The Impact of Technology on Electoral Participation in South Africa
How to cite
McIntosh, Craig; Long, James D.; Jung, Danielle F.; Gibson, Clark; Ferree, Karen. 2016. "The Impact of Technology on Electoral Participation in South Africa." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001705. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1705-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Can new technology be used to improve the quality of democracy by boosting citizen participation? In this paper we report on the VIP:Voice platform, which was constructed to allow South African citizens to engage politically through an ICT platform, to report on political events in their communities, and to monitor their polling places on election day. We sent out over 50 million 'Please Call Me' messages encouraging South Africans to register on the system, and provided a multi-channel platform allowing citizens to engage politically via low-tech mobile phones and high-tech social media. We find starkly different demographic profiles of users across channels, indicating that the success of efforts to overcome marginalization using ICT will be partially determined by the technological channel used. Attrition of users across each step in the engagement process is high, and while thousands of citizens are willing to engage in costly political actions based only on intrinsic motivation, extrinsic incentives induce large increases in participation rates. Using the platform, we were able to recruit citizen volunteers willing to monitor 12 percent of the polling stations in 38 percent of the wards in the country.
Intervention
Phase 1: Individuals were encouraged to register for the platform and were either required to pay all associated fees (messaging costs, etc.) themselves (standard arm); were promised to have their interaction fees covered (free arm); or were entered into a lottery for R55 when they registered (lottery arm).
Phase 2: All respondents were asked to complete five separate pre-election surveys. Participants completed a brief set of demographic questions, a "What's Up?" survey about local campaign activities; the "VIP" survey which was a standard set of polling questions; a "Push" survey about local political activities; and a "Thermometer" survey about voting intentions.
Phase 3: Individuals who registered as volunteer COs were either offered R5 or R50 as an incentive to complete their tasks. The set of tasks expected of COs involved returning to polling stations on the day after the election to observe whether or not a tally sheet had been posted, to submit information about the tally via SMS, and, if equipped with a phone that could take photos, to take a photograph of the results sheet.
Phase 4: Individuals were reminded to vote with one of three messages: a simple reminder which acted as the control; a reminder plus an 'intrinsic' message which included reference to the "voice" dimension of political participation; or a reminder plus an 'extrinsic' treatment which included a message reminding citizens that their inked finger would show others that they had voted (visibility), designed to activate considerations of social pressure to vote. Two surveys were also given in Phase 4 - one of voter experience at polling stations (with free participation), and a second post-election survey to gauge satisfaction with the electoral process (incentivized with a lottery).
Experimental design
Researchers designed and deployed a unique ICT/DM platform to conduct series of experiments during South Africa's 2014 national election. In Phase 1, one month before the election, researchers recruited South African citizens into the ICT/DM platform. In Phase 2, respondents completed a series of demographic and election related surveys. Phase 3 included recruiting a set of volunteers from the initial respondents to serve as Citizen Observers (COs) on voting day. In Phase 4, researchers implemented a Get Out the Vote (GOTV) reminder experiment, accompanied by two surveys.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Ferree, Karen, Clark Gibson, Danielle Jung, James Long and Craig McIntosh. "Using Technology to Promote Participation in Emerging Democracies: VIP:Voice and the 2014 South African Election." Working Paper, November 2015. https://www.povertyactionlab.org/sites/default/files/publications/3899%20Technology%20and%20Participation%20in%20SA%20Oct2015_5.pdf
- Ferree, Karen, Clark Gibson, Danielle Jung, James Long and Craig McIntosh. "How Technology Shapes the Crowd: Participation in the 2014 South African Election" Working Paper, April 2016. https://static1.squarespace.com/static/55af94b0e4b0cc8a396f8c40/t/572221e52eeb818e05d4b2fe/1461854694098/SA_ICT_2016.pdf
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.