Split Standing Charge Tariff Trials: Encouraging demand flexibility to meet clean power goals

How to cite

Panzone, Luca; Moon, Beth; Almond, Rosie; Smart, Laura; Collins, Emily; Taylor, Max; Robertson, Helena; Dwivedi, Annu. 2025. "Split Standing Charge Tariff Trials: Encouraging demand flexibility to meet clean power goals." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017049. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17049-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Luca Panzone* , Beth Moon , Rosie Almond , Laura Smart , Emily Collins , Max Taylor , Helena Robertson , Annu Dwivedi

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017049
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17049-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-11-04 – 2026-03-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93 (Field Experiments); D12 (Consumer Economics: Empirical Analysis); H2 (Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue); Q48 (Energy/Government Policy); Q5 (Environmental Economics).
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17049

Abstract

The supply of electricity requires the development and maintenance of infrastructure, the cost of which are generally recovered through a Standing Charge (SC), which is separate from electricity prices. Consumers have often reported feelings of unfairness on the existence of the Standing Charge, prompting the need to look for alternative ways to recover the costs of energy infrastructure investment. Here, we run three different RCTs with different suppliers to explore novel approaches to standing charges. In all trials, we propose a novel approach that links the standing charge to usage during peak times, whereby consumers pay less (more) standing charge if they limit (do not limit) electricity consumption during peak time. The literature currently presents limited evidence on the impacts of ongoing long-term peak-time price signals in encouraging consumers to reduce energy at peak times; these trials aim to explore how a broad range of energy consumers respond to peak time price signals. Importantly, this novel approach to SC has the potential to address consumer perceptions of unfairness and encourage energy usage patterns that substantially reduce network strain – and costs – at peak times.

Intervention

The trial aims to test the potential of a restructured standing charge linked to peak-time electricity usage in encouraging consumers to shift their demand away from peak periods.  
We aim to learn: 
• The magnitude of peak-time demand reduction potential
• Substitution patterns: are consumers reducing demand or shifting it to off-peak periods?
• The impact of the tariff on household bills and system cost recovery 
• Whether consumers find the restructured standing charges fair, acceptable, understandable, and actionable 
The trials introduce a split standing charge mechanism where consumers stand to earn up to 50% off their daily standing charge based on their level of peak-time electricity usage that day relative to other consumers. The rebate is calculated daily, providing participants with a fresh opportunity each day to lower their peak energy usage and earn a higher rebate off their standing charge. At the end of every [month/two weeks] customers will be notified of their cumulative rebate earnt off their daily standing charges.

Experimental design

The trial introduces a split standing charge mechanism where consumers stand to earn up to 50% off their daily standing charge based on their level of peak-time electricity usage that day relative to other consumers.
All 3 suppliers will have a sample of 20,000 participants each (10000 in the control group), and will reward participants on the basis of their peak electricity consumption, with reward size inversely related to peak consumption.
The design changes slightly across consumers, as suppliers personalised the intervention based on their own infrastructure.

Design details

Randomization method
Suppliers 1 and 2 will randomise using a random number generator that allocates participants to treatment vs control. Supplier 3 will ask participants to volunteer into treatment, and then generate a matched control group.
Randomization unit
Individual consumer.
Clusters
20,000 participants (i.e., households) in each of the three trials, for a total of 60,000 participants.
Observations
20,000 participants (i.e., households) in each of the three trials, for a total of 60,000 participants. Time periods: 3-5 months, where consumption is recorded at 30-min intervals from smart meters. For a single month (30 days), we would expect 28.8 million data points per supplier, which we will aggregate at daily level to aggregate peak vs off-peak electricity consumption..
Arms
In trial 1, we expect 10,000 households in the control, 5,000 in treatment 1, and 5,000 in treatment 2. We will also have two smaller groups of around 300 households each for additional A/B testing. In trial 2 and 3, we will have 10,000 participants in the control, and 10,000 in the treatment group.
Primary outcomes
The key outcome variable is the amount of electricity consumed by participating, measured in kWh. We will split between peak and off-peak energy consumption.
Secondary outcomes
customer satisfaction and approval of standing charges.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords