The role of social contacts and women’s perception of midwife-led care

How to cite

MHISHI, KUDZAI SANDRA; ROSSO, ANNA CECILIA. 2026. "The role of social contacts and women’s perception of midwife-led care." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016912. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16912-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

KUDZAI SANDRA MHISHI* , ANNA CECILIA ROSSO

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016912
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16912-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-02-26 – 2026-08-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I11, I12, D83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16912

Abstract

We will conduct a survey experiments to explore the role of social contacts or networks in influencing women's perceptions regarding midwife-led model. Specifically, the study seeks to assess the role of these networks or social contacts in shaping women's decision-making during pregnancy and childbirth. We vary the extent to which a participant is exposed to different types of information by their social contacts and investigate their effects on beliefs, preferences and behaviour towards the midwife-led model. This will be accomplished through the vignettes which contain treatment: (1) information about a friend's positive birth experience using the midwife-led model, (2) information about a friend's negative birth experience using the midwife-led model which resulted in an emergency c-section, (3) information from a gynaecologist/obstetrician sharing positive experiences using the midwife-led model, (4) information from a gynaecologist/obstetrician sharing negative experiences using the midwife-led model which may result in an emergency c-section, and (5) information about breast cancer awareness. We expect there will be a significant increase in the beliefs and perceptions of women regarding the non-medicalisation of pregnancy and childbirth. Understanding the role these networks play is crucial for developing strategies that promote wider adoption of this model of care in Italy.

Intervention

Our study employs a vignette-based survey experiment to explore the role of social contacts in influencing women’s perceptions about midwife-led care. The intervention includes five hypothetical scenarios containing: (i) a positive (or good) birth experience of a friend using the midwife-led care, and (ii) a negative (or bad) birth experience of a friend using the midwife-led model but resulted in an emergency c-section, (iii) a gynaecologist sharing positive experiences using the midwife-led model, (iv) a gynaecologist sharing negative experiences using the midwife-led model which may result to emergency c-section and (v) information on breast cancer awareness.

Experimental design

We will conduct a survey experiment. The participants will be randomly assigned to one of the five groups – four treatment and one control – using a computer from the platform where the survey will be distributed. Those in treatment groups will be presented with a vignette:
(i) Treatment 1: a friend sharing her positive birth experience using midwife-led care
(ii) Treatment 2: a friend sharing her negative experience using midwife-led care, which resulted in an emergency c-section.
(iii) Treatment 3: a gynaecologist doctor sharing positive experiences using midwife-led care
(iv) Treatment 4: a gynaecologist doctor sharing negative experiences using midwife-led care, which may result in an emergency c-section
(v) Treatment 5: general information on breast cancer – this is the control group.

The main hypotheses we will test is whether a woman’s access to information from social contacts can influence her perception of the midwife-led care model. Our main hypotheses is that there are differences in perceptions about the midwife-led model among women who are exposed to information from their social contacts compared to those without information (control group).
Other hypotheses we will test include: (i) the information source effect - i.e., there are differences in perceptions about the midwife-led model among individuals who receive information from friends and medical professionals compared to the control group, and (ii) the direction of the social contact’s influence - i.e., whether there are differences in perceptions about the model among individuals who are exposed to positive or negative birth experiences from social contacts.

Our proposed sample consists of 2,079 women aged 24–55 years, residing in Italy and recruited via online panels. Of these, 250 will participate in a pilot study (50 per arm), leaving 1,829 women for the main study, allocated across five treatment arms of approximately 366 respondents each. Although this falls short of the 700 respondents per arm recommended by Haaland et al. (2023) for information experiments, we argue that our sample remains sufficiently powered to detect effect sizes commonly observed in this literature.

Following Haaland et al. (2023)—who show that information experiments typically generate large effects on beliefs but smaller effects on stated preferences or behavioural outcomes, and that null results are frequent—we adopt their recommendation that such studies should maintain at least 80% power to detect a treatment effect of 0.15 standard deviations. To account for multiple hypothesis testing across four planned pairwise comparisons, we apply a Bonferroni correction, yielding an adjusted significance level of α = 0.0125. Under this correction, our sample of approximately 366 respondents per arm achieves 80% power to detect effect sizes of 0.17 standard deviations or larger. Effect sizes between 0.15 and 0.17 standard deviations are consistent with the small-to-moderate treatment effects widely documented in the information-experiment literature, supporting both the plausibility and policy relevance of effects detectable within our power parameters.

To ensure representativeness, we employ stratified random sampling with re-weighting, benchmarking the distribution of key observable characteristics—including age, education, employment status, and macro-areas indicators—against official ISTAT population data. We adopt the entropy-balancing strategy recommended by Grembi et al. (2024) to achieve covariate balance with respect to known population characteristics, applying regional weights derived from age and educational shares. We incorporate these weights into both baseline estimation models and population-level inference, thereby ensuring that our results are generalisable to the broader population of women in Italy while preserving sufficient statistical power to detect effect sizes between 0.15 and 0.17 standard deviations at the adjusted significance level of α = 0.0125.

Data collection will capture key observable characteristics, including age, education, employment status, and macro-area indicators. Pre-treatment questions will collect demographic information (age, marital status, education, employment), pregnancy status, and awareness of alternative maternity care models, as well as factors influencing model choice. To mitigate demand effects, we will incorporate a social desirability index. Post-treatment questions will measure respondents' perceptions of pregnancy, childbirth, and the midwife-led care model. Quality-control measures will include monitoring survey completion times and implementing a post-treatment attention check that requires respondents to recall information provided before treatment (e.g., prior pregnancy history), in order to identify and exclude inattentive respondents.

Design details

Randomization method
The participants will be randomly assigned to one of the five groups – four treatment and one control – using a computer from the platform where the survey will be distributed. Those in treatment groups will be presented with a vignette. Data collection will be on important observable characteristics, such as age, education, employment, and macroarea dimensions.
Randomization unit
Individual level
Clusters
N/A
Observations
1829 women
Arms
366 women in each treatment arm
Primary outcomes
(i) Beliefs about pregnancy and childbirth and (ii) Perceptions about the midwife-led model (iii) Behaviour towards the midwife-led model which are composite indices holding the values between 0 and 1.
Sponsors
Name: Department of Economics Location: University of Insubria, Italy Url: https://dieco.uninsubria.it/en/ Name: Insubria Experimental Economics Centre (INEXEC) Location: University of Insubria, Italy Url: https://dieco.uninsubria.it/en/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords