AI as an Agent
How to cite
Innes, Robert; Hua, Tony. 2025. "AI as an Agent." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016811. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16811-1.2
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study examines AI decision-making as an agent in choice experiments with a moral component. Questions of interest are: How are AI decisions affected by (1) posited objectives for AI (extent of representation of one person v. another), (2) the decision frame / game type, (3) observability of AI choices by affected person(s), (4) observability of the choice environment by affected parties, (5) preferences of affected person(s), and (6) whether AI is making a final decision or providing advice to affected parties? Treatments vary in all of these dimensions. Additional data will be collected on human responses to AI v. human advice.
Intervention
AI (ChatGPT 5) will be prompted with choice frameworks that vary along the dimensions indicated in the abstract. AI will decide (or advise a decision) that affects interactions and payoffs between two human individuals (e.g., Sender and Receiver) in a choice experiment. AI will be acting on behalf of one of the two individuals (e.g., Sender) as an agent, but with an objective that may account for effects on the other individual (e.g., Receiver). AI decision responses and justifications will be recorded. With a sample of prompts, inferences will be drawn on effects of different dimensions on AI decisions and associated preferences. For example, in a dictator game, how do prompted objectives favoring the Dictator (v. Receiver) relatively more affect (1) the AI propensity for choosing a fair allocation on behalf of the Dictator and (2) AI's responsiveness to a revealed Dictator preference for a fair (v. selfish) allocation? Similar questions will be examined along the other dimensions of interest in this project.
Experimental design
AI choice environments will be varied in two games with moral components. Treatment variation will include (1) game type, (2) AI decision v. AI advice, (3) information made available to the human parties affected by AI decisions, (4) information on human preferences made available to AI, and (5) the objective posed to AI (e.g., representing one of the human individuals interests). Repeated prompts will generate a profile of AI behavior in each treatment.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.