NGO Experience and Employer Interest
How to cite
Hurst, Reuben; Oseguera, Mariana. 2025. "NGO Experience and Employer Interest." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016889. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16889-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We examine for-profit employers' demand for workers with prior experience in non-governmental organizations (NGOs). We motivate this study by theorizing contrasting perspectives on how for-profit firms might perceive these workers. On one hand, for-profit employers may value such workers if they perceive them as possessing valuable knowledge about navigating external stakeholder pressure. Conversely, employers may be concerned that these workers harbor strong ideological commitments that could lead them to disrupt business operations or otherwise perform poorly in a for-profit setting. We also consider whether these experiences are perceived differently depending on the applicants' gender or race. We investigate this question using a large-scale audit study in the United States.
Intervention
The key manipulations in our audit study are applicants' prior work experience. Each applicant will have two prior jobs on their resume. These jobs are randomized to be for either a for-profit or non-profit employer. We identify real for-profit and non-profit employers in the CBSA where the targeted job is located. We identify sets of for-profit and non-profit employers within this CBSA that are relatively large and well-known and others that are small and lesser-known. Based on a set of real resumes, we use LLMs to create sets of skills and past experiences that correspond to the occupations we will be applying for. We randomize these skills such that we can isolate the effect of the applicant's prior employer, as opposed to the effect of inferences regarding skills that hiring firms might make based on the presence of certain employers on an applicant's resume.
Individuals are randomized to have either typically female or typically male names as well as names that are typically Black or White.
Applicants' resumes will also list an undergraduate degree from a college located in the CBSA or state in which the job is located. Where possible, these are large, well-known state universities. Where no such university exists, we list a private college in the area that is ranked below the top-ranked public college in our collection of created resumes. Our motivation here is that highly elite private universities may consistently elicit high callback rates, decreasing our ability to measure the effects of the other resume components that are of more central interest. We randomize applicants' GPAs to be between 3.5 and 4.0 inclusive. Besides the name of the school, we will randomize whether the resume indicates the applicant participated in an activist-related or non-activist-related club in college.
Experimental design
We implement randomization and resume construction using a custom application that is similar to the Resume Randomizer created by Lahey and Beasley (2009). Items are randomly combined creating randomized resumes that follow standard resume templates containing: name, contact information, education, college extracurricular activities, and work history.
Once a job is identified, the applicant's profile will be randomly chosen from among the designed profiles. Each job opening will receive two applications: one from an applicant with NGO experience and one from a different applicant without NGO experience. It is possible that multiple locations of the same chain business could use the same hiring managers. To avoid allowing these managers to view similar applicants, we will use the same pair of profiles whenever applications are made to the same company within the same geography. This is equivalent to the same applicant applying to multiple nearby locations, which is common. Applications to locations in different geographies, in contrast, will use different profile pairs.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.