Improving Migrant Tracking Through Household Incentives: Evidence from a Randomized Controlled Trial in Thailand and Vietnam

How to cite

Gasten, Anna; Do, Manh Hung; Grote, Ulrike; Kis-Katos, Krisztina; Nguyen, Duc Tri Anh; Nguyen, Trung Thanh; Diez, Javier Revilla. 2025. "Improving Migrant Tracking Through Household Incentives: Evidence from a Randomized Controlled Trial in Thailand and Vietnam." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017043. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17043-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Anna Gasten* , Manh Hung Do , Ulrike Grote , Krisztina Kis-Katos , Duc Tri Anh Nguyen , Trung Thanh Nguyen , Javier Revilla Diez

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017043
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17043-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-09-10 – 2026-01-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O15 Economic Development: Human Resources, Human Development, Income Distribution, Migration J61 Geographic Labor Mobility, Immigrant Workers C83 Survey Methods; Sampling Methods D91 Role and Effects of Psychological, Emotional, Social, and Cognitive Factors on Decision Making
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17043

Abstract

This study tests strategies to reduce attrition in follow-up surveys of rural-to-urban migrants using a randomized controlled trial embedded in the Thailand Vietnam Socio-Economic Panel (TVSEP). Migrants are initially listed as “absent members” by rural households in the baseline survey. We randomize rural households into three groups: (T1) a conditional monetary incentive for providing up-to-date migrant contact information, disbursed only if the migrant completes the tracking survey; (T2) the same conditional monastery incentive as in T1, PLUS a small airtime credit encouraging the household to notify the migrant about the upcoming survey, disbursed unconditionally before the survey; and (C) a control group with no intervention. Primary outcomes include the likelihood of obtaining valid contact information, successful completion of the migrant follow-up survey, and survey implementation metrics such as number of contact attempts and response quality. Beyond its contributions to survey methodology and migration research, the study offers insights into how social ties can be mobilized to enhance response rates in both longitudinal and cross-sectional data collection, particularly when network members are in a position to assist with locating or motivating respondents.

Intervention

This study investigates how low-cost, network-informed strategies can reduce attrition in follow-up surveys of rural-to-urban migrants. Attrition and non-contact are persistent challenges not only in longitudinal panel studies, but also in cross-sectional data collection—especially when targeted respondents are mobile, difficult to locate, or sampled via intermediaries. In such cases, the sampled population may diverge from the interviewed population due to failure to reach individuals after the sampling stage, introducing potential bias, reducing external validity, and decreasing the final sample size—ultimately undermining the statistical power of the analysis. This issue is particularly acute in surveys of mobile or displaced populations, such as internal migrants, refugees, seasonal workers, and residents of informal settlements.

We explore whether leveraging the social ties between migrants and their rural origin households can improve response rates in tracking surveys. Migrants are often still connected to their households of origin, both socially and financially. These connections present an opportunity: if households are motivated to support researchers in reaching migrants, this may improve the success rate of follow-up data collection.
The study also has broader implications for all data collection efforts that rely on network-based sampling approaches such as snowball sampling and respondent-driven sampling (RDS), where respondent cooperation and accurate referral are essential for reaching eligible individuals.
To test this idea, we implement two types of interventions targeting the migrants’ rural households:

1. A conditional incentive, disbursed ex-post: Households are informed that they will receive a monetary reward if the researchers are able to successfully reach and interview the migrant. This incentive is conditional on both the household providing accurate contact information and the migrant ultimately completing the follow-up survey. The goal is to encourage households to actively assist in identifying valid contact details and encouraging the migrant’s cooperation.

2. An unconditional communication incentive, disbursed ex-ante: In a separate intervention, households receive a small airtime top-up for their mobile phone. They are encouraged to use this airtime to notify the migrant about the upcoming survey. This intervention aims to overcome common communication barriers, such as widespread reluctance to answer calls from unknown numbers due to concerns about scam calls and fraud. By prompting households to proactively inform migrants about the survey, the airtime credit helps migrants anticipate the follow-up contact, increasing their likelihood of participation.

Both interventions engage households as active partners in tracking migrants, testing whether small, network-based nudges can cost-effectively improve follow-up success. This research contributes to the survey methodology and social networks literature by exploring how family ties and informal communication can support participation. While implemented in a panel survey of internal migrants in Southeast Asia, the findings are likely generalizable to other settings and populations where social networks play a key role in locating and motivating respondents, including cross-sectional surveys that rely on third-party contact or referral.
We target household heads who, in the most recent TVSEP wave (2024), reported that at least one household member had migrated to an urban area.

The implementation follows a three-stage process. First, rural households are contacted by phone to confirm the migrant’s current location and provide updated migrant contact information. Households in treatment groups are informed about the different financial incentives during this call. Second, migrants are contacted using the phone numbers collected from their households. A randomly selected subset of migrants whose households are eligible for the ex-post incentive are informed about the financial reward available to their household upon survey completion. All migrants are then asked whether they are willing to participate in the follow-up survey. Finally, enumerators will perform face-to-face interviews with those migrants who agreed to be interviewed.
As the migrant data collection is embedded within the long-term TVSEP panel study, we can leverage historical household and migrant panel data to explore heterogeneity in intervention effects and examine how past characteristics influence survey participation.

Our survey sample will include approximately:
- 1115 migrants from 729 households in three rural provinces of Thailand (Nakhon Phanom, Ubon Ratchathani, and Buriram), representing 34.8% of the 2024 Thai household sample
- 697 migrants from 490 households in three rural provinces of Vietnam (Ha Tĩnh, Thừa Thiên Huế, and Đắk Lắk), representing 22.3% of the 2024 Vietnamese household sample

Because the experiment is being conducted in both Thailand and Vietnam—two contexts with historically different response rates and data quality among both household and migrant respondents—we are also able to descriptively compare intervention effects across settings. This allows us to explore whether the interventions are particularly effective in contexts where tracking and data quality have traditionally been more challenging, or whether they primarily reinforce already strong survey performance. While not designed for formal cross-country comparisons, these descriptive insights can inform how such strategies might be prioritized or tailored to different implementation environments.

Both Thailand and Vietnam are also settings where concerns about phone- and online-based fraud are widespread. We thus expect that some households might be hesitant to share their migrant member’s contact information, particularly when the conversation involves financial incentives. To address this, calls will be conducted by official university research teams using institutional phone lines (fixed lines), and enumerators will clearly identify themselves and their institutional affiliation at the start of each conversation. Despite these safeguards, the prevalence of scam-related mistrust may still limit the willingness of some households to disclose contact details. Importantly, the financial incentive could affect trust in both directions: it may encourage cooperation by signaling legitimacy and offering a clear benefit, but it could also raise suspicion among households wary of fraudulent schemes. We will explore whether the effectiveness of the interventions varies with households’ prior exposure to scam calls, as reported in the 2024 TVSEP wave, to better understand how trust and perceived legitimacy shape participation in this context.
An additional aspect of interest is whether, even if fewer households initially share contact information, those that perceive the research team as trustworthy (“non-scammers”) are more likely to follow the survey team’s request to notify the migrant about the upcoming interview. Such proactive communication may help reduce attrition in the second stage by ensuring that migrants are less likely to mistake the enumerators’ calls for potential scams.

The sampling stage, and thus experimental intervention is planned to start on the 10th of September 2025 in Thailand and 1st of October 2025 in Vietnam. Data collection (and thus our outcomes of interest) will be carried out between 10/2025 and 01/2026 in both Thailand and Vietnam.

Experimental design

The experiment follows a 2×2 factorial design at the household level, complemented by a secondary migrant-level information treatment.
At the household level, rural origin households with at least one urban migrant are randomly assigned to one of four treatment groups:

1. Control (no incentive) = C
2. Ex-ante nudge only = T1
3. Ex-post incentive only = T2
4. Combined treatment (both nudge and incentive) = T3

Randomization is conducted at the village level to avoid potential spillover effects or perceived inequities between households living nearby. All households within the same village therefore receive a consistent treatment message.
During the migrant contact stage, we introduce an additional migrant-level information treatment among the groups eligible for the ex-post incentive (T2 and T3). For a random subset of these migrants, enumerators explicitly inform them about the incentive that their household will receive upon successful interview completion. This nested design enables assessment of whether directly communicating the incentive to migrants amplifies household-level effects on participation.
The study thus enables identification of (i) the separate and joint impacts of ex-ante and ex-post incentives on survey participation, and (ii) the additional effect of providing information directly to migrants.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-based - Ex-ante randomization for household-level treatment group assignment - Within tablet randomization for migrant-level information treatment
Randomization unit
Randomization of household-level treatments was implemented at the village (cluster) level. Villages were first randomly ordered and then sequentially assigned to treatment arms to achieve the target total numbers of households across groups, according to the experimental design target size (Control, T1, T2, T3). This procedure ensures target household counts while maintaining a random assignment order. The random seed and resulting assignment were recorded for reproducibility. Randomization for the migrant information treatment was implemented at the individual level, within the Survey Program (Survey Solutions).
Clusters
211 villages in Thailand 191 villages in Vietnam
Observations
1115 migrants from 729 households in Thailand 697 migrants from 490 households in Vietnam We anticipate some attrition and non-response due to factors such as scam-call concerns in both countries and frequently changing mobile phone numbers. These challenges may particularly affect the first household calling stage, where the main treatment arms are implemented. We expect that any attrition will occur at random and be roughly proportionally distributed across treatment groups.
Arms
Based on the unequal treatment allocation described above, we expect the following approximate sample sizes at the household–migrant link level: - Control group (C): 186 observations in Thailand and 116 in Vietnam. - T1 (ex-ante nudge only): 186 in Thailand and 116 in Vietnam. - T2 (ex-post compensation only): 186 in Thailand and 116 in Vietnam. - T3 (both ex-ante nudge and ex-post compensation): 557 in Thailand and 349 in Vietnam. At the migrant level, where an additional information treatment is applied among T2 and T3 households, we expect approximately: - No information treatment (T2-i and T3-i combined): 371 observations in Thailand and 232 in Vietnam. - Information treatment (T2+i and T3+i combined): 372 observations in Thailand and 233 in Vietnam. These figures reflect the expected distribution given the randomization proportions (1/6, 1/6, 1/6, and 1/2 across household treatment arms, with an even split across information treatment conditions within T2 and T3).
Primary outcomes
Our primary measures of interest are: 1. Household provision of valid migrant contact information 2. Number of call attempts per migrant/ household until the contact is achieved 3. Successful scheduling of the migrant interview 4. Migrant survey completion
Secondary outcomes
1. Response quality indicators, e.g. data entry errors; number of answered questions/ completeness of key survey sections 2. Migrant-reported prior notification by household of TVSEP survey call 3. Timing of survey completion 4. Heterogeneity of intervention effects and their effect on sample representativeness
Sponsors
Name: Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) - Project number 283672937 Location: Bonn, Germany Url: https://gepris.dfg.de/gepris/projekt/283672937
Partners
Name: Thailand: Kasetsart University Partner_type: none Url: https://www.ku.ac.th/en/community-home Name: Thailand: Ubon Ratchathani University Partner_type: none Url: https://www.ubu.ac.th/web/ubuenglish/ Name: Vietnam: University of Economics Ho Chi Minh City Partner_type: none Url: https://ueh.edu.vn/en/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords