Sports Buddies: How peer feedback shapes exercise commitment

How to cite

Dadic, Hana; Kaeser, Michèle; Hafner, Danièle. 2025. "Sports Buddies: How peer feedback shapes exercise commitment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016689. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16689-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Hana Dadic* , Michèle Kaeser , Danièle Hafner

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016689
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16689-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-09-10 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16689

Abstract

This project examines how the source of motivational feedback – whether selected by a peer or a computer – affects individuals' exercise levels. We plan to conduct a framed field experiment in collaboration with a Swiss university sports facility. Participants will sign up individually, set their weekly exercise goal (in number of sports facility visits), and will then be randomly matched with another participant with the same exercise goal, who will be their “sports buddy” for the remainder of the study (Gershon et al., 2024). After each week, all participants will receive descriptive feedback about their own and their buddy’s goal achievement. The control group receives no additional motivational feedback, while two treatment groups receive motivational messages from a predefined set of quotes (Moreno-Jaimes & Meza, 2020). In one treatment, the quotes are randomly selected by a computer, while in the other, they are chosen by the participant’s buddy. By systematically varying the source of feedback, we assess whether peer-driven motivation is better at supporting goal achievement than computer-based motivation. Our study offers relevant insights for practice, as it shows how digital fitness apps, workplace wellness programs, and health interventions can leverage social accountability as a cost-effective behavioral tool to improve adherence to exercise goals.

Intervention

We will implement two experimental conditions and one control condition:
• Control condition: Participants receive descriptive information on their own and their buddy’s goal achievement.
• Automatic Feedback Treatment: Like the control condition, but participants also receive motivational feedback randomly selected by a computer.
• Peer Feedback Treatment: Like the control condition, but participants also receive motivational feedback selected by their buddy.

Experimental design

We will conduct a framed field experiment in collaboration with a Swiss university sports facility to investigate how different sources of motivational feedback – selected by a peer or a computer – affect individuals' exercise levels. Participants’ visits to the sports facilities will be measured through check-in-tools implemented for this study. Each sports visit will count towards a lottery where participants can win vouchers after the study is completed. Only participants who complete all three surveys will be eligible for the draw of the prize winners.

The experiment will proceed as follows:
• Before study:
- Participants will be recruited through various online and offline marketing channels.
- Interested participants can sign up for the study during the recruiting phase via an online registration form (will include study information, social image concerns, motivation to attend Unisport activities, sports activity questions, demographics, informed consent).
- After recruiting is closed, buddy dyads will be randomly formed based on the same self-set goals, and then randomly assigned to one of the treatments. Afterwards, participants will be informed about their assigned buddy and asked to complete a buddy survey (will include IOS scale and question on buddy familiarity).

• During study:
- Pre-intervention: All participants will receive a weekly WhatsApp message including descriptive information on their own and their buddy’s goal achievement
- Intervention: In addition to the message with descriptive information, participants will receive the following second WhatsApp message:
- Control condition: Filler information
- Automatic Feedback Treatment: Filler information + feedback randomly selected by a computer.
- Peer Feedback Treatment: Filler information + feedback randomly selected by their buddy.
- After the final WhatsApp message of the intervention, participants will be asked to complete the closing survey, which will assess social image concerns, the Other in the Self (IOS) 11 Scale, motivation to attend Unisport activities along with a range of control variables, such as failure aversion, academic workload during the study, and types of activities most frequently attended.
- Post-intervention (4 weeks): Participants do not receive any WhatsApp messages anymore, but each sports facility visit still counts towards the prize draw.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer
Randomization unit
Buddy dyad
Clusters
Our minimum number of clusters is 105 buddy dyads. The final number of clusters will be determined by recruiting as many participants as possible during the recruitment period.
Observations
Our minimum sample size for recruiting is at least 210 participants (i.e., 105 buddy dyads). The sample size will be determined by recruiting as many participants as possible during the recruitment period. We will exclude subjects: - Who cannot be matched with a buddy at the start of the study. - Who miss confirming the first WhatsApp message before the start of the study. - (For Peer Feedback only): Whose buddy fails to select a feedback quote more than twice.
Arms
For each of the three treatments: Minimum 70 participants (i.e., 35 buddy dyads).
Primary outcomes
Number of sports facility visits per week (max. 1 per day), goal attainment
Secondary outcomes
Social image concerns, Other in the Self (IOS) 11 Scale, Motivation to attend Unisport activities

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords