Vaccination rates are declining globally, threatening public health and herd immunity. Effective communication is critical to counter misinformation and increase vaccine uptake, but little is known about whether messenger identity or communication format most influences beliefs and intentions. This study examines how people respond to trusted scientific sources versus popular non-expert voices, and whether immersive or conventional communication channels affect persuasion and information diffusion. By integrating insights from behavioral economics, communication, and social networks, the project aims to identify evidence-based strategies for improving public health messaging and understanding how messages spread through social connections. Findings will have implications for policymakers, public health agencies, and institutions seeking to enhance engagement with credible science.
Intervention
This project investigates how the identity of a communicator and the format of their message influence individuals’ beliefs and intentions regarding vaccination, while ensuring that the informational content itself is identical across conditions.
Experimental design
The study randomly assigns participants to receive identical informational content delivered by either a scientific expert or a popular non-expert communicator. This design allows us to compare the influence of messenger identity on beliefs, attitudes, and intentions.
Design details
Randomization method
Each session will be randomly assigned to one treatment arm. All participants to a session will receive the same treatment. Within session, those participating to those sessions receiving the information treatment (either VR or Video) will be randomized into one of the 4 speakers: Male Scientist, Female Scientis, Male Influencer, Female Influencer.
Randomization unit
Experimental sessions, as each session will see the participants receiving the same treatment.
Clusters
Randomization occurs at the individual participant level. The study therefore does not involve clustered assignment. The planned sample is approximately 1,000 individual participants (clusters of size 1).
Observations
The planned number of observations is 1,000, although we will try to collect more based on funding availability.
Arms
Approximately 333 participants in Control, 333 participants in Video, and 333 participants in VR. The primary treatment assignment is across three session-level arms: Control, Video, and VR. The presentation materials describe the treatment arms as VR, Video, or Control.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes capture participants’ beliefs and attitudes toward vaccination and public health institutions following exposure to the informational intervention. The main endpoints are summary indices constructed from post-treatment survey responses:
Trust in Vaccines Index
Trust in Healthcare System / Health Authorities Index
Vaccination Acceptance / Vaccination Intent
These outcomes measure the extent to which exposure to the informational message affects participants’ trust in vaccination, trust in medical institutions, and willingness to accept vaccination recommendations.
Each index will also be analyzed through its individual components as secondary specifications.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes measure mechanisms through which the intervention may affect attitudes toward vaccination, as well as additional behavioral and evaluative responses to the informational message.
The main secondary outcomes include:
Willingness to discuss vaccination
Perceived credibility and evaluation of the speaker
Engagement and visual attention during the message (VR condition)
These outcomes help identify the channels through which communication medium and speaker identity influence beliefs and attitudes toward vaccination.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.