Overcoming Peer Pressure To Drink

How to cite

Hoffmann, Manuel; Leisen, Bernd Josef; Mertins, Vanessa. 2025. "Overcoming Peer Pressure To Drink." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016852. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16852-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Manuel Hoffmann* , Bernd Josef Leisen , Vanessa Mertins

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016852
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16852-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-12-19 – 2022-05-19
Countries
Germany ()
JEL codes
C93, I12, D90, H0
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16852

Abstract

We study how to overcome peer pressure to drink through a series of field experiments in Germany. We randomly provide feedback to individuals about their peer and own alcohol levels to better understand whether individuals converge to the average consumption of their peers. We further provide monetary incentives to strengthen single group members to resist peer pressure to drink and incentivizing all group members to reduce drinking. In further field experiments, we measure the social value of drinking within groups and test the impact of feedback in combination with an auction-like mechanism. In particular, we measure the willingness to abstain from drinking to better understand how the value of peer pressure may change behavior. Finally, in a third experiment we offer an instrument to exert peer pressure to individuals in an online drinking setting to better understand whether direct peer pressure can be a mechanism for indirect peer pressure.

Experimental design

This study contains three field experiments with a series of settings for individuals who are actively drinking within groups. We introduce feedback as a major intervention to study how to measure and overcome peer pressure in the context of alcohol consumption.

Randomized field experiment I:
- No Feedback: individuals receive feedback only upon exiting the event
- Live Feedback to individuals upon entering the event
- Live Feedback + Monetary incentive to drink below the peer average for one randomly selected individual upon entering the event
- Live Feedback + Monetary incentive to drink below the peer average for one randomly selected individual upon exiting the event

Randomized field experiment II:
- No Feedback: Individuals receive feedback only after stating their willingness to abstain from a BDM auction mechanism
- Live Feedback: Individuals receive feedback before stating their willingness to abstain from a BDM auction mechanism

Randomized field experiment III:
- No Feedback: peers state their consumption privately
- Live Feedback: peers state their consumption publicly

Feedback always includes information on individuals about their peer and own alcohol levels from breathalyzer tests (I/II) or from stated consumption (III). In the first two experiments the groups are endogenous while they are randomly assigned in the third experiment.

Experiment 1 is conducted in bars, discos, festivals and at parties. Experiment 2 is conducted at parties and pre-gaming events as well as on May 1st, a nationwide German holiday during which many groups practice heavy day drinking. Experiment 3 is in online drinking settings.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
All Experiments: Group Level
Clusters
Experiment I: 120 groups Experiment II: 40 groups Experiment III: 50 groups
Observations
Experiment I: 360 group members Experiment II: 120 group members Experiment III: 150 group members
Arms
Experiment I: Treatment 1 52, Treatment 2 82, Treatment 3 66, Treatment 4 86 Experiment II: Treatment 1 66 Treatment 2 92 Experiment III: Treatment 1 107, Treatment 2 100
Primary outcomes
Experiment I. Our main outcome variable is the change in individual relative to peer intoxication over time Experiment II. Our main outcome variable is the individual relative to peer willingness to abstain Experiment III. Our main outcome variable is the individual relative to peer offer to abstain from drinking received by peers
Secondary outcomes
Experiment I. Own intoxication, Peer Intoxication Experiment II. Own Willingness to Abstain, Peer Willingness to Abstain Experiment III. Own Offer to Abstain from Drinking Received by Peers, Peer Offer to Abstain from Drinking Received by Peers

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords