Communication Frictions and the Gender Gap in Access to Credit

How to cite

Neshat, Navid; Kim, Yongseok. 2025. "Communication Frictions and the Gender Gap in Access to Credit." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017067. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17067-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Navid Neshat* , Yongseok Kim

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017067
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17067-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-11-15 – 2026-06-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
G2, J16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17067

Abstract

This study explores how gender affects communication between borrowers and lenders. In partnership with a bank in Afghanistan, we invited micro-entrepreneurs to apply for small loans. The application collects standard financial information, and it also gives borrowers the opportunity to write a message to the loan officer explaining, in their own words, why their ability and willingness to repay can be trusted. Each applicant can provide one explanation addressed to a male loan officer and one addressed to a female loan officer. Providing financial information is mandatory, but writing a message is optional. By analyzing the narratives written by the same applicant, we assess whether individuals—and particularly female applicants—communicate differently when the message is directed to an opposite-gender loan officer. Next, we recruit loan officers to evaluate the applications and test whether the marginal value of borrower narratives is lower when they communicate with opposite gender. These findings will allow us to evaluate whether gender-based communication barriers contribute to disparities in access to finance and whether increasing the number of female loan officers could help reduce these gaps.

Intervention

This study examines how borrowers’ written communication in small-loan applications influences loan officers’ evaluations and actual lending outcomes at a partner bank. Eligible micro-entrepreneurs complete standardized, collateral-free loan applications that include a short narrative describing their ability and willingness to repay. Each applicant can provide one narrative addressed to a male loan officer and one addressed to a female loan officer. All applications are anonymized before review so that loan officers cannot see any borrower identifiers. Loan officers evaluate applications using the bank’s regular scoring procedures, and loan decisions are based on these evaluations. After the evaluation phase, officers complete a short follow-up survey about their review experience. Some details of the study design are temporarily withheld to preserve research integrity and will be made public once data collection and analysis are complete.

Experimental design

This study examines how written communication in loan applications affects how applicants are perceived by loan officers. We collaborate with a financial institution to collect anonymized loan applications that include a short open-ended section where borrowers describe their credibility and repayment ability. Professional loan officers evaluate these applications, and the bank’s lending decisions are based on these evaluations. To protect privacy, all applications are anonymized before review, and loan officers cannot see any borrower information that reveals gender or identity. The study aims to better understand how borrower communication influences officers’ assessments. More details of the study are temporarily withheld to preserve the integrity of the research and will be made public once the study concludes.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is conducted in the office using a computer program.
Randomization unit
Borrower-level randomization: The gender of the officer shown to applicants (“male officer” vs. “female officer”) is randomized at the individual borrower application level. Officer–application-level randomization: The narrative visibility condition (“Narrative Visible” vs. “Narrative Concealed”) is randomized independently for each officer–application pair. Officer-level randomization: In the post-evaluation survey stage, whether borrower gender is revealed in the officer’s feedback report (“Gender Revealed” vs. “Gender Hidden”) is randomized at the officer level.
Clusters
Approximately 600 borrower applications (individual-level randomization, not clustered) and 50 loan officers (clustered randomization for post-evaluation survey stage).
Observations
150*50=7500 application-officer
Arms
Borrower-level treatment (unit = application; not clustered) Officer gender shown = Male: Planned invitations: 300 borrowers (≈ half female, half male overall sample stratified by borrower gender) Expected completed applications: ≈250 Officer gender shown = Female: Planned invitations: 300 Expected completed applications: ≈250 Note: Total invitations = 600 (300 female, 300 male). Expected completed applications ≈ 500 in total, with ≈ 250 per arm. ************ Officer–application condition (unit = officer–application evaluation; not clustered) Narrative Visible: approximately 50 percent of officer–application evaluations Narrative Concealed: approximately 50 percent of officer–application evaluations Exact counts depend on the final number of evaluations per application. The split is designed to be 1:1 across all officer–application observations. ************ Post-evaluation survey treatment (unit = loan officer; clustered at officer level) Borrower gender revealed in officer report: 25 clusters (officers) Borrower gender hidden in officer report: 25 clusters (officers) Total officers = 50, randomly assigned 25/25 across the two survey arms.
Primary outcomes
Evaluation Score (Likert scale, 1 to 10)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords