Continuous training for workers plays a fundamental role in enabling firms to keep up with technological advancements and the resulting changes in production and organisational processes. This is particularly relevant for craft firms, where training supports adaptation to shifts in the demand for products and services while preserving the quality of products and services. Yet, compared to larger firms, craft firms tend to invest less in training (Kotey & Folker, 2007; Storey, 2004), often underestimating its benefits and overestimating its cost (Barrett & Mayson, 2007; Storey, 2004; Storey & Westhead, 1997). A key policy question is which levers are most effective in encouraging these firms to engage in training activities. Since micro-enterprises and craft businesses typically operate in narrow and competitive local markets, where the innovation capacity is generally limited, the literature shows how they heavily rely on their peers when making important business decisions (McPherson, 1996; Nichter & Goldmark, 2009; Maté-Sánchez Val et al., 2018; Tomelleri & Billé, 2025), and this may also apply to investments in training. In this vein, to test the extent to which craft firms' decisions to participate in training depend on the training activities undertaken by their peers, we run an information treatment experiment. In collaboration with the local Employment Agency (EA) of Trento, located in a highly productive province in Northern Italy, we randomly provide craft firms with accurate information about the training activities undertaken by their peers to evaluate the effect on training decisions. The study contributes to the literature on training behavioural nudges by examining low-cost interventions in the training markets.
Experimental design
Our experimental design follows a stratified four-arm randomised controlled trial (three treatment groups + one control). Experimental details will be available as soon as the trial is over.
Design details
Randomization method
Computer random number generator.
Randomization unit
The randomisation unit is the individual craft firm operating in the province of Trento.
Clusters
No clustering.
Observations
Indicatively 12,000 craft firms (the full universe of craft firms in the province of Trento) obtained from administrative data.
Arms
3 treatment groups (20% of firms each) and 1 control group (40% of firms).
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are:
1. Request for additional information via email (binary, 0/1 – intermediate outcome ).
2. a. Extensive margin: Firm participation in training funded by the local employment agency (binary, 0/1) in the 2025-26 cycle (and potentially onwards); 2b) Intensive margin: number of hours of training funded by the local employment agency (continuous)
3. Qualitative margin: The type of training the firm participates in (technical vs. Soft skills, as well as other potential categorisations to be decided afterwards); whether a firm is more likely to participate in a course that falls within the category of the top 5 courses other firms have benefited from, indicated in the dashboard; 0 otherwise.
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes are:
1. General attitudes toward training: This outcome is captured through a composite index based on seven survey items measuring firms’ perceptions and attitudes toward training. The items cover perceived benefits, costs, and barriers to training (continuous).
2. Total hours of training conducted in the year 2025-2026, besides the one financed through the local employment agency (continuous).
3. Percentage of firms that are aware of at least one incentive and/or subsidy provided by the Employment Agency or directly by the province. In the baseline survey, more than 50% of responding firms reported not being aware of the existence of such funding opportunities.
4. Average training expenditure within the firm, excluding contributions received from the Province or the Employment Agency.
5. Planned increase in training effort (hours and budget): Plans to increase training hours over the next 12–24 months (binary 1/0).
Partners
Name: Agenzia del Lavoro di Trento (Trento Employment Agency).
Partner_type: government
Url: https://www.agenzialavoro.tn.it/
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.