Building Supranational Support: A Cross-Country Survey Experiment on EU Narratives

How to cite

Maggio, Federico; Nannicini, Tommaso; Cervellati, Matteo; Onorato, Massimiliano Gaetano; Barone, Guglielmo. 2025. "Building Supranational Support: A Cross-Country Survey Experiment on EU Narratives." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016926. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16926-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Federico Maggio* , Tommaso Nannicini , Matteo Cervellati , Massimiliano Gaetano Onorato , Guglielmo Barone

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016926
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16926-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-11-16 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16926

Abstract

This project examines how short, non-partisan informational videos about the European Union shape attitudes, beliefs, and engagement toward supranational governance across five EU countries: Italy, France, Germany, Poland, and Spain. It extends the 2024 Italian randomized controlled trial “ElectionDrive: Empowering European Engagement,” which tested how informational messages affect political trust and mobilization in a national electoral context.

In this new cross-country survey experiment (N = 15,000), respondents are randomly assigned to view one of three video narratives or a control condition. The treatments emphasize: (i) external threats to Europe’s stability (defense narrative), (ii) common challenges requiring collective EU responses (cooperation narrative), and (iii) Western or commercial threats linked to global competition and the Trump-era trade environment.

Immediately after exposure, respondents complete a harmonized post-treatment questionnaire measuring trust in EU and national institutions, perceived EU effectiveness, identity, policy preferences, issue salience, and voluntary participation (opt-in to provide ideas and comments for EU institutions).

By combining experimental variation with rich attitudinal data across diverse political and cultural contexts, the study identifies which types of narratives foster support for EU reforms, trust in supranational institutions, and civic engagement. The results contribute to understanding how informational framing can enhance legitimacy and participation in multilevel democracies.

Experimental design

This project is a cross-country randomized survey experiment designed to study how informational narratives about the European Union influence attitudes, beliefs, and engagement toward supranational governance. The study extends a previous Italian RCT (Programmatic Advertising and Electoral Participation, 2024) to a multi-country setting, focusing exclusively on survey-based treatments without programmatic ad delivery.

The experiment will be conducted in five EU countries: Italy, France, Germany, Poland, and Spain. A total of approximately 15,000 adult respondents (about 3,000 per country) will be recruited through the professional survey provider SWG S.p.A., using its proprietary CAWI platform. Within each country, participants will be stratified by gender, age group, and region and then randomly assigned at the individual level to one of four experimental arms:

T1 – External Threats (Defense Narrative): emphasizes external threats and the need for unity and protection.

T2 – Common Challenges (Cooperation Narrative): stresses shared challenges and the importance of joint European solutions.

T3 – Western Threats (Trump/Commercial Narrative): focuses on Western or commercial threats linked to global competition and Trump-era dynamics.

C – Control group: no video or neutral non-political content.

After exposure, all respondents complete a harmonized post-treatment questionnaire capturing trust, perceived EU effectiveness, identity, policy preferences, issue salience, and behavioral engagement. The control group receives the same questionnaire without video-related items. Data collection will take approximately 25 working days per country, with all survey instruments and videos fully localized by language.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done by computer within the online survey platform (CAWI) managed by SWG S.p.A., using automated assignment algorithms with pre-specified random seeds and stratification by gender, age group, and region.
Randomization unit
Individual-level randomization within countries, stratified by gender, age group, and region. Each respondent is independently assigned to one of four treatment arms within the CAWI survey platform (SWG S.p.A.).
Clusters
15,000 individual respondents in total (approximately 3,000 per country: Italy, France, Germany, Poland, and Spain). Randomization is individual, not clustered, with participants evenly allocated across four treatment arms (T1, T2, T3, and Control).
Observations
15,000 individual survey respondents in total (approximately 3,000 per country: Italy, France, Germany, Poland, and Spain). Each observation corresponds to one individual who completes the online survey and is randomly assigned to one of four experimental arms.
Arms
Approximately 3,750 individual respondents per treatment arm: – 3,750 Control (no video / neutral content) – 3,750 T1 – External Threats (Defense Narrative) – 3,750 T2 – Common Challenges (Cooperation Narrative) – 3,750 T3 – Western Threats (Trump/Commercial Narrative) Totals approximately 15,000 individuals across all five countries (≈3,000 per country), with balanced assignment within each country.
Primary outcomes
The key outcomes are all post-treatment measures collected in the harmonized cross-country survey following exposure to the informational videos. They are grouped into seven pre-specified families of conceptually related variables: Behavioral participation – indicator equal to 1 if the respondent voluntarily provides an email to be recontacted to share ideas and comments about the European Union (opt-in). Emotions and message agreement – perceived neutrality and agreement with the video (1–5), and sentiment or emotional tone extracted from the open-ended recall question. Issue salience – perceived importance (1–5) of major global issues: military conflicts, environment, economic growth, inequalities, migration, and trade wars. Need for EU (with certainty) – desired degree of EU involvement (1–5) and self-reported certainty (1–5) for each issue. Trust and political efficacy – trust in EU institutions, national institutions, parties, unions, and media (1–5); and perceived political efficacy (“my voice counts” in the EU and in Italy). Policy support – agreement (1–5) with EU-level reforms and cooperation policies (common army, common migration policy, EU fiscal capacity, continued support for Ukraine, social and labor policies, import tariffs). Identity – feeling of belonging as a local, national, and European citizen (1–5). Within each outcome family, related survey items will be combined into standardized indices to summarize overall effects and to limit multiple-testing concerns. Individual items will also be analyzed separately for transparency.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords