Experimental Insights into Carbon Policies: Assessing the Environmental and Economic Impacts of Carbon Taxes and Emissions Trading Systems
How to cite
Chuang, Yating; Chen, James Wei; Huang, Shihan. 2025. "Experimental Insights into Carbon Policies: Assessing the Environmental and Economic Impacts of Carbon Taxes and Emissions Trading Systems." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016787. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16787-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This experiment examines how firms adjust production decisions under different environmental policy regimes. Participants are assigned to one of three treatments: a control group with free output choice and emissions information, a carbon tax treatment where firms pay for each unit of emissions, and a carbon trading treatment requiring permits that can be traded in a market. Firms are divided into large and small producers, differing in production capacity and emission intensity. Within the trading treatment, we compare two allocation schemes—grandfathering (permits allocated based on initial endowments) versus equal allocation without grandfathering. Across 12 rounds, participants make output decisions based on marginal costs, policy rules, and market conditions, with real monetary payoffs determined by one randomly selected round. To connect laboratory choices to real-world environmental impact, the organizers purchase real-world carbon offsets based on the lab result. This design links participants’ profit-maximizing strategies directly to tangible carbon outcomes, allowing us to study policy effectiveness, firm heterogeneity, and the role of permit allocation in shaping both market efficiency and environmental results.
Intervention
An economical experiment built on the oTree framework, specifically designed to study the impact of different carbon reduction policies, including carbon trading and carbon tax, on firm production behavior.
Experimental design
This experiment consists of three treatments simulating firms’ production decisions under
different environmental policies.
Group I (Control): firms freely decide output, with information on their carbon emissions.
Group II (Carbon Tax): firms freely decide output but must pay a tax for each unit of emissions, so decisions depend on both production costs and tax costs.
Group III (Carbon Trading): firms need permits to produce and may trade them in a market before deciding output.
Each round, participants choose output based on marginal costs and policy rules, with 12 rounds in total.Firms are divided into large and small producers, differing in production capacity and emission intensity. Initial conditions include allocation of permits and starting capital. At the end, one round is randomly selected for real monetary payment based on profits. To highlight the environmental impact, the experiment
organizers purchase 50 tons of carbon offsets and deduct participants’ emissions, making choices in the lab directly linked to real-world carbon outcomes.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.