Strengthening Fiscal Contracts Through Digital Town Halls in Freetown, Sierra Leone
How to cite
Grieco, Kevin; Kamara, Abou Bakarr; Meriggi, Niccolò F.; Prichard, Wilson; Michel, Julian. 2025. "Strengthening Fiscal Contracts Through Digital Town Halls in Freetown, Sierra Leone." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016843. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16843-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Building durable fiscal capacity requires that states obtain compliance with their taxes—a persistent challenge for states with low enforcement capacity. One promising option for governments in weak states is to raise voluntary compliance by enhancing governmental legitimacy. This study reports results from a participatory budgeting policy experiment in Sierra Leone designed to increase legitimacy and tax compliance by inviting public participation in local policy decision-making. In phone-based town halls, participants shared policy preferences with neighbors and local politicians and then voted for public services that were subsequently implemented. We find that the intervention durably increased participants’ perceptions of government legitimacy. However, contrary to influential models of tax compliance, we report a robust null effect on tax compliance behavior. Participants’ partisan affiliation strongly conditions the treatments’ effects on tax compliance and attitudes toward paying taxes: We find large, positive impacts among copartisans of the incumbent government but significant negative impacts among non copartisans. Our results highlight that the legitimacy gains of participatory interventions may not increase voluntary tax compliance when participation politicizes compliance.
Intervention
The intervention contained three components: (i) digital town halls, (ii) service delivery, (iii) notification calls about delivered services. For more details, see Section 3 of attached PAP.
i. Digital Town Halls (DTH): In this study, DTHs take the form of WhatsApp group chats. Participants were assigned to one of 58 chat groups, where the number of participants in each chat ranged from 17 to 37 (the median chat group size was 24). All participants in a given chat group own property in the same ward. The overarching goal of the DTH is for the group to deliberate and decide over how a budget of 15 million leones (about USD 1,500) should be spent in their ward. The budget allocated to the DTH does not come from FCC tax revenue given (1) the severity of the budget constraint the FCC faces and (2) that the expected increase in property tax revenue will be accrued after the DTHs have taken place. For these reasons, the funds to be decided on are taken from the project's research budget. However, this is not communicated to the DTH audience, allowing the Mayor and (FCC) political representatives to fully claim credit for the participatory budgeting opportunity, which further ensured buy-in to enable our research.
ii. Service Delivery:
Each participating ward received a service project—essentially a local public good both treated and control units in that ward could profit from. Construction began in most wards in October 2021, with the notable exception of one ward (Tengbeh Town) where the FCC needed to provide additional assurances over liability to the delivery company. By the end of 2021 all projects were completed, except the project in Tengbeh Town, which was completed in February of 2022.
iii. Service Delivery Notification Calls:
While our endline survey was conducted after all selected services were successfully delivered, we found it plausible that not all participants would be aware of the completed service project. To address this, we made notification calls on behalf of the FCC to all treated units, informing participants that the project chosen in the DTH had been successfully implemented. Note that by making these notification calls to treated units but not to the control group, we build the notification calls into our treatment.
Experimental design
The unit of randomization is the property owner. To construct our sample frame we draw on FCC administrative records of the universe of taxable properties in Freetown, which contains a set of property characteristics and property owner contact information. To be eligible to participate in the Digital Town Hall a property owner must (i) own a property in one of the 30 study wards and (ii) have WhatsApp on their phone. We were able to complete baseline surveys with 3859 property owners that met this condition. To mitigate spillovers we drew a restricted sample from this set of property owners such that each property is at least 15 meters from the closest study property. The restricted sampling leaves us with fi nal sample of 3619.
We assign treatment status using a matched-pair design, leveraging baseline data to match similar observations into groups of two. We create 1809 pairs and then assign one observation in each matched-pair to treatment and the other to control. We generate matched-pairs using the blockTools package in R. We use the Optimal Greedy (“opt-Greedy”) matching algorithm to find best matches along mahalanobis distance. We implement this randomization in R using the block ra function in the randomizr package.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.