Trust, Autonomy & Paternalism: An Experimental Study
How to cite
Meemann, Christine; Halm, Pauline; Schütt, Christoph. 2025. "Trust, Autonomy & Paternalism: An Experimental Study." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016963. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16963-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study aims to investigate the role of trust in attitudes towards paternalism. Using an online experiment, we examine whether trust affects i) the willingness to accept a paternalistic intervention and ii) the willingness to paternalistically intervene in another person's freedom of choice.
Intervention
Using an online experiment, we study whether trust influences i) the willingness to accept a paternalistic intervention, or in other words, the willingness to decide and ii) the willingness to paternalistically intervene in another person's freedom of choice.
Experimental design
We address the research question using a two-part experimental design: Throughout the experiment, participants are matched in groups of two and are randomly assigned the roles of Participant A or Participant B.
In Part 1 of the experiment, the level of trust (for Participants A) and the belief in the level of the other participants’ trust (for Participants B) are measured by decisions and via belief-elicitation in the “Trust Game” (à la Berg et al. 1995).
In Part 2 of the experiment, the paternalism game, Participants A states for a specific decision-making situation whether they want to make their own decision or if they want Participant B to decide for them. Participants B, who has perfect information about the decision-making situation, is asked whether they want to make the decision for Participant A. Participants B receive a fixed payoff independent of their decisions in Part 2. The specific decision-making situation only has payoff-relevant consequences for Participants A.
We implement two treatments between-subjects as induced in Part 1:
After reading the instructions and prior to making their decisions, participants receive the following information on a separate screen depending on the treatment (Control vs. Trust):
Treatment Control: Participants receive general information about the decision situation and the trust game.
Treatment Trust: In addition, participants receive information about the level of trust (for Participants B) or the level of trustworthiness (for Participants A) from prior sessions of the study.
Note: The information is based on two sessions from a pilot study of this study.
Our hypotheses are as follows:
Willingness to decide (Participant A): Trust decreases the willingness to decide.
Willingness to intervene (Participant B): Perceived trust increases the willingness to intervene.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.