Is sharing caring? Disentangling prosociality from virtue signalling

How to cite

Ioannidis, Konstantinos; Lohse, Johannes; Borzadaran, Hamideh Mohtashami. 2026. "Is sharing caring? Disentangling prosociality from virtue signalling." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017033. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17033-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Konstantinos Ioannidis* , Johannes Lohse , Hamideh Mohtashami Borzadaran

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017033
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17033-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-03-30 – 2026-07-31
Countries
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland ()
JEL codes
C91, D64, D91, H41
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17033

Abstract

Cheap public signals such as liking or sharing charitable causes on online platforms may crowd out charitable donations if they already satisfy image and social-approval motives without subsequent giving. We study this substitution effect in an online experiment in which participants select a charity aligned with their preferred cause and decide how much of a potential bonus to donate. Participants are randomized to a baseline with donations only or to a treatment condition that also allows choosing a short, pre-written supportive message in addition to giving. To discern between different motives we also randomize participants to one of three observability conditions: (i) private decisions or public decisions that may be observed by others either (ii) before or (iii) after those others decide. Primary outcomes are the probability of donating and the donation amount. We additionally examine how observed donations and messages affect subsequent participants’ behaviour. The findings will clarify when public support complements versus substitutes monetary giving, and will provide guidance for fundraising design on digital platforms.

Intervention

Interventions manipulating the action set and the observability in a 2x3 design.

Experimental design

We run an online randomized experiment with a factorial structure at the charity decision screen. Participants are randomly assigned to one of six conditions formed by crossing:
1. Action set: Baseline (donation only) vs Message (donation plus the option to select a supportive message)
2. Observability: Private vs Observed Before vs Observed After.

In Observed-Before, participants may observe a predecessor’s decision before choosing, and their own decision may be shown to later participants before those participants choose, enabling analysis of direct and indirect social transmission across generations. In Observed-After, information (if any) is revealed only after the participant decides, separating pure observability (image) from strategic influence. In Private, decisions are not shown to anyone.

Primary outcomes are donation participation (donate indicator) and donation amount.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-generated randomization implemented within the online survey (simple random assignment with fixed assignment probabilities across treatment cells). Allocation is performed automatically at the individual’s entry to the survey.
Randomization unit
Primary randomization is at the individual participant level into the 2 × 3 design cells. In conditions involving observability, participants are linked into chains for information display (generational structure). Participants in later generations are hence randomly allocated a specific generational sequence. For later analysis standard errors are clustered at the chain level in analyses that use these links.
Clusters
8,000 participants organised in 2,000 chains. Each chain has 1 Gen 0 participant and 3 Gen 1 participants.
Observations
8,000 donation decisions, and 4,000 message decisions.
Arms
Each treatment arm has 2,000 participants organised in 500 chains. Each chain has 1 Gen 0 participant and 3 Gen 1 participants.
Primary outcomes
Amount donated (GBP). Donation amount chosen from {0, £2.50, £5.00, £7.50, £10.00}. Decision to donate (binary). Indicator equal to 1 if donation amount > 0, else 0.
Secondary outcomes
Message sent (binary). In the Message condition, indicator equal to 1 if a supportive message is selected, 0 otherwise. Message content choice. Categorical indicator for which pre-written message is selected (within cause). Beliefs about peer donations. For Gen 0, this is belief about the amound donated from Gen 1 participants who observe thir decision. For Gen 1, this is belief about other Gen 1 participants. Both beliefs are incentivized with a small bonus for accuracy. Mechanism measures (post-experiment). Agreement scales on motives related to influencing others, concern for generous image, and learning from predecessors. Attitudinal covariates and demographics. Attitudes on charity trust and giving, frequency and typical annual giving, and standard demographics.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords