Quality premium transmission and quality upgrading – evidence from Ugandan dairy value chains

How to cite

Campenhout, Bjorn Van; Byarugaba, Benon; Kariuki, Sarah Wairimu; Chamberlin, Jordan; Ariong, Richard; Atuha, Dennis. 2025. "Quality premium transmission and quality upgrading – evidence from Ugandan dairy value chains." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016750. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16750-4.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Bjorn Van Campenhout* , Benon Byarugaba , Sarah Wairimu Kariuki , Jordan Chamberlin , Richard Ariong , Dennis Atuha

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016750
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16750-4.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2025-09-14 – 2026-01-01
Countries
Uganda (southwestern region)
JEL codes
O13, Q13, L15, D82, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16750

Abstract

Abstract We study whether quality premiums at milk collection centers can transmit incentives upstream and upgrade compositional milk quality in Ugandan dairy value chains. Building on prior work that installed approximately 150 milk analyzers and raised testing without consistent quality-based price differentiation, we partner with MCCs and small processors to randomize trader eligibility for a per-liter quality premium tied to butterfat and solids-non-fat. Randomization occurs at the trader level with blocking by MCC or processor. The primary trader outcome is an Anderson index of compositional quality measured by analyzers during deliveries in the final study week. The primary farmer outcome is the volume-weighted farmgate price from the last three sales, used to assess pass-through. Secondary trader outcomes cover prices received from MCCs, prices paid to farmers, sourcing practices, and trading intensity and allocations. Secondary farmer outcomes include production investment and management practices, post-milking handling and cooling, and marketing allocation and payment terms.

Intervention

We partner with milk collection centers (MCCs) and processors to introduce a randomized quality premium for traders who aggregate raw milk from smallholders and deliver to MCCs. Traders are randomly assigned within MCC or processor blocks to treatment or control. Treated traders are eligible for a per liter bonus tied to compositional quality measured at intake with milk analyzers. A baseline threshold is set for butterfat and solids non fat (SNF). For every 0.1 percentage point above the threshold in either component, the trader earns UGX 10 per liter. Premiums are additive across butterfat and SNF. No penalties apply below the threshold. Payments are recorded in an app and settled by the MCC on the usual payment cycle. The intervention runs for one month, with daily analyzer testing at intake, calibration checks using a reference analyzer, and light touch monitoring of adherence. Control traders deliver under business as usual pricing.

Experimental design

We evaluate whether downstream quality premiums transmit incentives upstream in Ugandan dairy value chains. The unit of randomization is the trader who aggregates milk from smallholders and delivers to a milk collection center (MCC) or small processor. Traders are randomly assigned within MCC or processor blocks to treatment or control with approximately equal allocation. Treated traders are eligible for a per liter bonus tied to compositional quality measured at intake by milk analyzers. A threshold is set for butterfat and solids-non-fat; for each 0.1 percentage point above the threshold in either component, a UGX 10 bonus is paid. Premiums across components are additive. Control traders operate under business-as-usual pricing. The intervention runs for about one month, with analyzer readings recorded in an app and payments settled on the usual cycle.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization is done in the field by the ODK software on a tablet computer
Randomization unit
the intervention is randomized within MCCs at the trader level, which also leads to cluster assignment at the farmer level
Clusters
100 traders
Observations
100 trader and 5 farmers per trader (so 500 farmers)
Arms
50 traders and 250 farmers connected to 50 treated traders
Primary outcomes
at trader level: compositional milk quality (index); at farmer level: milk price
Secondary outcomes
Trader level: prices and pass-through (prices received from MCC and prices paid to farmers), sourcing practices (field testing, acceptance thresholds, pickup rejections), trading intensity and allocations (volumes, delivery frequency, seller concentration) - Farmer level: production investment and feeding practices, sourcing practices, trading intensity and allocations

Materials

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords