Can Generative AI help Investors Avoid the Disposition Effect?

How to cite

Livingston, Jeffrey; Rankich, Kobe; Martinez, Maria Adelaida; Aamodt, Adrian; Duane, Ja-Nae; Lauer, David. 2025. "Can Generative AI help Investors Avoid the Disposition Effect?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016753. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16753-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jeffrey Livingston* , Kobe Rankich , Maria Adelaida Martinez , Adrian Aamodt , Ja-Nae Duane , David Lauer

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016753
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16753-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-09-05 – 2025-09-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D9, G4
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16753

Abstract

Beginning with Odean (1998), many studies have shown that investors, professional and otherwise, are often vulnerable to the disposition effect: a tendency to hold on to assets that have declined in value for too long, and to sell assets that have risen in value too early. Weber and Camerer (1998) developed an experimental task to measure the disposition effect where subjects buy and sell assets that have constant but unknown probabilities of going up or down in price from round to round. Previous studies have used this task and have shown that this effect can be mitigated (e.g. Fischbacher et al. 2017), and recent work shows that robo-advisors that have been conditioned to give good advice can be particularly effective (Back et al. 2023).

We conduct an artefactual field experiment with investor subjects recruited from the community of Urvin Finance. Urvin Finance has the following mission statement: "Urvin will truly democratize access to financial data and tools, and provide a unique platform for enabling communities to organize, analyze and publish compelling research and analysis. Urvin will, at all times, seek to serve the underserved, focusing on retail investors around the world, and always putting their interests first. Urvin will also provide comprehensive educational resources, with access to experts, unique content, and always in the most open and accessible way possible." it was co-founded by David Lauer, a co-author on this project.

We follow a similar strategy to that of Back et al. (2023). We study whether ChatGPT can help investors avoid the disposition effect in a version of the Weber and Camerer 91998) task. Subjects are randomized into one of three treatment groups: 1) Control, which simply does the task as normal; 2) Treatment No Prompt, in which subjects have access to a ChatGPT window and can ask it anything they want; or 3) Treatment Prompt, which also gives access to ChatGPT and pre-enters prompts that explain the details of the game and update it with the new situation after each round.

Intervention

we use a version of the Weber and Camerer (1998) task to measure the disposition effect where subjects buy and sell six assets that have constant but unknown probabilities of going up in price by 6% or down in price by 5% in each round over 14 rounds. The probabilities of increasing in price range from 40% to 60%. Subjects have $2000 in experimental currency to invest in shares of the six assets. The price of a share of each asset starts at $100 in round 1, then evolves according to pre-generated price paths that are simulated according to the assigned probabilities.

We follow a similar strategy to that of Back et al. (2023). We study whether ChatGPT can help investors avoid the disposition effect in a version of the Weber and Camerer (1998) task. Subjects are randomized into one of three treatment groups: 1) Control, which simply does the task as normal; 2) Treatment No Prompt, in which subjects have access to a ChatGPT window and can ask it anything they want; or 3) Treatment Prompt, which also gives access to ChatGPT and pre-enters prompts that explain the details of the game and update it with the new situation after each round.

Experimental design

Subjects are randomized into one of three treatment groups: 1) Control, which simply does the task as normal; 2) Treatment No Prompt, in which subjects have access to a ChatGPT window and can ask it anything they want; or 3) Treatment Prompt, which also gives access to ChatGPT and pre-enters prompts that explain the details of the game and update it with the new situation after each round.

Design details

Randomization method
We use a randomization procedure and design that is similar to that of Back, Morana, and Spann (2023). We generate 98 sets of price paths for the randomization by first randomizing the type of each asset, then randomizing a price path for each asset (according to the asset’s assigned probability of increasing in price) across the 14 rounds. The subjects are recruited from the community of Urvin Finance, members of which are day traders and/or individuals interested in investing in the stock market. They are recruited by email announcements and social media postings, so they show up to participate in the experiment not all at once but rather at different times of their choosing. We first randomly assign each show up position (the first to begin the experiment is position 1, the next person to start is position 2, etc.) to a group of 3, then within each group, randomize each of the three subjects to one of the three treatment groups. Then, each group is randomly assigned to one of the 98 price paths.
Randomization unit
individual
Clusters
n/a, though there are 98 possible price paths that the subjects might face and 3 subjects are randomly assigned to each one, then the three subjects are randomized within each price path group to the treatment conditions.
Observations
294
Arms
98
Primary outcomes
The disposition effect measure, which is the proportion of gains realized - the proportion of losses realized. See our pre-analysis plan and/or Back et al. (2023) for more details.
Secondary outcomes
o Proportion of Losses Realized o Proportion of Gains Realized o Profit/Loss o Shares invested in risky assets o Shares invested in the highest priced asset o Shares invested in the lowest priced asset

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords