assignment randomizes the order and presentation of these distributions within subjects.
Treamnet group 2: Perceived uncertainty ambiguity treatment
- Respondents face scenarios without explicit probabilities for income outcomes, requiring them to rely on their own subjective beliefs.
- This condition identifies behavioral responses to uncertainty under ambiguity.

Experimental design

This study is a randomized survey experiment. The study aims to understand how households’ consumption, saving, debt repayment resposnese under income risk and uncertainty, seperately. The experiment is implemented within a national representative household online panel. Each respondent completes a series of income allocation under three conditions: a guaranteed-income (certainty) scenario, a known-risk scenario with small and big income shock, and an ambiguous-income scenario.

At the start of the survey, respondents are randomly assigned at the individual level to four groups. Two groups are risk groups in which income over the next 12 months follow mean-preserving spread with equal probability. For example, respondents are told that their household income will be x% higher or lower than their current household income, with equal probabilty for both scenorios. Between these two risk groups, one group will received smaller income shock another with will received bigger shock.
Another two groups are ambiguity groups, in which probabilities are not disclosed. Respondents only know the size of their income variace but need to make decision based on the distribution in their mind. The uncertainty questions follow after knowing equal probability for anchoring people firstly under the certainty situation. All respondents first report baseline allocations under prior and certainty. Meanwhile, they can all the time see what they answered under certainty situation. Afterwards, respodents will face the risk and ambiguity preference questions.

The control condition corresponds to the certain-income scenario, providing a within-respondent benchmark. Behavioral responses are captured as the change in the share of income allocated to saving, consumption, and debt repayment between the certain and uncertain conditions. The main hypotheses are: (i) households increase saving (and reduce consumption) under known income risk relative to certainty, consistent with a precautionary saving motive; (ii) the same or stronger response occurs under ambiguity, consistent with ambiguity aversion; and (iii) the adjustment under ambiguity is at least as large as under risk.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization is performed automatically within the survey platform implemented by the professional survey company Forsa. Respondents are randomly assigned to one of four treatment groups (risk-low variance, risk-high variance, ambiguity-low variance, ambiguity-high variance) at the start of the preference elicitation module. The assignment will be done by Forsa to ensure balanced group sizes across condition.
Randomization unit
Individual respondents
Clusters
NA
Observations
The Bundesbank wil recurit around 3,000 respondents. However, the respondents can choose to answer or not to answer questions.
Arms
Group 1 (750 respondents): small income variance Group 2 (750 respondents): big income variance Group 3 (750 respondents): small income variance + uncertainty Group 4 (750 respondents): large income variance + uncertainty
Primary outcomes
Each outcome variable is constructed as the self-reported percentage share of total household income (normalized to 100) allocated to consumption, saving, and debt repayment. For each respondent, we compute differences in these allocation shares across the certainty, risk, and ambiguity conditions. These within-individual changes are interpreted as behavioral responses to (i) known income risk (variance-based uncertainty) and (ii) ambiguous income uncertainty (unknown probabilities). The key constructed measures are: • ΔSaving (risk) = Saving under risk – Saving under certainty • ΔSaving (ambiguity) = Saving under ambiguity – Saving under certainty Similar difference measures are constructed for consumption and debt repayment. These indicators serve as behavioral proxies for the precautionary saving motive and ambiguity aversion.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords