Employment Retention and Advancement Project--Texas Site
How to cite
Hamilton, Gayle; Hendra, Richard. 2016. "Employment Retention and Advancement Project--Texas Site." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001674. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1674-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The federal welfare overhaul of 1996 ushered in myriad policy changes aimed at getting low-income parents off public assistance and into employment. These changes--especially cash welfare's transformation from an entitlement into a time-limited benefit contingent on work participation--have intensified the need to help low-income families become economically self-sufficient and remain so in the long term. Although a fair amount is known about how to help welfare recipients prepare for and find jobs in the first place, the Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) project was a comprehensive effort to discover what approaches help--and do not help--welfare recipients and other low-income people stay steadily employed and advance in their jobs. The ERA project, which tested 15 programs around the country, was conducted by MDRC, under contract to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, with additional funding from the U.S. Department of Labor.
In this part of the study, a program in Texas aimed to promote job placement, employment retention, and advancement among applicants and recipients in the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program. To encourage employment retention and advancement among working TANF leavers, the Texas ERA program provided job search assistance, pre- and postemployment case management, and a monthly stipend of $200 to individuals who retained their jobs. The program was evaluated in three Texas sites--Corpus Christi, Fort Worth, and Houston--starting in 2000. Using random assignment, eligible individuals were assigned either to a program group, whose members participated in the ERA program, or to a control group, whose members participated in Texas's standard welfare-to-work program (called "Choices"). Employment and earnings data (as well as other data) were collected for individuals in both groups (n=4,288) over a four-year post-random assignment period. A comparison of the outcomes for the two groups indicates the effectiveness of the Texas ERA program.
Texas ERA findings at a glance:
--Served unemployed TANF applicants and recipients
--Provided a financial incentive for employment retention for those leaving TANF for work, coupled with job search assistance and postemployment services (including reemployment assistance and visits to working clients at their employer's site)
--Was well implemented in Corpus Christi but experienced some operational difficulties in Fort Worth and, particularly, in Houston
--Compared with the control group, programmatic differences related mostly to the postemployment services and the financial incentive (preemployment services were similar for the two research groups)
--Resulted in 30 percent receiving the financial incentive in Corpus Christi and approximately 20 percent doing so in the two other Texas sites
--Produced consistent impacts on employment retention and advancement outcomes in Corpus Christi, less consistent impacts in Fort Worth, and no impacts in Houston -- over a four-year follow-up period
--In Corpus Christi, the ERA program increased average annual earnings by $640, or by 15% of control group earnings, over the four-year follow-up period. The ERA program in Corpus Christi produced gains in earnings through the end of the four-year period, even after program group members would have lost eligibility for the stipends and services. In fact, the Corpus Christi program had its largest effect on earnings in the fourth year, suggesting the possibility that the program may have produced to even longer-term gains.
Intervention
The Texas ERA program was designed to provide both pre- and postemployment services to TANF applicants and recipients. As designed, the program had three key features:
1. Preemployment job search and team-based case management services. For most participants, the ERA program initially provided job search, job readiness, and case management services. Texas began case management services at the preemployment stage and used a team-based approach. The goal was to involve partners from multiple agencies (including the Texas Department of Human Services [DHS], local workforce staff, and organizations working to prevent substance abuse or domestic violence) that had expertise in addressing specific employment-related barriers. Key case management services included employment assessment, goal setting and career planning, support services, resolution of employment barriers, and job search assistance.
2. Stipend for welfare leavers. The ERA program provided monthly stipends of $200 per month to participants who had left TANF, were employed for a minimum of 30 hours per week, and participated in a postemployment "advancement" activity. The stipend was also available to those who combined 15 hours a week of employment with an education and training activity that lasted 15 hours per week. The stipend was available after a four-month earned income disregard, whereby 90 percent of earnings were disregarded in calculating the TANF grant. Individuals could receive the earned income disregard once in a 12-month period (but the four months did not have to be used consecutively within this time period). There was a lifetime limit of 12 stipends (stipends also did not have to be used in consecutive months). The stipend was included in the ERA model based on other studies that found earnings supplements to be effective in encouraging employment and increasing earnings.
3. Intensive postemployment services. The ERA program provided a comprehensive set of postemployment services, which could include assistance with job-related problems and support services, monitoring job performance and issues through regular site visits to employers, rapid reemployment assistance for participants who lost jobs, and support in meeting the requirements of the stipend. ERA postemployment services could continue for as long as an individual was eligible for the stipend.
Program entry: Immediately following an eligibility or recertification interview for TANF (but, in the case of applicants, before they were approved for cash assistance), individuals were randomly assigned either to the ERA program or to the Choices program. Those who were assigned to ERA were introduced to the program and, then, once recertified or approved for TANF, they were engaged in ERA program services. Individuals who were not approved for TANF were not eligible for the ERA program.
Participation in the ERA program was mandatory for most individuals, meaning they faced a reduction of termination of TANF benefits for noncompliance with program rules. Some individuals were not required to participate and did not face sanctions for noncompliance--this is known as being "exempt"--if they had a child younger than age 1, were ill or disabled, or were caring for a disabled family member. Exempt individuals were eligible for all components of the ERA program, and program staff strongly encouraged them to participate.
Once randomly assigned to the ERA program, individuals completed an assessment; then they generally participated in job search and, if they did not find a job, community service (a volunteer position in a nonprofit or public organization) and also received case management services. Once participants were employed, they received postemployment services, and--after leaving TANF and after receiving the earned income disregard--they became eligible for the monthly stipend.
Experimental design
The random assignment process began in November 2000 in Corpus Christi and Fort Worth and in March 2001 in Houston. Random assignment ended in all the Texas sites in December 2002, and the ERA program ended in August 2004. Thus, the amount of time that sample members could potentially be exposed to the ERA program ranged from 20 months to 46 months, depending on when they were randomly assigned. However, it is unlikely that participants would be engaged in ERA for as long as 46 months.
When a TANF applicant or recipient met with a DHS staff person to complete an eligibility or recertification interview, staff referred those who they believed would be certified (or recertified) for TANF to ERA evaluation random assignment. After staff completed baseline paperwork for each individual--recording such standard client characteristics as educational background and welfare history--individuals were randomly assigned to either the ERA or the Choices (control) group.
Both ERA and control group members were assigned to attend a workforce orientation, which was required in order to be certified for TANF. (Individuals who did not attend the orientation could not receive TANF or participate in either ERA or Choices.) The sites operated separate orientations for ERA and Choices, and the content reflected the differences in the programs. As in all welfare-to-work programs, many individuals who were referred to ERA or to Choices did not attend a workforce orientation or a program activity--some found employment on their own; some were not approved for receiving TANF; and some chose not to participate in program services (thereby facing possible sanctions).
Members of the control group were not eligible for ERA services and were assigned to participate in Choices, the state's standard welfare-to-work program. Although Choices also provided pre- and postemployment services to TANF recipients, there were important differences between the two programs, particularly in terms of postemployment services:
--Preemployment services. These services were similar under both programs. As in ERA, individuals who were assigned to Choices completed an assessment and participated in job search or--if they did not find employment--community service. Choices also provided case management services, but these generally did not involve multiple agencies and focused less on longer-term career planning. Like ERA, Choices services were mandatory for most TANF recipients, although the program encouraged those who were exempt to participate as well.
--Postemployment services. Choices participants were not eligible for the monthly $200 stipend. Once employed, however, they were eligible for the earned income disregard for four months (for the same amount as in the ERA program). In Choices, postemployment case management services generally lasted only for the duration of the earnings disregard, whereas services continued for up to an additional 12 months in ERA, for those who were receiving the stipend. Postemployment services in Choices were also less intensive--consisting primarily of monthly contacts with participants to verify employment status. Members of both groups were eligible for transitional child care subsidies once they left TANF after receiving the earned income disregard. (While receiving the disregard, individuals continued to receive child care through TANF.)
Because of the job search and case management services, participation requirement, and support services, the control group in the ERA evaluation received a relatively strong set of services.
Design details
Materials
Papers from this trial
- Hamilton, Gayle, and Susan Scrivener. 2012. Increasing Employment Stability and Earnings for Low-Wage Worker: Lessons from the Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) Project. OPRE Report 2012-19, Washington, DC: Office of Planning, Research and Evaluation, Administration for Children and Families, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. http://www.mdrc.org/sites/default/files/Increasing%20Employment%20Stability%20and%20Earnings%20FR.pdf
- Hendra, Richard, Keri-Nicole Dillman, Gayle Hamilton, Erika Lundquist, Karin Martinson, and Melissa Wavelet. 2010. How Effective Are Different Approaches Aiming to Increase Employment Retention and Advancement? Final Impacts for Twelve Models. New York: MDRC. http://www.mdrc.org/publication/how-effective-are-different-approaches-aiming-increase-employment-retention-and
- Martinson, Karin, and Richard Hendra. 2006. [Two-Year] Results from the Texas Site in the Employment Retention and Advancement Project. New York: MDRC. http://www.mdrc.org/publication/results-texas-site-employment-retention-and-advancement-project
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.