Misperceived Workplace Norms in Japan

How to cite

Kamei, Kenju; Nishihata, Masaya; Tyran, Jean-Robert. 2025. "Misperceived Workplace Norms in Japan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016654. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16654-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Kenju Kamei* , Masaya Nishihata , Jean-Robert Tyran

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016654
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16654-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-09-11 – 2025-09-29
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, D83, D91, J22, J81
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16654

Abstract

Japanese workers are widely recognized for working long hours, experiencing high stress, and reporting relatively low levels of happiness. We conduct an online survey of workers at large firms to examine whether they misperceive (i) existing workplace norms and (ii) the extent of demand for change within the workforce. We then test whether providing information about actual norms—and thereby correcting potential misperceptions—encourages employees to take action toward shifting workplace practices. We also conduct a heterogeneity analysis with particular attention to gender differences.

Intervention

We will use the average responses from Wave 1 to do a randomized information intervention in Wave 2. The details of the intervention are explained in Experimental Design section below.

Experimental design

This study involves a two-wave survey targeting workers aged 18 to 69 who work as regular employees at large-sized firms in Japan. In Wave 1, workplace norms are elicited from them, and in Wave 2, another set of workers guesses the norms. The details will be summarized as follows:

A. Conducting Survey:
In Wave 1, we will survey 1,000 gender-representative regular employees at large-sized firms in Japan. Participants will be asked whether they agree that workplace norms in Japan are toxic. They will also be asked whether they agree that actions urgently need to be taken to improve workplace norms.
In Wave 2, we will recruit a different set of 4,000 regular employees at large-sized firms and ask them the same two questions. In addition, we ask them to guess the percentage of workers who agreed with each statement in Wave 1. These guesses are incentivized. Upon answering the questions, half of the employees (Treatment) will receive the actual results from Wave 1. The other half of the employees (Control) will not receive this information.
The remainder of the experiment in Wave 2 is identical to both the treatment and control groups: they will be asked about their beliefs, intentions, and actions related to workplace norms, including their willingness to take action to change the workplace practices.

B. Exclusion criteria for fraud answer/outliers:
Participants will be excluded from the analysis based on survey completion times, variability in responses to matrix-form questions, and implausible responses (e.g., reported age outside the eligible range).

C. Hypotheses:
H1: Pluralistic ignorance exists regarding (a) workers’ perceptions about toxic workplace norms and (b) demand for changes in Japan.
H1’: The degree of pluralistic ignorance differs by gender.
H2: Providing information about others’ actual opinions breaks the pluralistic ignorance, i.e., increases (i) their tendency to evaluate toxic workplace behaviors as inappropriate, and/or (ii) their willingness to take action to change such norms.
H2’: The effects of information intervention differ by gender.

Design details

Randomization method
Three types of randomization are employed. (1) Treatment vs. control assignment: Participants are randomly allocated by the survey company through separate survey URLs, with the assignment intended to achieve a 50/50 split. (2) Question order randomization: To control for order effects, the order of certain survey questions is randomized using SurveyMonkey’s built-in randomization function, which assigns question order probabilistically with equal chance. (3) Bonus allocation: As an incentive, a certain number of workers will be randomly given money (points). For questions involving the bonus eligibility, assignment to “bonus winner” vs. “non-winner” is conducted in two ways: (a) by distributing separate URLs to participants so that a pre-specified number of respondents are designated as winners, and (b) for specific subgroups (e.g., respondents providing certain answers), winners are selected using random number generation in R.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization in all cases is the individual respondent.
Clusters
4,000 individuals (survey respondents) This is the number of participants in Wave 2 of the survey.
Observations
4,000 individuals (survey respondents)
Arms
Control group: 2,000 individuals (1,000 male and 1,000 female) Treatment group: 2,000 individuals (1,000 male and 1,000 female)
Primary outcomes
In Wave 1, participants will be asked whether they agree that workplace norms in Japan are toxic. They will also be asked whether they agree that actions urgently need to be taken to improve workplace norms (see the Experimental Design section). In Wave 2, different participants guess the percentage of workers in Wave 1 who agreed with each statement. Their guessed agreement rates are the key outcome variables. The primary test is whether these perceived agreement rates differ significantly from the actual agreement rates seen in Wave 1, i.e., thereby testing whether pluralistic ignorance exists. Analysis method: (a) Descriptive analysis and statistical tests (including both non-parametric and parametric tests, as appropriate). (b) Regression analysis to test whether misperception differs by gender while also including other controls.
Secondary outcomes
We will measure the following outcomes in Wave 2 (binary or four-point scales) and compare them between the treatment and control groups to investigate effects of the information intervention: 1. Actions and intentions related to addressing toxic workplace norms and job search. 2. Attitudes toward family/childcare initiatives (“Kurumin certification” and “Eruboshi certification”). 3. Knowledge/attitudes regarding Japan’s “Work Style Reform Related Laws.” 4. Support for actions to address toxic workplace norms. 5. Perceived social appropriateness of specific workplace behaviors (following Krupka & Weber 2013). Analysis Method: (a) Descriptive analysis and statistical tests: We will perform both non-parametric and parametric tests, as appropriate, to summarize and compare the key features of the data. (b) Regression analysis: We regress each outcome variable on the treatment indicator and other covariates, including interaction terms between the treatment and selected variables in certain specifications. (c) Robustness check: We will assess the robustness of our findings by including additional control variables.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords