The Cost of Rejection: Understanding Gender Dynamics in Leadership Aspirations

How to cite

Bouleau, Clémentine. 2025. "The Cost of Rejection: Understanding Gender Dynamics in Leadership Aspirations." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017012. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17012-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Clémentine Bouleau*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017012
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17012-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-12-07 – 2026-04-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J24, J16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17012

Abstract

This study investigates whether repeated experiences of rejection from leadership positions reduce future leadership ambitions and whether these dynamics differ by gender. I design an experiment in which participants repeatedly apply for leadership roles, experience acceptance or rejection, and decide whether to reapply in subsequent rounds. By leveraging a probabilistic selection mechanism—where leader appointment is determined through a lottery weighted by individual performance (and therefore not entirely deterministic)—I can further study gender differences in the interpretation of rejection. Prior research suggests that women react more negatively to failure and are more likely than men to attribute rejection to a lack of ability. Based on these results I hypothesize that, over multiple rounds, a gender gap in willingness to lead (WTL) will emerge and widen, as women disproportionately exit the leadership pipeline following rejection. If confirmed, these findings could contribute to the broader understanding of gender disparities in leadership aspirations and inform policy interventions designed to sustain women’s leadership trajectories by mitigating the discouraging effects of early setbacks.

Experimental design

I build on the framed “survival” task used by Born et al. (2022) to study willingness to lead. Specifically, my experiment employs a modified version of this paradigm to measure individual performance and confidence in two preliminary rounds, followed by group-based tasks in which a leader is appointed. Participants are informed that the leader's appointment is determined through a lottery weighted by individual performance. Over multiple rounds, they have repeated opportunities to put themselves forward for the leadership role and, if selected, to determine their group’s outcome. Observing how individuals modify their willingness to lead after acceptance or rejection allows for an analysis of whether and why men and women react differently to these experiences.

Part 1 - Individual Phase
Part 1a: Participants are presented with 5 pairs of items from the ”Lost at Sea” task and must select the item they believe is most critical for survival. We also ask them to guess their score, and rank compared to a reference sample of other participants.
Part 1b: Participants complete the whole task again with new pairs of items and a different survival scenario. We also ask them to guess their score, and rank compared to a reference sample of other participants.
This individual phase establishes baseline measures of ability and confidence.

Part 2 - Group-based Phase
Part 2a
Group Formation: Participants are placed in groups, their anonymity is maintained. They are informed that a leader will be selected to represent the group during a second round of the task. The leader’s answers alone will determine the group’s final payoff for that round. Participants are informed that leader selection will be based on the outcome of a lottery in which each candidate’s chance of being selected depends on their performance scores from the two initial tasks (Part 1a and 1b). Participants with higher performance scores will have higher chances of being selected as leader, but no one is guaranteed to be chosen. If no one applies, all group members will automatically be included in the lottery using the same rule—so even if you choose not to apply, you may still be selected as leader if no one else applies.
Willingness to Lead elicitation: Each participant is asked to indicate whether they wish to apply for the leadership position + their WTL on a 0-10 points scale. We also ask a guess about the number of candidates.

Group Task: While we process leaders’ selection, all participants complete the task again with new item pairs. Only the elected leader’s answers determine the group’s final payout. They do not get any feedback on outcomes for this task until the end of the experiment.

Leader Revelation: Participants learn about whether they have been appointed as leader or not for this round.
Among those who applied: “Your application has been rejected/accepted for this round”
Among those who did not apply: “You were not appointed as leader for this round” + hypothetical feedback “Had you applied you would have been accepted/rejected”. (this feedback is obtained by adding the participant to the existing candidate pool and running the election again)

Attribution Question: Participants are asked about their beliefs on how much of the outcome was due to luck vs. performance. They are also asked to guess again the number of candidates in the round.

Confidence Elicitation: We elicit global and relative confidence the same way as we did in Part 1.

Part 2b
Same overall structure as Part 2a. Participants are told that they are going to complete the same task again, but that a new leader will be appointed for this task. Again, they are asked whether they want to apply, how willing they are to lead on the scale and their guess about the number of candidates. The same rule applies for the leader’s selection and revelation.

Group Task: They complete the task with a new set of items. Participants are asked again about their beliefs on how much of the outcome was due to luck vs. performance, number of candidates and confidence.

(Hypothetical) Part 3c
Participants are told to imagine that they could complete the same task again. Again, they are asked whether they would apply for the leader’s role, and how willing they would be to lead on the scale.

Post-Experiment Survey Participants complete a survey measuring risk preferences, the belief in good luck scale, explicit gender biases, previous knowledge about the task, previous leadership experience, demographics and some open-ended questions about their decisions during the experiment.

Feedback and Payment
The leaders’ answers are revealed, and the group’s overall outcomes are shared. They also have the opportunity to view the experts' solutions to better understand their scores.

Final payoffs consist of:
A £5 Prolific participation fee.
A bonus equal to the performance in one randomly selected question from one randomly selected Part (Part 1a, Part 1b, Part 2a or Part 2b. If Part 2a or 2b are selected, only the leader’s answers determine the payout. They receive £2 if their answer to this question is correct.
£0.5 bonuses for on the beliefs questions (14 in total: 6 confidence questions, 2 attributions, 4 number of candidates)
A £0.5 for being the leader (up to £1 if someone is selected twice)

Anonymity is maintained throughout the experiment. This ensures that gender remains private information, ruling out additional barriers to women’s willingness like concerns about backlash for deviating from gender expectations.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is implemented by computer within the experimental software. All random assignments (including leader selection lotteries, and feedback conditions) are determined algorithmically using a reproducible random seed.
Randomization unit
While group-level outcomes exist, all random assignments (grouping, leader selection, hypothetical feedback, bonus draws) are implemented at the individual level through computer randomization.
Clusters
450 participants
Observations
450 participants
Arms
450 participants
Primary outcomes
Leadership application: binary variable (applied = 1, did not apply = 0), assessed across rounds Willingness to lead: 0-10 points scale measure, assessed across rounds Leadership status (candidates only): accepted / rejected, assessed across rounds Beliefs about outcome attribution and number of candidates: perceptions of the reasons for acceptance or rejection and number of candidates, assessed across rounds (incentivized) Confidence beliefs: both relative and global confidence measures (incentivized) Individual performance (incentivized)
Secondary outcomes
Hypothetical Leadership Status: For participants who did not initially apply for the leadership role, I provide a hypothetical leadership outcome, that is, information on whether they would have been accepted or rejected had they applied. This manipulation aims to test whether receiving such a counterfactual signal influences subsequent decisions to apply for leadership positions Explicit gender biases Risk attitudes Previous knowledge about the task Previous leadership experience Demographic information - age, gender, occupation, field of study for students

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords