Energy Investments – A Discrete Choice Experiment with Manufacturing Executives
How to cite
Blasco, Andrea. 2025. "Energy Investments – A Discrete Choice Experiment with Manufacturing Executives." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016764. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16764-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Understanding CEOs’ preferences, such as risk aversion, environmental values, and time preferences, is critical for designing public incentives schemes (grants, tax rebates, loans) that effectively promote energy efficiency investments. We conducted a phone survey with about 1,000 executives from manufacturing firms in six different EU countries (Germany, Italy, Greece, Portugal, Slovakia, and Malta), evenly split between medium and large firms. Using a discrete choice experiment, we elicit the relative importance of investment attributes (e.g., risk, upfront cost, emissions) and preferences for different incentive mechanisms (varying by funding duration, flexibility, administrative burden). We examine how these preferences interact with firm size and self-reported behavioural traits. Our results provide new insights into how public programs can be designed to foster firms’ competitiveness while fostering energy efficiency.
Intervention
1. Discrete Choice Experiment (DCE)
The DCE has two components:
The first explores Investment decision preferences: CEOs choose between hypothetical investment options (X vs. Y) that vary along four dimensions:
Initial investment cost (€250k–€1m)
Annual savings (€50k–€200k)
Annual emissions reductions (100–500 tons)
Uncertainty of savings (+/– €10k–40k)
The second component aims to elicit Public funding preferences: CEOs choose between hypothetical funding schemes differing on six attributes:
Type of incentive (tax credits, loans, grants)
Maximum support (25–75% of costs)
Administrative burden (low–high)
Flexibility of use (flexible vs. restricted)
Duration (1–6 years)
Environmental goals (none, sustainability, carbon reduction)
To reduce complexity, only 4–6 attributes are used per choice task. Respondents complete two choice scenarios for investments and two for funding schemes. Random assignment into 10 blocks (stratified by firm size) ensures statistical efficiency.
Experimental design
We use algorithms in the EDT package in Python to split respondents into ten blocks. As from the documentation, EDT is a Python-based tool to construct D-efficient designs for DCEs based on the widely used D-efficiency criterion (see Kuhfeld, 2005) but with speed improvements. This approach requires us to set some priors for the model parameters, and a given number of blocks. We decided to do ten blocks, yielding an expectation of 100 respondents per block. Blocks are assigned stratifying by firm size (50 medium 50 large).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.