Tackling Biased Beliefs to Foster Women’s Entry into Economics: Experimental Evidence from Mexico

How to cite

Maldonado, Stanislao; Naranjo, Elvira; Chapa, Joana. 2025. "Tackling Biased Beliefs to Foster Women’s Entry into Economics: Experimental Evidence from Mexico." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017053. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17053-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Stanislao Maldonado* , Elvira Naranjo , Joana Chapa

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017053
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17053-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-02-02 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, I23, J16, D83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17053

Abstract

Economics remains one of the most gender-imbalanced academic fields, with women systematically underrepresented among students and professionals. In Mexico, as in many other countries, female students make up less than one-third of economics majors, reflecting persistent stereotypes about the discipline’s technical nature and limited social relevance. Recent behavioral economics research suggests that such disparities are not solely the result of structural barriers but also stem from motivated beliefs—psychologically grounded misperceptions about one’s own abilities and the character of the field. Women often underestimate their quantitative competence and perceive economics as disconnected from social impact, even when evidence contradicts these views.

This project evaluates the causal impact of an in-person female role model intervention designed to correct these misperceptions and foster greater interest in economics among high-school students in Nuevo León, Mexico. The intervention consists of interactive classroom sessions in which trained female economists share their professional experiences, highlight the social dimensions of economics, and address common stereotypes related to gender and quantitative ability.

The study leverages the networks of the Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León (UANL) and the Tecnológico de Monterrey, encompassing 31 affiliated high schools and over 45,000 students. Within each participating school, six classroom groups enrolled in the Proyecto de Vida course are selected, and treatment is randomized at the group level (three treatment, three control). This within-school randomization design allows identification of causal effects while controlling for institutional and contextual heterogeneity.

By integrating psychological insights about belief formation with field-experimental methods, the study contributes to understanding how exposure to relatable female role models can reshape gendered beliefs about economics. Outcomes include students’ perceptions of the field, self-assessed quantitative abilities, and stated intentions to pursue economics or related majors. The findings will shed light on the mechanisms—belief updating, identity alignment, and stereotype reduction—through which early interventions can reduce gender disparities in economics education and inspire broader participation in the discipline.

Intervention

We propose an in-person role model intervention designed to address women's misperceptions and beliefs regarding economics and their quantitative abilities. By engaging students at a critical stage in their educational trajectory—just before university application decisions—the intervention aims to reshape beliefs about economics as a field and strengthen students' confidence in their own quantitative skills.

The intervention consists of a single, interactive classroom session led by trained female economists. During these in-person visits, role models will deliver a comprehensive 45–60 minute session that combines the sharing of personal narratives, the projection of informative videos, guided reflection exercises, and structured information delivery. Each session will take place during the Proyecto de Vida course, which focuses on students' personal development and career planning. This format ensures high participation rates and curricular relevance, while allowing discussions to unfold in a psychologically safe and familiar classroom environment.

Experimental design

The study implements a clustered randomized controlled trial (RCT) to evaluate the impact of an in-person female role-model intervention on high-school students’ beliefs, aspirations, and application decisions regarding economics.

The experiment will take place in 29 upper-secondary schools in the Monterrey metropolitan area: 24 affiliated with the Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León (UANL) and 5 with the Tecnológico de Monterrey (Tec).
Randomization occurs at two levels:

School-level assignment: half of the schools are randomly allocated to the treatment group (receiving the intervention) and half to the control group (business-as-usual).

Classroom-level assignment within treated schools: in each treated school, six Proyecto de Vida classroom groups are selected; three are randomly assigned to receive the intervention and three remain untreated to allow measurement of within-school spillovers.

The intervention is delivered during the Proyecto de Vida course in February–April 2026. Each 45–60 minute session is led by trained female economists and combines personal narratives, interactive discussion, and information about economics as a socially relevant discipline.

Data will be collected at baseline, immediately after the intervention, and approximately two months later.
Primary outcomes relate to actual applications to economics programs, while secondary outcomes measure beliefs, aspirations, and identity alignment.

Analyses will follow the intention-to-treat (ITT) principle, clustering standard errors at the school level, and will use ANCOVA specifications controlling for baseline outcomes

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was conducted centrally by computer using a blocked and re-randomized procedure. At the first stage, schools were randomly assigned to treatment or control using computer-generated random numbers, stratified by university network (UANL vs. Tecnológico de Monterrey). At the second stage, within each treated school, three of six classroom groups in the Proyecto de Vida course were randomly selected to receive the intervention. The algorithm followed the Morgan and Rubin (2012) re-randomization approach, repeating the assignment until standardized mean differences across treatment arms in key baseline covariates (gender composition, GPA, and baseline beliefs) were below 0.25 standard deviations. All randomization was implemented by the research team at the coordinating university, using Stata’s random-number generator (set seed recorded) to ensure reproducibility
Randomization unit
The experiment uses a two-level randomization design: School level (primary unit): Schools are the main clusters for treatment assignment. Half of the participating schools are randomly assigned to the treatment condition and half to the control group. Classroom level (secondary unit within treated schools): In each treated school, six classroom groups from the Proyecto de Vida course are selected, with three classrooms randomly assigned to receive the intervention and three left untreated to allow measurement of within-school spillover effects. Accordingly, the study’s units of randomization are schools and classroom groups, with clustering of standard errors at the school level during analysis
Clusters
The study includes a total of 29 schools (clusters): 24 schools affiliated with the Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León (UANL) 5 schools affiliated with the Tecnológico de Monterrey (Tec) Within each treated school, 6 classroom groups from the Proyecto de Vida course will participate in the study (3 treated and 3 untreated), yielding a total of 174 classroom groups across all schools
Observations
The main field experiment will include approximately 5,220 students across 29 schools. This estimate assumes an average of 6 classroom groups per school, each with roughly 30 students (29 × 6 × 30 ≈ 5,220). In addition, a laboratory subsample of around 200 students (10 sessions with 20 participants each, balanced by treatment and gender) will participate in incentive-compatible behavioral tasks designed to measure psychological mechanisms such as belief updating, competitiveness, and aspirations. Thus, the total planned number of individual observations across both components is approximately 5,400 students
Arms
School-level assignment: 14 schools assigned to the treatment arm (schools that implement the in-person female role model intervention). 15 schools assigned to the control arm (schools that continue with regular curriculum and receive no intervention during the study period). Classroom-level assignment within treated schools: In each treated school, 6 classroom groups in the Proyecto de Vida course are selected. Of these: 3 classrooms per treated school are assigned to receive the in-person intervention session. 3 classrooms per treated school are not treated (to measure within-school spillovers). This yields approximately 42 treated classrooms and 42 untreated classrooms within treated schools (14 schools × 3 classrooms per status)
Primary outcomes
Primary Outcomes (End Points) The primary outcome is the proportion of students who apply to an undergraduate economics program during the 2026 admissions cycle (April–June 2026). This outcome is measured using administrative records from the participating universities (Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León and Tecnológico de Monterrey), complemented where necessary with application-system logs (file creation and submission flags). This behavioral endpoint directly captures the intervention’s main objective: whether exposure to female role models increases the likelihood that female students apply to study economics. It will be analyzed as a binary indicator (1 = applied to economics program; 0 = did not apply) using a difference-in-differences framework comparing treated and control schools across cohorts
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes capture the belief- and identity-based mechanisms through which exposure to female role models may influence students’ aspirations and application decisions. These outcomes are measured using standardized survey instruments administered at three points in time: (i) baseline (pre-visit), (ii) short-term endline (immediately after the classroom session), and (iii) long-term endline (8–10 weeks later). Each domain is summarized as a standardized z-score index to improve statistical power and reduce multiple-testing concerns. The pre-specified secondary outcome domains are: Intentions and Aspirations – students’ academic intentions, likelihood of applying to economics, perceived family support, and perceived affordability of studying economics. Beliefs about Economics – understanding of what economists do, perceived social relevance of the field, and rejection of the belief that economics is only about money or finance. Identity Alignment and Self-Concept – perceived fit between self and the discipline of economics, identification with economists, comfort with studying economics, and self-assessed analytical ability relative to peers. Gender Stereotypes and Perceived Barriers – endorsement of gender stereotypes (“men are naturally better at economics”), perceived discrimination in economics-related careers, and ability to name female economists. All indices are computed so that higher scores indicate more inclusive or pro-equality attitudes, greater confidence, or stronger alignment with economics as a field

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords