Nudges and the Malleability of Identity: Evidence from Religiosity
How to cite
Megalokonomou, Rigissa; Sartori, Tommaso; Dioikitopoulos, Evangelos. 2025. "Nudges and the Malleability of Identity: Evidence from Religiosity." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016648. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16648-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We will test whether brief prosocial messages framed in religious or scientific language change how adults describe their religiosity. Volunteers are randomly assigned to a religious message, a scientific message, or no message. We then compare average self-reported religiosity across groups. The study is anonymous, minimal risk, and aims to show whether everyday language can subtly shape personal identity, such as religiosity.
Intervention
Religious prosocial message (treatment A).
Participants read a very brief text (≈90–120 words) promoting prosocial behavior using religious language (e.g., references to kindness/charity and a general biblical principle such as treating others well). The message is neutral in tone (non-coercive, non-evaluative), does not ask participants to change beliefs, and contains no doctrinal content beyond the framing.
Scientific prosocial message (treatment B).
Participants read a closely matched text (≈90–120 words) promoting the same prosocial theme but using scientific/psychology language (e.g., research suggests helping others benefits well-being and communities). Length, reading level, and structure are matched to the religious message; only the framing differs.
Control (no message).
Participants proceed directly to the questionnaires with no message exposure.
Experimental design
Design: Parallel-arm, between-subjects randomized controlled trial conducted online. Participants are randomly assigned (1:1:1) to one of three arms at the start of the survey: (A) a brief prosocial message framed in religious language; (B) a closely matched prosocial message framed in scientific/psychology language; or (C) no message (control). Messages are similar in length and readability; only the framing differs. No deception is used.
Eligibility & setting: Adults (18+) completing a single session on a standard survey platform. Participation is anonymous and voluntary; respondents may skip some questions.
Timing & flow: After consent, the assigned message (or no message) is shown on its own screen. Immediately afterward, participants complete the outcome measures.
Primary outcome (confirmatory): Self-reported religiosity (0–10 scale; 0 = not at all religious, 10 = very religious), measured immediately after the intervention.
Secondary/exploratory outcomes (public summary): A small set of related attitudes/behaviors (e.g., importance of God, prayer desire frequency, simple belief items).
Randomization & masking: Assignment is automated by the survey platform’s randomizer. Participants are unaware of the existence/content of alternative messages.
Analysis (high-level): Intent-to-treat comparisons of group means using two-sided tests at α = 0.05. The primary confirmatory contrast is Scientific vs. Control; Religious vs. Control is secondary. Exploratory outcomes will be analyzed with appropriate multiple-comparison safeguards.
Exposure/quality controls (summary): Minimum on-screen time for the message and a simple attention check are used to encourage exposure and data quality. Any exclusion criteria are prespecified elsewhere in the preregistration.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.