Evaluating nudge policies in sales processes of high risk financial products
How to cite
Roh, Seongmin; Choi, Syngjoo; Choi, Jaewon; Yoon, Chamna; Hong, Changdeok; Han, Heewon. 2025. "Evaluating nudge policies in sales processes of high risk financial products." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017068. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17068-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Equity-Linked Securities (ELS) are high risk structured notes linked to multiple indices, and the recent plunge in the Hang Seng China Enterprises Index (HSCEI) triggered substantial retail losses, underscoring the need for clearer disclosure and bias mitigating information design. This study examines, in the field, whether such information changes real subscription decisions. The Financial Supervisory Service and one of the largest commercial banks co-design and advise the trial. Implementation takes place at bank branches, and outcome evaluation is conducted at Seoul National University.
Sixty branches are cluster randomized into four arms (A, B, C, D, 15 per arm). Arm A maintains business as usual. Arm B appends an amended profit loss(P&L) chart that front loads loss information and corrects scale distortions. Arm C appends a within ELS comparison that, under identical underlying and fee conditions, displays first barriers alongside the associated coupons, early redemption likelihoods, and loss ranges. Arm D appends a side by side comparison of ELS versus principal protected ELB/DLB. The analysis focuses on KRW-denominated ELS combining KOSPI200, S&P500, and EUROSTOXX50. These are the bank’s highest risk grade products and, under suitability rules, are eligible only for customers with the most aggressive investor profile. Product menus are uniform by date across branches.
The intervention runs for three months. We track behavioral changes in risk-taking, transaction scale, immediate deterrence, post-execution reassessment, and shifts toward safer substitution and diversification. Primary outcomes are the annualized coupon rate (%), the first barrier, and the contract amount (KRW). Pre-specified heterogeneity for seniors (65+, a policy defined vulnerable group) and repeat ELS subscribers identifies for whom the information is most effective. Whereas prior work on structured products has largely relied on lab experiments with synthetic instruments, this regulator bank field RCT observes real products and real purchases, isolating the effect of information framing under a common menu and providing quantitative evidence for reducing high risk choices and supporting standardized disclosure materials.
Intervention
This study investigates whether presenting additional explanatory materials on top of the standard product brochure affects customers’ investment decisions when purchasing Equity-Linked Securities (ELS), a high risk financial product. Sixty branches are randomly assigned to four groups (A to D), with 15 branches per group. Arm A serves as the control and maintains business as usual, while Arms B, C, and D receive the interventions described below. All activities take place at the bank’s trust product sales counters. The study focuses on KRW denominated ELS sold during the intervention period whose underlying structure combines KOSPI200, S&P500, and Eurostoxx50. To comply with regulatory requirements for investment solicitation, the added materials are delivered uniformly by supplementing the standard brochure with an additional explanatory insert, and data are collected from transactions during the three month intervention window.
The first intervention addresses potential behavioral biases induced by the profit and loss (P&L) charts commonly used in bank presentations and emphasizes the salience of potential losses when customers consider subscribing to ELS. In existing brochures, the chart at times uses inconsistent or split vertical scales between gain and loss regions, which can lead investors to overestimate gains and underestimate risks. Such design can trigger probability misjudgments and create a dark nudge toward overstating upside and understating downside. The intervention therefore presents loss information first, corrects scale distortions by using consistent axes for gains and losses, and clarifies labels and annotations (for example, explicitly noting that “8.2 percent per annum” is an annualized rate and adding plain language explanations for states such as early redemption success or failure).
The second intervention provides a comparative table across ELS variants, highlighting that higher first barrier levels imply a lower likelihood of early redemption and therefore higher risk. For multiple underlying, high risk ELS, a higher barrier typically offers a higher fixed coupon yet comes with greater risk, and this trade off should be made explicit. Existing sales routines often rely on historical simulations for individual products and do not clearly convey the systematic relation between barrier levels and redemption probabilities. The insert therefore summarizes, under identical underlying and fee conditions, key items by first barrier level, namely 75, 80, 85, and 90. It presents the fixed coupon, the loss range, the barrier level, and the historical probability of first redemption in a single table for side by side comparison.
The third intervention introduces a comparative table between ELS and ELB/DLB. Whereas the second intervention compares barrier levels within ELS, the third contrasts ELS that are not principal protected with ELB/DLB that are principal protected, which are relatively safer except under extraordinary circumstances such as issuer default during a severe financial crisis. Previously, there was no explicit guideline requiring advisors to present principal protected alternatives alongside ELS. This intervention therefore presents, in one place, a comparison of fixed return, loss range, redemption conditions, underlying assets, and risk grades, enabling customers to clearly understand the risk and return differences between ELS and ELB/DLB.
Experimental design
[Group Assignment and Treatment Overview]
We conduct a field study with 60 sales branches of Customer Bank, organized into four groups (A to D) with 15 branches per group.
Control (A) maintains business as usual, and staff are not informed about the experiment.
Treatment 1 (B) appends to the standard brochure an amended profit and loss chart that presents loss information first and corrects scale distortions.
Treatment 2 (C) adds an ELS comparison table clarifying that a higher first barrier raises the fixed coupon but lowers the probability of early redemption and widens the loss range.
Treatment 3 (D) appends a comparison table between ELS and principal protected products (ELB, DLB) to make risk and return differences clear.
[Sales procedures and supplemental information timing]
All branches follow the same baseline counseling flow. Upon visit, staff assess the customer’s risk profile and determine the investor suitability grade before recommending products. The ELS products studied are the bank’s highest risk grade and, under suitability rules, are eligible only for customers with the most aggressive investor profile. In treatment branches, during recommendation and brochure explanation, staff present the group specific supplemental insert alongside the standard brochure and use it in counseling. Apart from the group specific materials, all other sales procedures remain unchanged.
[Weekly cycle of experimental progress]
The weekly cycle for the supplemental inserts is as follows. Each Monday, the bank finalizes the product lineup for the following week; on Tuesday, the bank sends the product list to the research team. On Wednesday, the research team returns the supplemental inserts to the bank. After the bank obtains the regulatory document review, Friday features distribution of group appropriate brochures to staff (control materials for A and supplemental versions for B, C, and D). The following Monday, products launch, and staff use the distributed group specific brochures in on site sales and counseling.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.