Framing and Financial Incentives to Increase Influenza Vaccination Uptake: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Chinese Communities
How to cite
Wang, Yizhi; Yang, Shenshen; Li, Xiongfei; Yu, Chan. 2025. "Framing and Financial Incentives to Increase Influenza Vaccination Uptake: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Chinese Communities." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016944. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16944-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study evaluates whether information framing and monetary incentives increase uptake of the seasonal influenza vaccine among community residents. Participants are individually randomized to one of four information arms: (i) no additional information, (ii) neutral factual information, (iii) positively framed information emphasizing the benefits of vaccination, and (iv) negatively framed information emphasizing the risks of non-vaccination. Participants are also exposed to an incentive module that offers either no subsidy or a randomly assigned subsidy or lottery amount ranging from RMB 10 to RMB 100.
The study collects three survey waves: baseline, a midline follow-up 2–3 weeks after the intervention, and an endline follow-up at the end of the influenza season, approximately 3–4 months after the intervention. Primary outcomes are short-run vaccination uptake and cumulative end-of-season uptake. Secondary and intermediate outcomes include future vaccination intention, vaccination timing, beliefs about vaccine effectiveness and side effects, perceived influenza risk, barriers to vaccination, message exposure and message perception, and end-of-season health outcomes such as influenza-like illness, healthcare utilization, and missed work or school days.
Intervention
T0: Control group. Participants receive no additional vaccination information.
T1: Neutral information group. Participants receive objective factual information on where to get vaccinated, timing, costs, safety standards, and appointment procedures.
T2: Positive-framing group. Participants receive messages emphasizing the benefits of vaccination, such as protecting oneself and family members, reducing missed work or school, and contributing to herd immunity.
T3: Negative-framing group. Participants receive messages emphasizing the risks of non-vaccination, such as infection risk, complications, medical costs, and transmission to vulnerable household members.
Monetary incentive module. Participants are additionally assigned to either no subsidy or to a randomly determined monetary incentive/subsidy amount between RMB 10 and RMB 100. The study materials also describe this incentive module as a subsidy/lottery notification.
Primary hypotheses
H1. Subsidy effect on current uptake.
Higher subsidy amounts will increase verified flu-vaccination uptake in the current season.
H2. Information effect on current uptake.
Receiving any vaccine-information message will increase current-season vaccination uptake relative to receiving no information.
H3a. Complementarity between information and subsidy.
Information messages will strengthen the behavioral response to subsidies, so the marginal effect of subsidy on uptake will be larger in the information arms than in the control arm.
H3b. Substitutability between information and subsidy.
Information messages will substitute for the motivating effect of subsidies, so the marginal effect of subsidy on uptake will be smaller in the information arms than in the control arm.
H4. Framing effect of message content.
Message framing will matter for current-season vaccination uptake. In particular, framed messages (positive/gain or negative/loss) will have larger effects than a neutral informational message.
H5. Loss framing versus gain framing.
Negative/loss framing will generate a larger increase in current-season vaccination uptake than positive/gain framing.
H6. Framing effect on future intention. Information framing will affect stated future vaccination intention, including willingness to vaccinate in the next influenza season and willingness to vaccinate under lower out-of-pocket cost.
H7. Behavioral and attitudinal change. Information and subsidy treatments will shift beliefs about vaccine effectiveness, side-effect risk, and influenza risk, and will also affect behavioral margins such as stated intention, perceived barriers, and self-reported reasons for vaccination or non-vaccination.
H8. Health consequences of uptake. Higher vaccination uptake will be associated with lower influenza-like illness, lower healthcare utilization, and fewer missed work or school days over the influenza season.
Longer-run hypotheses
H9. Persistence of intervention effects.
Exposure to current-season subsidies and/or information will increase stated willingness to vaccinate in the following flu season even when next-season vaccination is not subsidized.
H10. Information sustains future motivation.
Information messages paired with subsidies will produce more persistent future vaccination intention than subsidies alone.
Mechanism hypotheses
H11. Belief updating.
Information messages will improve vaccine-related beliefs, including perceived effectiveness, perceived safety, and/or perceived benefits of vaccination.
H12. Beliefs as a mediator.
Part of the effect of information messages on current-season uptake and future intention will operate through changes in vaccine-related beliefs.
Experimental design
This is an individually randomized controlled trial. The design materials target an overall sample of approximately 1,300 participants, with about 300 participants assigned to each of the four information arms. If recruitment falls short of the target, the design calls for keeping cell sizes as balanced as possible while preserving balance on key baseline characteristics. Random assignment is stratified using baseline characteristics including gender, age, whether the participant was vaccinated in the previous influenza season, and baseline vaccination intention. The study collects three survey waves: a baseline survey before treatment, a midline survey 2–3 weeks after the intervention, and an endline survey at the end of the influenza season, approximately 3–4 months after the intervention.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.