Smartphone bans and students’ wellbeing: Experimental evidence from high schools in Peru

How to cite

Ortiz, Elena Arias; Berlinski, Samuel; Cristia, Julian; Naslund-Hadley, Emma; Suarez, Sonia. 2025. "Smartphone bans and students’ wellbeing: Experimental evidence from high schools in Peru." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016895. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16895-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Elena Arias Ortiz* , Samuel Berlinski , Julian Cristia , Emma Naslund-Hadley , Sonia Suarez

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016895
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16895-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-08-13 – 2025-12-19
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I21 – Analysis of Education: Education and Economic Development I28 – Education: Government Policy I31 – General Welfare, Well-Being
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16895

Abstract

We conduct an experimental evaluation to examine the effects of restricting mobile phone use in schools on the socioemotional well-being of public secondary students in Lima, Peru. The randomized controlled trial includes 104 schools that are randomly assigned to one of two arms: a treatment group that introduces locking pouches to restrict phone use during school hours, accompanied by an awareness campaign for students, teachers, and parents about the risks of excessive use; and a control group. The intervention is implemented school-wide: all students who report bringing a cellphone to school are provided with a pouch in which they must store their phone during school hours. We collected baseline data on cellphone ownership and on whether students bring their phones to school to students in grades 3 to 5. We also collected data from all students in a randomly selected third-grade section on a range of dimensions such as demographics, cellphone ownership and use, socioemotional well-being (WHO-5), mental health (PHQ-4), behavior (SDQ), attitudes toward cellphone restrictions, school climate, peer relationships, and sleep patterns. Implementation started in September 2025 and will continue at least until November 2025 (and later if funding is secured). The study will collect endline measures to estimate impacts on emotional wellbeing, mobile-use patterns and potential mechanisms such as interpersonal relations complemented by administrative records on academic performance.

Intervention

Treatment package (school-wide): Restrict in-school mobile phone use by providing locking pouches for students during school hours, plus an awareness campaign for students, teachers, and parents on the risks of excessive phone use. The intervention is implemented at the school level.

Control condition: Business as usual.

Timing & dose: Rollout over three months during the 2025 school year. Baseline surveys are conducted immediately prior to implementation; endline after the 3-month exposure. We plan to continue the intervention during 2026 and later if funding is secured.

To strengthen the study’s internal validity, we will implement multiple quality-control strategies, including instrument standardization and validation, rigorous enumerator training, continuous fieldwork supervision, and verification of implementation fidelity

Experimental design

We implement a cluster randomized controlled trial at the school level to estimate the causal effect of restricting in-school mobile phone use on student outcomes. From an eligible sample of 104 public secondary schools in Lima, 52 schools were randomly assigned to the treatment group and 52 to the control group. Group description:
 Treatment: locking pouches for cellphones during school hours plus an awareness campaign for students, teachers, and parents;
 Control: business as usual (no intervention).
Randomization occurred after baseline data was collected. It was blocked by school enrollment size: schools are first ordered by the number of enrolled students and then grouped into blocks of equal size (four schools per block). Within each block, half of the schools are randomly assigned to the treatment group and half to the control group. The unit of randomization is the school, while the primary unit of analysis is the student. Our main results will include ITT estimates but we will also report ToT estimates considering effects on actual in-school phone use. We will cluster the standard errors at the school level and include dummies in regressions for randomization blocks and baseline outcomes (when available).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done using Stata
Randomization unit
School Level
Clusters
104 secondary schools in Lima
Observations
13,800 students in grades 3 to 5 (Parameters. Mean enrollment 260. Students in grades 3 to 5: 60%; Attendance to endline: 85%)
Arms
52 control group; 52 treatment group
Primary outcomes
Components measured at endline for surveyed students who participated in the baseline: 1. SDQ Internalizing problems (scale, reverse-coded so higher = better) 2. SDQ Externalizing problems (scale, reverse-coded so higher = better) 3. WHO-5 Psychological well-being (scale) 4. PHQ-4 Anxiety/Depression (scale, reverse-coded so higher = better) 5. Life satisfaction (single item, 0-10). Each component will be standardized (z-score using the mean and SD of the control group) and oriented so higher = better. The primary outcome is an equal-weighted index averaging the standardized components available at endline (and re-standardized to produced a z-score using the mean and SD of the control group). This primary outcome will not be adjusted for multiple hypothesis testing. We will produce these adjustments for the five individual indices.
Secondary outcomes
Educational outcomes (constructed using administrative data): 1. Grades (average standardized z-scores using grades at the grade level) 2. Repetition (binary, 1 = repeated the year) 3. Dropout (binary, 1 = not enrolled at endline)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords