This paper re-examines the classical Allais paradox by exploring how different elicitation methods and choice modes influence its manifestation. Recent research has suggested that observed violations may reflect decision errors or deeper departures from fundamental principles rather than failures of the independence axiom. Building on this line of inquiry, we argue that the implementation of choice tasks themselves may play a critical role in generating paradoxical behavior. Our study investigates whether the paradox is confined to binary choices or whether it extends to alternative elicitation frameworks. We further examine the relationship between task comparability and the consistency of preferences, offering new insights into the mechanisms underlying the paradox and its implications for models of decision-making under risk.
Experimental design
The study investigates whether the Allais paradox is specific to binary choice by comparing behavior across different elicitation methods. Participants make decisions both through portfolio-style and valuation-based tasks, allowing us to test the robustness of the paradox beyond standard binary comparisons. In addition, we vary the comparability of options to examine whether preference consistency depends on the structural similarity of the lotteries being evaluated.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomisation of questions
The lotteries and decision tasks will be presented in the program in random order.
Randomisation of the risky decisions in the experiment
When implementing the real payment of the lottery, the physical device will be used to realise the probability, such as drawing a marble from an opaque bag, or throwing two ten-sided dice.
Randomisation of participants
There will not be any randomisation of the participants. The two experiments are within-subject, so all participants will get the same set of decision questions.
For each participant, the only difference is how the questions are presented, e.g., the order of the questions.
Randomization unit
The experiment is conducted at the individual level, with no clustering or additional levels of randomization.
Clusters
The plan is to conduct the experiment at the Behavioural and Decision Research Lab at Beijing Normal - Hong Kong Baptist University with the student sample and then online via the Prolific platform with a more representative sample.
Observations
500 - 1000 participants in total.
Arms
Not applicable.
Primary outcomes
The Allais paradox is most likely to emerge in binary choice tasks, but becomes less pronounced or disappears when preferences are elicited through alternative methods (e.g., valuation tasks or broader choice formats). This would suggest that the paradox is partly an artifact of the elicitation mode rather than a robust violation of the independence axiom.
Secondary outcomes
According to the comparability hypothesis, preferences will be more consistent in low-comparability tasks (e.g., certainty equivalents where options differ in structure) than in high-comparability tasks (e.g., probability equivalents where options share a similar structure). This would highlight how task comparability shapes decision biases and consistency.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.